我经常听到有人说c++是一种上下文敏感的语言。举个例子:
a b(c);
这是变量定义还是函数声明?这取决于符号c的含义。如果c是一个变量，则ab (c);定义一个名为b的类型为a的变量。它直接用c初始化。但如果c是类型，则ab (c);声明一个名为b的函数，该函数接受c并返回a。
如果您查找上下文无关语言的定义，它基本上会告诉您，所有语法规则的左侧必须恰好包含一个非终结符。另一方面，上下文敏感语法允许在左侧使用任意的终结符和非终结符字符串。
浏览“c++程序设计语言”的附录A，我找不到一条语法规则，它的左边除了一个非终结符之外，还有其他任何东西。这意味着c++是上下文无关的。(当然，每一种与上下文无关的语言也是与上下文相关的，因为与上下文无关的语言构成了与上下文相关的语言的一个子集，但这不是重点。)
那么，c++是上下文无关的还是上下文敏感的?
当前回答
这个答案说c++不是上下文无关的…有一个暗示(不是由回答者)，它不能被解析，回答提供了一个困难的代码示例，如果某个常数不是质数，就会产生一个无效的c++程序。
正如其他人所观察到的，关于语言是否上下文敏感/自由的问题与关于特定语法的相同问题是不同的。
为了解决可解析性的问题，我提供了经验证据，证明c++中存在可以使用的上下文无关语法 生成一个AST，用于源文本的上下文无关的解析 实际上是通过使用现有的基于glr解析器的工具进行解析，该工具由显式语法驱动。
Yes, it succeeds by "accepting too much"; not everything it accepts is a valid C++ program, which is why it's followed up with additional checks (type checks). And yes, the type checker may run into computability problems. In practice tools don't have this problem; if people wrote programs like that, none of them would compile. (I think the standard actually puts a limit on the amount of computation you can do unfolding a template, so in fact the computation is actually finite but probably pretty big).
如果您的意思是，则确定源程序是否是成员 的集合有效的c++源程序，那么我将同意 问题就难多了。但问题并不在于解析。
The tool resolves this issue by isolating parsing from type-checking the parsed program. (Where there are multiple interpretations in the absence of context, it records an ambiguity node in the parse tree with several possible parses; the type checking decides which one is correct and eliminates the invalid subtrees). You can see a (partial) parse tree in the example below; the whole tree is too large to fit in an SO answer. Note you get a parse tree whether the value 234797 or 234799 is used.
在原始值为234799的AST上运行工具的名称/类型解析器成功。如果值为234797，名称解析器将失败(正如预期的那样)，并给出错误消息“typen不是类型”，因此该版本不是有效的c++程序。
967 tree nodes in tree.
15 ambiguity nodes in tree.
(translation_unit@Cpp~GCC5=2#6b11a20^0 Line 1 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
(declaration_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1021#6b06640^1#6b11a20:1 {10} Line 1 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
(pp_declaration_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1022#6b049a0^1#6b06640:1 Line 1 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
(declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1036#6b04980^1#6b049a0:1 Line 1 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
|(template_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=2079#6b04960^1#6b04980:1 Line 1 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (template_parameter_list@Cpp~GCC5=2082#6afbde0^1#6b04960:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (template_parameter@Cpp~GCC5=2085#6afbd80^1#6afbde0:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1611#6afbd40^1#6afbd80:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| |(basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6afb880^1#6afbd40:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6afb840^1#6afb880:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6afb7e0^1#6afb840:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1138#6afb7a0^1#6afb7e0:1 Line 1 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | )trailing_type_specifier#6afb7e0
| | )decl_specifier#6afb840
| |)basic_decl_specifier_seq#6afb880
| |(ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6afbc40^1#6afbd40:2 Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6afbba0^1#6afbc40:1 Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6afbb80^1#6afbba0:1 Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6afbaa0^1#6afbb80:1 Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6afb9c0^1#6afbaa0:1 Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6afb780^1#6afb9c0:1[`V'] Line 1 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | |)unqualified_id#6afb9c0
| | )id_expression#6afbaa0
| | )declarator_id#6afbb80
| | )noptr_declarator#6afbba0
| |)ptr_declarator#6afbc40
| )parameter_declaration#6afbd40
| )template_parameter#6afbd80
| )template_parameter_list#6afbde0
