给定以下代码(不起作用):

while True:
    # Snip: print out current state
    while True:
        ok = get_input("Is this ok? (y/n)")
        if ok.lower() == "y": break 2 # This doesn't work :(
        if ok.lower() == "n": break

    # Do more processing with menus and stuff

有办法解决这个问题吗?还是我必须先检查一次,跳出输入循环,然后再检查一次,如果用户满意,再跳出外部循环?


当前回答

# this version breaks up to a certain label

break_label = None
while True:
    # snip: print out current state
    while True:
        ok = get_input("Is this ok? (y/n)")
        if ok == "y" or ok == "Y":
            break_label = "outer"   # specify label to break to
            break
        if ok == "n" or ok == "N":
            break
    if break_label:
        if break_label != "inner":
            break                   # propagate up
        break_label = None          # we have arrived!
if break_label:
    if break_label != "outer":
        break                       # propagate up
    break_label = None              # we have arrived!

#do more processing with menus and stuff

其他回答

PEP 3136建议标记中断/继续。Guido拒绝了它,因为“需要这个功能的复杂代码非常罕见”。不过,PEP确实提到了一些变通方法(比如异常技术),而Guido认为在大多数情况下,使用return进行重构会更简单。

这不是最漂亮的方法,但在我看来,这是最好的方法。

def loop():
    while True:
    #snip: print out current state
        while True:
            ok = get_input("Is this ok? (y/n)")
            if ok == "y" or ok == "Y": return
            if ok == "n" or ok == "N": break
        #do more processing with menus and stuff

我很确定你也可以用递归解出一些东西,但我不知道这对你来说是不是一个好选择。

我想提醒你,Python中的函数可以在代码中间创建,并且可以透明地访问周围的变量以进行读取,也可以通过非局部或全局声明进行写入。

所以你可以使用一个函数作为“易碎的控制结构”,定义一个你想要返回的地方:

def is_prime(number):

    foo = bar = number

    def return_here():
        nonlocal foo, bar
        init_bar = bar
        while foo > 0:
            bar = init_bar
            while bar >= foo:
                if foo*bar == number:
                    return
                bar -= 1
            foo -= 1

    return_here()

    if foo == 1:
        print(number, 'is prime')
    else:
        print(number, '=', bar, '*', foo)

>>> is_prime(67)
67 is prime
>>> is_prime(117)
117 = 13 * 9
>>> is_prime(16)
16 = 4 * 4

要跳出多个嵌套循环,而不需要重构为函数,可以使用带有内置StopIteration异常的“模拟goto语句”:

try:
    for outer in range(100):
        for inner in range(100):
            if break_early():
                raise StopIteration

except StopIteration: pass

请参阅使用goto语句打破嵌套循环的讨论。

我个人会做的是使用一个boolean,当我准备跳出外部循环时切换。例如

while True:
    #snip: print out current state
    quit = False
    while True:
        ok = input("Is this ok? (y/n)")
        if ok.lower() == "y":
            quit = True
            break # this should work now :-)
        if ok.lower() == "n":
            quit = True
            break # This should work too :-)
    if quit:
        break
    #do more processing with menus and stuff