更新:

再次感谢你的例子,它们对我很有帮助,我并不是说 夺走他们的一切。

Aren't the currently given examples, as far as I understand them & state-machines, only half of what we usually understand by a state-machine? In the sense that the examples do change state but that's only represented by changing the value of a variable (and allowing different value- changes in different states), while usually, a state machine should also change its behavior, and behavior not (only) in the sense of allowing different value changes for a variable depending on the state, but in the sense of allowing different methods to be executed for different states.

还是我对状态机及其常用用法有误解?


最初的问题:

我发现了关于c#中的状态机和迭代器块的讨论,以及用于创建状态机和c#的工具,所以我发现了很多抽象的东西,但作为一个新手,所有这些都有点令人困惑。

因此,如果有人能提供一个c#源代码-示例,实现一个简单的状态机,可能只有3,4个状态,那就太好了,只是为了了解它的要点。


当前回答

关于stateppattern。这符合你的需要吗?

我认为这与上下文有关,但值得一试。

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_pattern

这让你的状态决定去哪里,而不是“对象”类。

布鲁诺

其他回答

您可能希望使用现有的开源有限状态机之一。例如,在http://code.google.com/p/bbvcommon/wiki/StateMachine找到的bbv.Common.StateMachine。它具有非常直观流畅的语法和许多特性,如进入/退出操作、转换操作、保护、分层、被动实现(在调用者的线程上执行)和主动实现(fsm运行在自己的线程上,事件被添加到队列中)。

以Juliets为例,状态机的定义非常简单:

var fsm = new PassiveStateMachine<ProcessState, Command>();
fsm.In(ProcessState.Inactive)
   .On(Command.Exit).Goto(ProcessState.Terminated).Execute(SomeTransitionAction)
   .On(Command.Begin).Goto(ProcessState.Active);
fsm.In(ProcessState.Active)
   .ExecuteOnEntry(SomeEntryAction)
   .ExecuteOnExit(SomeExitAction)
   .On(Command.End).Goto(ProcessState.Inactive)
   .On(Command.Pause).Goto(ProcessState.Paused);
fsm.In(ProcessState.Paused)
   .On(Command.End).Goto(ProcessState.Inactive).OnlyIf(SomeGuard)
   .On(Command.Resume).Goto(ProcessState.Active);
fsm.Initialize(ProcessState.Inactive);
fsm.Start();

fsm.Fire(Command.Begin);

更新:项目位置已移动到:https://github.com/appccelerate/statemachine

我推荐state.cs。我个人使用state.js (JavaScript版本),并且非常满意。c#版本以类似的方式工作。

你实例化状态:

        // create the state machine
        var player = new StateMachine<State>( "player" );

        // create some states
        var initial = player.CreatePseudoState( "initial", PseudoStateKind.Initial );
        var operational = player.CreateCompositeState( "operational" );
        ...

你实例化了一些转换:

        var t0 = player.CreateTransition( initial, operational );
        player.CreateTransition( history, stopped );
        player.CreateTransition<String>( stopped, running, ( state, command ) => command.Equals( "play" ) );
        player.CreateTransition<String>( active, stopped, ( state, command ) => command.Equals( "stop" ) );

在状态和转场上定义动作:

    t0.Effect += DisengageHead;
    t0.Effect += StopMotor;

差不多就是这样了。更多信息请查看网站。

我还没有尝试过在c#中实现FSM,但这些听起来(或看起来)与我过去在C或ASM等低级语言中处理FSM的方式非常复杂。

我相信我所知道的方法被称为“迭代循环”。在其中,你实际上有一个“while”循环,它周期性地根据事件(中断)退出,然后再次返回到主循环。

在中断处理程序中,您将传递一个CurrentState并返回一个NextState,然后在主循环中覆盖CurrentState变量。你可以无限地这样做,直到程序关闭(或微控制器复位)。

在我看来,与FSM的实现方式相比,我看到的其他答案都显得非常复杂;它的美丽在于它的简单性,FSM可以非常复杂,有很多很多的状态和过渡,但它们允许复杂的过程很容易被分解和消化。

我知道我的回答不应该包含另一个问题,但我不得不问:为什么这些其他提出的解决方案看起来如此复杂? 它们似乎类似于用一个巨大的大锤敲一个小钉子。

在NuGet中有两个流行的状态机包。

Appccelerate。StateMachine (13.6K下载量+ 3.82K遗留版本(bbv.Common.StateMachine))

中文工具箱(1.56K downloads)

Appccelerate库有很好的文档,但是它不支持。net 4,所以我选择了StateMachineToolkit作为我的项目。

我用朱莉叶的代码做了这个通用状态机。这对我来说非常有效。

以下是好处:

你可以用两个枚举TState和TCommand在代码中创建新的状态机, 增加了struct TransitionResult<TState>以更好地控制[Try]GetNext()方法的输出结果 只通过AddTransition(TState, TCommand, TState)暴露嵌套类StateTransition,使其更容易使用