| (declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1033#6b04940^1#6b04960:2 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (block_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1050#6b04920^1#6b04940:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (simple_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1060#6b04900^1#6b04920:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| |(basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b048e0^1#6b04900:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b048c0^1#6b048e0:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1110#6b048a0^1#6b048c0:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (class_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1761#6b04880^1#6b048a0:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(class_head@Cpp~GCC5=1763#6afb980^1#6b04880:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (class_key@Cpp~GCC5=1791#6afbca0^1#6afb980:1 Line 1 Column 18 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)class_key
| | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6afbcc0^1#6afb980:2[`answer'] Line 1 Column 25 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | (optional_base_clause@Cpp~GCC5=1872#6afba60^1#6afb980:3 Line 1 Column 32 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)optional_base_clause
| | |)class_head#6afb980
| | |(member_specification@Cpp~GCC5=1794#6b042e0^1#6b04880:2 {2} Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (member_declaration_or_access_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1806#6b04060^1#6b042e0:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (member_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1822#6b04040^1#6b04060:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (function_definition@Cpp~GCC5=1632#6b04020^1#6b04040:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | |(function_head@Cpp~GCC5=1673#6afbec0^1#6b04020:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6afbfe0^1#6afbec0:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1422#6afbf80^1#6afbfe0:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6afbf60^1#6afbf80:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | |(declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6afbea0^1#6afbf60:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6afbb40^1#6afbea0:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6afbc80^1#6afbb40:1 Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6afbc20^1#6afbc80:1[`answer'] Line 1 Column 34 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | | | )unqualified_id#6afbc80
| | | | | )id_expression#6afbb40
| | | | |)declarator_id#6afbea0
| | | | )noptr_declarator#6afbf60
| | | | (parameter_declaration_clause@Cpp~GCC5=1559#6afbd00^1#6afbf80:2 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | |(pp_parameter_declaration_list@Cpp~GCC5=1570#6afb940^1#6afbd00:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (pp_parameter_declaration_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1574#6afb800^1#6afb940:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1610#6afb9a0^1#6afb800:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6afbf40^1#6afb9a0:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | |(decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6afbfa0^1#6afbf40:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6afbfc0^1#6afbfa0:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | | (simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1140#6afb860^1#6afbfc0:1 Line 1 Column 41 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | | | | | )trailing_type_specifier#6afbfc0
| | | | | |)decl_specifier#6afbfa0
| | | | | )basic_decl_specifier_seq#6afbf40
| | | | | )parameter_declaration#6afb9a0
| | | | | )pp_parameter_declaration_seq#6afb800
| | | | |)pp_parameter_declaration_list#6afb940
| | | | )parameter_declaration_clause#6afbd00
| | | | (function_qualifiers@Cpp~GCC5=1438#6afbce0^1#6afbf80:3 Line 1 Column 46 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)function_qualifiers
| | | | )noptr_declarator#6afbf80
| | | | )ptr_declarator#6afbfe0
| | | |)function_head#6afbec0
| | | |(function_body@Cpp~GCC5=1680#6b04000^1#6b04020:2 Line 1 Column 46 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (compound_statement@Cpp~GCC5=888#6afbee0^1#6b04000:1 Line 1 Column 46 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)compound_statement
| | | |)function_body#6b04000
| | | )function_definition#6b04020
| | | )member_declaration#6b04040
| | | )member_declaration_or_access_specifier#6b04060
