我相信有一种方法可以找到长度为n的O(n)无序数组中第k大的元素。也可能是期望O(n)之类的。我们该怎么做呢?


当前回答

这是一个Javascript实现。

如果您释放了不能修改数组的约束,则可以使用两个索引来标识“当前分区”(经典快速排序样式- http://www.nczonline.net/blog/2012/11/27/computer-science-in-javascript-quicksort/)来防止使用额外的内存。

function kthMax(a, k){
    var size = a.length;

    var pivot = a[ parseInt(Math.random()*size) ]; //Another choice could have been (size / 2) 

    //Create an array with all element lower than the pivot and an array with all element higher than the pivot
    var i, lowerArray = [], upperArray = [];
    for (i = 0; i  < size; i++){
        var current = a[i];

        if (current < pivot) {
            lowerArray.push(current);
        } else if (current > pivot) {
            upperArray.push(current);
        }
    }

    //Which one should I continue with?
    if(k <= upperArray.length) {
        //Upper
        return kthMax(upperArray, k);
    } else {
        var newK = k - (size - lowerArray.length);

        if (newK > 0) {
            ///Lower
            return kthMax(lowerArray, newK);
        } else {
            //None ... it's the current pivot!
            return pivot;
        }   
    }
}  

如果你想测试它的表现,你可以使用这个变量:

    function kthMax (a, k, logging) {
         var comparisonCount = 0; //Number of comparison that the algorithm uses
         var memoryCount = 0;     //Number of integers in memory that the algorithm uses
         var _log = logging;

         if(k < 0 || k >= a.length) {
            if (_log) console.log ("k is out of range"); 
            return false;
         }      

         function _kthmax(a, k){
             var size = a.length;
             var pivot = a[parseInt(Math.random()*size)];
             if(_log) console.log("Inputs:", a,  "size="+size, "k="+k, "pivot="+pivot);

             // This should never happen. Just a nice check in this exercise
             // if you are playing with the code to avoid never ending recursion            
             if(typeof pivot === "undefined") {
                 if (_log) console.log ("Ops..."); 
                 return false;
             }

             var i, lowerArray = [], upperArray = [];
             for (i = 0; i  < size; i++){
                 var current = a[i];
                 if (current < pivot) {
                     comparisonCount += 1;
                     memoryCount++;
                     lowerArray.push(current);
                 } else if (current > pivot) {
                     comparisonCount += 2;
                     memoryCount++;
                     upperArray.push(current);
                 }
             }
             if(_log) console.log("Pivoting:",lowerArray, "*"+pivot+"*", upperArray);

             if(k <= upperArray.length) {
                 comparisonCount += 1;
                 return _kthmax(upperArray, k);
             } else if (k > size - lowerArray.length) {
                 comparisonCount += 2;
                 return _kthmax(lowerArray, k - (size - lowerArray.length));
             } else {
                 comparisonCount += 2;
                 return pivot;
             }
     /* 
      * BTW, this is the logic for kthMin if we want to implement that... ;-)
      * 

             if(k <= lowerArray.length) {
                 return kthMin(lowerArray, k);
             } else if (k > size - upperArray.length) {
                 return kthMin(upperArray, k - (size - upperArray.length));
             } else 
                 return pivot;
     */            
         }

         var result = _kthmax(a, k);
         return {result: result, iterations: comparisonCount, memory: memoryCount};
     }

剩下的代码只是创建一些游乐场:

    function getRandomArray (n){
        var ar = [];
        for (var i = 0, l = n; i < l; i++) {
            ar.push(Math.round(Math.random() * l))
        }

        return ar;
    }

    //Create a random array of 50 numbers
    var ar = getRandomArray (50);   

现在给你做几次测试。 因为Math.random()每次都会产生不同的结果:

    kthMax(ar, 2, true);
    kthMax(ar, 2);
    kthMax(ar, 2);
    kthMax(ar, 2);
    kthMax(ar, 2);
    kthMax(ar, 2);
    kthMax(ar, 34, true);
    kthMax(ar, 34);
    kthMax(ar, 34);
    kthMax(ar, 34);
    kthMax(ar, 34);
    kthMax(ar, 34);

如果你测试它几次,你甚至可以看到经验的迭代次数,平均来说,O(n) ~=常数* n, k的值不会影响算法。

其他回答

c++标准库几乎完全有这个函数调用nth_element,尽管它确实会修改数据。它有线性运行时间,O(N),它也做部分排序。

const int N = ...;
double a[N];
// ... 
const int m = ...; // m < N
nth_element (a, a + m, a + N);
// a[m] contains the mth element in a

这叫做求k阶统计量。有一个非常简单的随机算法(叫做quickselect),平均时间为O(n),最坏情况时间为O(n²),还有一个相当复杂的非随机算法(叫做introselect),最坏情况时间为O(n)。维基百科上有一些信息,但不是很好。

你需要的一切都在这些幻灯片里。只需提取O(n)最坏情况算法(introselect)的基本算法:

Select(A,n,i):
    Divide input into ⌈n/5⌉ groups of size 5.

    /* Partition on median-of-medians */
    medians = array of each group’s median.
    pivot = Select(medians, ⌈n/5⌉, ⌈n/10⌉)
    Left Array L and Right Array G = partition(A, pivot)

    /* Find ith element in L, pivot, or G */
    k = |L| + 1
    If i = k, return pivot
    If i < k, return Select(L, k-1, i)
    If i > k, return Select(G, n-k, i-k)

在Cormen等人的《算法介绍》一书中也有非常详细的描述。

它类似于快速排序策略,在快速排序策略中,我们选择一个任意的枢轴,并将较小的元素放在它的左边,将较大的元素放在右边

    public static int kthElInUnsortedList(List<int> list, int k)
    {
        if (list.Count == 1)
            return list[0];

        List<int> left = new List<int>();
        List<int> right = new List<int>();

        int pivotIndex = list.Count / 2;
        int pivot = list[pivotIndex]; //arbitrary

        for (int i = 0; i < list.Count && i != pivotIndex; i++)
        {
            int currentEl = list[i];
            if (currentEl < pivot)
                left.Add(currentEl);
            else
                right.Add(currentEl);
        }

        if (k == left.Count + 1)
            return pivot;

        if (left.Count < k)
            return kthElInUnsortedList(right, k - left.Count - 1);
        else
            return kthElInUnsortedList(left, k);
    }

我会这样做:

initialize empty doubly linked list l
for each element e in array
    if e larger than head(l)
        make e the new head of l
        if size(l) > k
            remove last element from l

the last element of l should now be the kth largest element

您可以简单地存储指向链表中第一个和最后一个元素的指针。它们只在更新列表时更改。

更新:

initialize empty sorted tree l
for each element e in array
    if e between head(l) and tail(l)
        insert e into l // O(log k)
        if size(l) > k
            remove last element from l

the last element of l should now be the kth largest element

你可以用O(n + kn) = O(n)(对于常数k)表示时间,用O(k)表示空间,通过跟踪你见过的最大的k个元素。

对于数组中的每个元素,您可以扫描k个最大的元素列表,并将最小的元素替换为更大的新元素。

Warren的优先级堆解决方案更简洁。