是否可以在ES6类中创建私有属性?

举个例子。 如何阻止访问instance.property?

class Something {
  constructor(){
    this.property = "test";
  }
}

var instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"

当前回答

更新:一个语法更好的提案正在酝酿中。欢迎投稿。


是的,对于对象的作用域访问,ES6引入了符号。

符号是唯一的,你不能从外部访问一个,除非通过反射(就像Java/ c#中的私有),但任何有权访问内部符号的人都可以使用它进行键访问:

var property = Symbol();
class Something {
    constructor(){
        this[property] = "test";
    }
}

var instance = new Something();

console.log(instance.property); //=> undefined, can only access with access to the Symbol

其他回答

大多数答案要么说不可能,要么要求你使用WeakMap或Symbol,这是ES6的特性,可能需要腻子。然而,还有另一种方法!看看这个:

// 1. Create closure var SomeClass = function() { // 2. Create `key` inside a closure var key = {}; // Function to create private storage var private = function() { var obj = {}; // return Function to access private storage using `key` return function(testkey) { if(key === testkey) return obj; // If `key` is wrong, then storage cannot be accessed console.error('Cannot access private properties'); return undefined; }; }; var SomeClass = function() { // 3. Create private storage this._ = private(); // 4. Access private storage using the `key` this._(key).priv_prop = 200; }; SomeClass.prototype.test = function() { console.log(this._(key).priv_prop); // Using property from prototype }; return SomeClass; }(); // Can access private property from within prototype var instance = new SomeClass(); instance.test(); // `200` logged // Cannot access private property from outside of the closure var wrong_key = {}; instance._(wrong_key); // undefined; error logged

我称这个方法为accessor pattern。基本思想是我们有一个闭包,闭包中有一个键,我们创建一个私有对象(在构造函数中),只有当你拥有键时才能访问它。

如果你感兴趣,你可以在我的文章中阅读更多有关这方面的内容。使用此方法,可以为每个对象创建不能在闭包外部访问的属性。因此,你可以在构造函数或原型中使用它们,但不能在其他任何地方使用。我还没有在任何地方见过这种方法,但我认为它真的很强大。

甚至Typescript也做不到。从他们的文档来看:

当成员被标记为private时,就不能从其包含类的外部访问它。例如: 动物类{ 私有名称:字符串; 构造函数(名称:字符串){this.name =名称;} } 新的动物(猫). name;//错误:'name'是private;

但在他们的操场上,这说明:

var Animal = (function () {
    function Animal(theName) {
        this.name = theName;
    }
    return Animal;
}());
console.log(new Animal("Cat").name);

所以他们的“私人”关键字是无效的。

不同的“私人”方式

Instead of fighting against the fact that private visibility is currently unavailable in ES6, I decided to take a more practical approach that does just fine if your IDE supports JSDoc (e.g., Webstorm). The idea is to use the @private tag. As far as development goes, the IDE will prevent you from accessing any private member from outside its class. Works pretty well for me and it's been really useful for hiding internal methods so the auto-complete feature shows me just what the class really meant to expose. Here's an example:

我现在听到的建议是使用WeakMaps来保存私人数据,以供其他看客参考。

下面是一个更清晰、有效的例子:

function storePrivateProperties(a, b, c, d) {
  let privateData = new WeakMap;
  // unique object as key, weak map can only accept object as key, when key is no longer referened, garbage collector claims the key-value 
  let keyA = {}, keyB = {}, keyC = {}, keyD = {};

  privateData.set(keyA, a);
  privateData.set(keyB, b);
  privateData.set(keyC, c);
  privateData.set(keyD, d);

  return {
    logPrivateKey(key) {
      switch(key) {
      case "a":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyA));
        break;
      case "b":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyB));
        break;
      case "c":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyC));
        break;
      case "d":
        console.log(privateData.set(keyD));
        break;
      default:
        console.log(`There is no value for ${key}`)
      }
    }
  }
}

更新:看别人的回答,这个已经过时了。

简单的回答,不,ES6类不支持私有属性。

但是你可以模仿这种行为,不将新属性附加到对象,而是将它们保存在类构造函数中,并使用getter和setter来获取隐藏的属性。注意,在类的每个新实例上重新定义getter和setter。

ES6

class Person {
    constructor(name) {
        var _name = name
        this.setName = function(name) { _name = name; }
        this.getName = function() { return _name; }
    }
}

ES5

function Person(name) {
    var _name = name
    this.setName = function(name) { _name = name; }
    this.getName = function() { return _name; }
}