| | | (member_declaration_or_access_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1806#6b042c0^1#6b042e0:2 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (member_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1822#6b04820^1#6b042c0:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (function_definition@Cpp~GCC5=1632#6b04280^1#6b04820:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | |(function_head@Cpp~GCC5=1674#6b04220^1#6b04280:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b040e0^1#6b04220:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b040c0^1#6b040e0:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6b040a0^1#6b040c0:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | |(simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1138#6b04080^1#6b040a0:1 Line 1 Column 49 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | | | )trailing_type_specifier#6b040a0
| | | | )decl_specifier#6b040c0
| | | | )basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b040e0
| | | | (ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6b04200^1#6b04220:2 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1422#6b041e0^1#6b04200:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6b041a0^1#6b041e0:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | |(declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6b04180^1#6b041a0:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b04160^1#6b04180:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=320#6b04140^1#6b04160:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (operator_function_id@Cpp~GCC5=2027#6b04120^1#6b04140:1 Line 1 Column 54 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | |(operator@Cpp~GCC5=2070#6b04100^1#6b04120:1 Line 1 Column 62 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)operator
| | | | | )operator_function_id#6b04120
| | | | | )unqualified_id#6b04140
| | | | | )id_expression#6b04160
| | | | |)declarator_id#6b04180
| | | | )noptr_declarator#6b041a0
| | | | (parameter_declaration_clause@Cpp~GCC5=1558#6afba40^1#6b041e0:2 Line 1 Column 65 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)parameter_declaration_clause
| | | | (function_qualifiers@Cpp~GCC5=1438#6b041c0^1#6b041e0:3 Line 1 Column 66 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)function_qualifiers
| | | | )noptr_declarator#6b041e0
| | | | )ptr_declarator#6b04200
| | | |)function_head#6b04220
| | | |(function_body@Cpp~GCC5=1680#6b04300^1#6b04280:2 Line 1 Column 66 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (compound_statement@Cpp~GCC5=889#6b04760^1#6b04300:1 Line 1 Column 66 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (pp_statement_seq@Cpp~GCC5=894#6b04780^1#6b04760:1 Line 1 Column 67 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | (statement@Cpp~GCC5=857#6b04440^1#6b04780:1 Line 1 Column 67 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | |(jump_statement@Cpp~GCC5=1011#6afba80^1#6b04440:1 Line 1 Column 67 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (pm_expression@Cpp~GCC5=551#6b04380^1#6afba80:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (cast_expression@Cpp~GCC5=543#6b04360^1#6b04380:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | (unary_expression@Cpp~GCC5=465#6b04340^1#6b04360:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | |(primary_expression@Cpp~GCC5=307#6b04320^1#6b04340:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b042a0^1#6b04320:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6b04260^1#6b042a0:1 Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | | | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6b04240^1#6b04260:1[`V'] Line 1 Column 74 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | | | | )unqualified_id#6b04260
| | | | | | )id_expression#6b042a0
| | | | | |)primary_expression#6b04320
| | | | | )unary_expression#6b04340
| | | | | )cast_expression#6b04360
| | | | | )pm_expression#6b04380
| | | | |)jump_statement#6afba80
| | | | )statement#6b04440
| | | | )pp_statement_seq#6b04780
| | | | )compound_statement#6b04760
| | | |)function_body#6b04300
| | | )function_definition#6b04280
| | | )member_declaration#6b04820
| | | )member_declaration_or_access_specifier#6b042c0
| | |)member_specification#6b042e0
| | )class_specifier#6b04880