代码:

public class StateMachine<TState, TCommand>
    where TState : struct, IConvertible, IComparable
    where TCommand : struct, IConvertible, IComparable
{
    protected class StateTransition<TS, TC>
        where TS : struct, IConvertible, IComparable
        where TC : struct, IConvertible, IComparable
    {
        readonly TS CurrentState;
        readonly TC Command;

        public StateTransition(TS currentState, TC command)
        {
            if (!typeof(TS).IsEnum || !typeof(TC).IsEnum)
            {
                throw new ArgumentException("TS,TC must be an enumerated type");
            }

            CurrentState = currentState;
            Command = command;
        }

        public override int GetHashCode()
        {
            return 17 + 31 * CurrentState.GetHashCode() + 31 * Command.GetHashCode();
        }

        public override bool Equals(object obj)
        {
            StateTransition<TS, TC> other = obj as StateTransition<TS, TC>;
            return other != null
                && this.CurrentState.CompareTo(other.CurrentState) == 0
                && this.Command.CompareTo(other.Command) == 0;
        }
    }

    private Dictionary<StateTransition<TState, TCommand>, TState> transitions;
    public TState CurrentState { get; private set; }

    protected StateMachine(TState initialState)
    {
        if (!typeof(TState).IsEnum || !typeof(TCommand).IsEnum)
        {
            throw new ArgumentException("TState,TCommand must be an enumerated type");
        }

        CurrentState = initialState;
        transitions = new Dictionary<StateTransition<TState, TCommand>, TState>();
    }

    /// <summary>
    /// Defines a new transition inside this state machine
    /// </summary>
    /// <param name="start">source state</param>
    /// <param name="command">transition condition</param>
    /// <param name="end">destination state</param>
    protected void AddTransition(TState start, TCommand command, TState end)
    {
        transitions.Add(new StateTransition<TState, TCommand>(start, command), end);
    }

    public TransitionResult<TState> TryGetNext(TCommand command)
    {
        StateTransition<TState, TCommand> transition = new StateTransition<TState, TCommand>(CurrentState, command);
        TState nextState;
        if (transitions.TryGetValue(transition, out nextState))
            return new TransitionResult<TState>(nextState, true);
        else
            return new TransitionResult<TState>(CurrentState, false);
    }

    public TransitionResult<TState> MoveNext(TCommand command)
    {
        var result = TryGetNext(command);
        if(result.IsValid)
        {
            //changes state
            CurrentState = result.NewState;
        }
        return result;
    }
}

这是TryGetNext方法的返回类型:

public struct TransitionResult<TState>
{
    public TransitionResult(TState newState, bool isValid)
    {
        NewState = newState;
        IsValid = isValid;
    }
    public TState NewState;
    public bool IsValid;
}

使用方法:

这是你如何从泛型类创建一个OnlineDiscountStateMachine:

为其状态定义一个enum OnlineDiscountState,为其命令定义一个enum OnlineDiscountCommand。

使用这两个枚举定义从泛型类派生的类OnlineDiscountStateMachine

从base(OnlineDiscountState. initialstate)派生构造函数,以便初始状态被设置为OnlineDiscountState。InitialState

根据需要多次使用AddTransition

public class OnlineDiscountStateMachine : StateMachine<OnlineDiscountState, OnlineDiscountCommand>
{
    public OnlineDiscountStateMachine() : base(OnlineDiscountState.Disconnected)
    {
        AddTransition(OnlineDiscountState.Disconnected, OnlineDiscountCommand.Connect, OnlineDiscountState.Connected);
        AddTransition(OnlineDiscountState.Disconnected, OnlineDiscountCommand.Connect, OnlineDiscountState.Error_AuthenticationError);
        AddTransition(OnlineDiscountState.Connected, OnlineDiscountCommand.Submit, OnlineDiscountState.WaitingForResponse);
        AddTransition(OnlineDiscountState.WaitingForResponse, OnlineDiscountCommand.DataReceived, OnlineDiscountState.Disconnected);
    }
}

使用派生状态机

    odsm = new OnlineDiscountStateMachine();
    public void Connect()
    {
        var result = odsm.TryGetNext(OnlineDiscountCommand.Connect);

        //is result valid?
        if (!result.IsValid)
            //if this happens you need to add transitions to the state machine
            //in this case result.NewState is the same as before
            Console.WriteLine("cannot navigate from this state using OnlineDiscountCommand.Connect");

        //the transition was successfull
        //show messages for new states
        else if(result.NewState == OnlineDiscountState.Error_AuthenticationError)
            Console.WriteLine("invalid user/pass");
        else if(result.NewState == OnlineDiscountState.Connected)
            Console.WriteLine("Connected");
        else
            Console.WriteLine("not implemented transition result for " + result.NewState);
    }