I've been working with a small group of people on a coding project for fun. It's an organized and fairly cohesive group. The people I work with all have various skill sets related to programming, but some of them use older or outright wrong methods, such as excessive global variables, poor naming conventions, and other things. While things work, the implementation is poor. What's a good way to politely ask or introduce them to use better methodology, without it coming across as questioning (or insulting) their experience and/or education?


当前回答

没有人喜欢听别人说他们的工作很糟糕,但任何理智的人都会欢迎指导和避免不必要工作的方法。

有一种教学流派甚至说,你不应该指出错误,而应该专注于做对的事情。例如,与其指出难以理解的代码不好,不如指出他们的代码特别容易阅读的地方。在第一种情况下,你会引导其他人像蹩脚程序员一样思考和行动。在后一种情况下,你会像一个熟练的专业人士一样思考。

其他回答

耐心再怎么强调都不为过。我见过这种完全事与愿违的事情,主要是因为有人希望现在就发生变化。相当多的环境需要进化的好处,而不是革命。今天强行改变,可能会给所有人带来一个非常不愉快的环境。

接受是关键。你的方法需要考虑到你所处的环境。

听起来你所处的环境有很多“个性”。所以…我不建议使用一套编码标准。你会发现你想把这个“有趣”的项目变成一个高度结构化的工作项目(哦,太好了,接下来是什么……功能文件?)相反,正如其他人所说,你必须在一定程度上处理它。

Stay patient and work toward educating others in your direction. Start with the edges (points where your code interacts with others) and when interacting with their code try to take it as an opportunity to discuss the interface they've created and ask them if it would be okay with them if it was changed (by you or them). And fully explain why you want the change ("it will help deal with changing subsystem attributes better" or whatever). Don't nit-pick and try to change everything you see as being wrong. Once you interact with others on the edge, they should start to see how it would benefit them at the core of their code (and if you get enough momentum, go deeper and truly start to discuss modern techniques and the benefits of coding standards). If they still don't see it... maybe you'll need to deal with that within yourself (especially on a "fun" project).

耐心。进化,而不是革命。

祝你好运。

如果你有一个松散的编码标准,能够指出这一点,或者表明你不能遵循代码,因为它不是正确的格式可能是值得的。

如果您没有编码格式,现在将是一个好时机。类似于这个问题的答案可能会有帮助:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4121/team-coding-styles

使用一些wiki软件在你的网络上创建一个wiki。

在你的网站上开始一个叫做“最佳实践”或“编码标准”的类别。

把每个人都指向它。允许反馈。

当您发布软件时,让负责将代码放入构建中的人员向开发人员推送,让他们指向上面的Wiki页面。

我曾在我的组织中这样做过,人们花了几个月的时间才真正熟悉使用Wiki,但现在它是一个不可或缺的资源。

通过例子。告诉他们正确的道路。

慢慢来。不要因为他们的每一个小错误就立刻痛斥他们,要从真正重要的事情开始。

人们编写糟糕的代码只是无知的一种症状(这与愚蠢不同)。这里有一些对付这种人的技巧。

Peoples own experience leaves a stronger impression than something you will say. Some people are not passionate about the code they produce and will not listen to anything you say Paired Programming can help share ideas but switch who's driving or they'll just be checking email on their phone Don't drown them with too much, I've found even Continuous Integration needed to be explained a few times to some older devs Get them excited again and they will want to learn. It could be something as simple as programming robots for a day TRUST YOUR TEAM, coding standards and tools that check them at build time are often never read or annoying. Remove Code Ownership, on some projects you will see code silos or ant hills where people say thats my code and you can't change it, this is very bad and you can use paired programming to remove this.