| | )type_specifier#6b048a0
| | )decl_specifier#6b048c0
| |)basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b048e0
| )simple_declaration#6b04900
| )block_declaration#6b04920
| )declaration#6b04940
|)template_declaration#6b04960
)declaration#6b04980
)pp_declaration_seq#6b049a0
(pp_declaration_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1022#6b06620^1#6b06640:2 Line 3 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
(declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1036#6b06600^1#6b06620:1 Line 3 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
|(template_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=2079#6b065e0^1#6b06600:1 Line 3 Column 1 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (template_parameter_list@Cpp~GCC5=2083#6b05460^1#6b065e0:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (template_parameter_list@Cpp~GCC5=2083#6b05140^1#6b05460:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (template_parameter_list@Cpp~GCC5=2083#6b04ee0^1#6b05140:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| |(template_parameter_list@Cpp~GCC5=2082#6b04cc0^1#6b04ee0:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (template_parameter@Cpp~GCC5=2085#6b04ca0^1#6b04cc0:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1611#6b04c80^1#6b04ca0:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b04a40^1#6b04c80:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b04a20^1#6b04a40:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6b04a00^1#6b04a20:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1138#6b049e0^1#6b04a00:1 Line 3 Column 10 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | | )trailing_type_specifier#6b04a00
| | |)decl_specifier#6b04a20
| | )basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b04a40
| | (ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6b04c40^1#6b04c80:2 Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6b04be0^1#6b04c40:1 Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6b04bc0^1#6b04be0:1 Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b04b60^1#6b04bc0:1 Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6b04ac0^1#6b04b60:1 Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | |(IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6b049c0^1#6b04ac0:1[`no'] Line 3 Column 15 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | )unqualified_id#6b04ac0
| | | )id_expression#6b04b60
| | | )declarator_id#6b04bc0
| | |)noptr_declarator#6b04be0
| | )ptr_declarator#6b04c40
| | )parameter_declaration#6b04c80
| | )template_parameter#6b04ca0
| |)template_parameter_list#6b04cc0
| |(template_parameter@Cpp~GCC5=2085#6b04ec0^1#6b04ee0:2 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1611#6b04ea0^1#6b04ec0:1 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b04b40^1#6b04ea0:1 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b04ba0^1#6b04b40:1 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6b04c60^1#6b04ba0:1 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1138#6b04580^1#6b04c60:1 Line 3 Column 19 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | |)trailing_type_specifier#6b04c60
| | )decl_specifier#6b04ba0
| | )basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b04b40
| | (ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6b04e60^1#6b04ea0:2 Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6b04e40^1#6b04e60:1 Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6b04de0^1#6b04e40:1 Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b04d80^1#6b04de0:1 Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6b04ce0^1#6b04d80:1 Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6b04560^1#6b04ce0:1[`yes'] Line 3 Column 24 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | )unqualified_id#6b04ce0
| | | )id_expression#6b04d80
| | |)declarator_id#6b04de0
| | )noptr_declarator#6b04e40
| | )ptr_declarator#6b04e60
| | )parameter_declaration#6b04ea0
| |)template_parameter#6b04ec0
| )template_parameter_list#6b04ee0
| (template_parameter@Cpp~GCC5=2085#6b05120^1#6b05140:2 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| |(parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1611#6b05100^1#6b05120:1 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b04d20^1#6b05100:1 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b04dc0^1#6b04d20:1 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6b04e80^1#6b04dc0:1 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1140#6b046e0^1#6b04e80:1 Line 3 Column 29 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | )trailing_type_specifier#6b04e80
| | )decl_specifier#6b04dc0
| | )basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b04d20
| | (ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6b05080^1#6b05100:2 Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6b05020^1#6b05080:1 Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6b05000^1#6b05020:1 Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b04fa0^1#6b05000:1 Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6b04f00^1#6b04fa0:1 Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6b046c0^1#6b04f00:1[`f'] Line 3 Column 33 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | | )unqualified_id#6b04f00
| | |)id_expression#6b04fa0
| | )declarator_id#6b05000
| | )noptr_declarator#6b05020
| | )ptr_declarator#6b05080
| |)parameter_declaration#6b05100
| )template_parameter#6b05120
| )template_parameter_list#6b05140
| (template_parameter@Cpp~GCC5=2085#6b05440^1#6b05460:2 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| (parameter_declaration@Cpp~GCC5=1611#6b05420^1#6b05440:1 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| |(basic_decl_specifier_seq@Cpp~GCC5=1070#6b05160^1#6b05420:1 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (decl_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1073#6b04fe0^1#6b05160:1 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (trailing_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1118#6b050e0^1#6b04fe0:1 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (simple_type_specifier@Cpp~GCC5=1140#6b050c0^1#6b050e0:1 Line 3 Column 36 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)simple_type_specifier
| | )trailing_type_specifier#6b050e0
| | )decl_specifier#6b04fe0
| |)basic_decl_specifier_seq#6b05160
| |(ptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1417#6b053e0^1#6b05420:2 Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (noptr_declarator@Cpp~GCC5=1421#6b053c0^1#6b053e0:1 Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (declarator_id@Cpp~GCC5=1487#6b05360^1#6b053c0:1 Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | (id_expression@Cpp~GCC5=317#6b05280^1#6b05360:1 Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | |(unqualified_id@Cpp~GCC5=319#6b051a0^1#6b05280:1 Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp
| | | (IDENTIFIER@Cpp~GCC5=3368#6b046a0^1#6b051a0:1[`p'] Line 3 Column 40 File C:/temp/prime_with_templates.cpp)IDENTIFIER
| | |)unqualified_id#6b051a0
| | )id_expression#6b05280
| | )declarator_id#6b05360
| | )noptr_declarator#6b053c0
| |)ptr_declarator#6b053e0
| )parameter_declaration#6b05420
| )template_parameter#6b05440
| )template_parameter_list#6b05460
其他回答
它是上下文敏感的，如a b(c);有两个有效的解析-声明和变量。当你说“If c是一个类型”时，这就是上下文，就在那里，你已经准确地描述了c++对它的敏感程度。如果没有“c是什么?”的上下文，就无法明确地解析它。
在这里，上下文通过标记的选择来表示——如果标识符指定了类型，解析器将其读取为typename标记。这是最简单的解决方案，避免了上下文敏感的复杂性(在本例中)。
编辑:当然，还有更多的上下文敏感性问题，我只是关注你展示的那个。模板在这方面尤其糟糕。
c++模板已经被证明是图灵强大的。虽然不是正式的参考资料，但从这方面来看，我们可以从以下几个方面入手:
http://cpptruths.blogspot.com/2005/11/c-templates-are-turing-complete.html
我大胆地猜测一下(古老的民间和简明的CACM证明表明，60年代的ALGOL不能用CFG表示)，并说c++因此不能仅用CFG正确地解析。cfg与各种TP机制结合在一起，无论是在树通道还是在减少事件中——这是另一个故事。一般来说，由于停止问题，存在一些c++程序不能被证明是正确的/不正确的，但仍然是正确的/不正确的。
{PS-作为Meta-S的作者(上面有几个人提到过)，我可以很肯定地说Thothic并没有消失，也不是免费的软件。也许我这样回答是为了不被删除或被投票降至-3。
要回答你的问题，你需要区分两个不同的问题。
几乎每一种编程语言的语法都与上下文无关。通常，它是作为扩展的Backus-Naur形式或上下文无关语法给出的。 然而，即使一个程序符合编程语言定义的上下文无关语法，它也不一定是一个有效的程序。为了成为一个有效的程序，程序必须满足许多与上下文无关的属性。例如，最简单的属性是变量的作用域。
综上所述，c++是否与上下文无关取决于你问的问题。
有时情况更糟:当人们说c++具有“不可判定语法”时，他们的意思是什么?
首先，你正确地观察到c++标准末尾的语法中没有上下文敏感的规则，因此语法与上下文无关。
然而，这种语法并不能精确地描述c++语言，因为它生成的是非c++程序，例如
int m() { m++; }
or
typedef static int int;
c++语言被定义为“一组格式良好的c++程序”，它不是与上下文无关的(可以证明，仅仅要求声明变量就可以做到这一点)。理论上，您可以在模板中编写图灵完备程序，并根据其结果使程序具有病态形式，因此它甚至不是上下文敏感的。
现在，(无知的)人们(通常不是语言理论家，而是解析器设计者)通常在以下一些含义中使用“not context-free”
模棱两可的 不能用Bison解析 而不是LL(k) LR(k) LALR(k)或任何他们选择的解析器定义的语言类
标准后面的语法不满足这些类别(即它是模糊的，不是LL(k)…)，所以c++语法对他们来说“不是上下文无关的”。从某种意义上说，他们是对的，要创建一个工作的c++解析器是非常困难的。
注意，这里使用的属性只与上下文无关的语言有微弱的联系——歧义与上下文无关没有任何关系(事实上，上下文敏感的规则通常有助于消除歧义)，另外两个只是上下文无关语言的子集。解析与上下文无关的语言不是一个线性过程(尽管解析确定性语言是)。
