我希望使用shell脚本调用长形式和短形式的命令行选项。

我知道可以使用getopts,但是像在Perl中一样,我不能用shell做同样的事情。

关于如何做到这一点的任何想法,这样我就可以使用如下选项:

./shell.sh --copyfile abc.pl /tmp/
./shell.sh -c abc.pl /tmp/

在上面,这两个命令对我的shell意味着同样的事情,但使用getopts,我还不能实现这些?


当前回答

长选项可以被内置的标准getopts作为- " option "的"参数"解析。

这是可移植的本地POSIX shell -不需要外部程序或bashisms。

本指南将长选项作为-选项的参数实现,因此——alpha被getopts视为参数alpha为-,而——bravo=foo被参数bravo=foo视为-。true实参通过shell参数展开获取,更新$OPT和$OPTARG。

在本例中,-b和-c(以及它们的长形式——bravo和——charlie)具有强制实参。长选项的参数出现在等号之后,例如——bravo=foo(长选项的空格分隔符很难实现,参见下文)。

因为它使用了内置的getopts,所以这个解决方案支持像cmd——bravo=foo -ac FILE这样的用法(它组合了选项-a和-c,并将长选项与标准选项交织在一起),而这里的大多数其他答案要么很难做到,要么无法做到这一点。

die() { echo "$*" >&2; exit 2; }  # complain to STDERR and exit with error
needs_arg() { if [ -z "$OPTARG" ]; then die "No arg for --$OPT option"; fi; }

while getopts ab:c:-: OPT; do
  # support long options: https://stackoverflow.com/a/28466267/519360
  if [ "$OPT" = "-" ]; then   # long option: reformulate OPT and OPTARG
    OPT="${OPTARG%%=*}"       # extract long option name
    OPTARG="${OPTARG#$OPT}"   # extract long option argument (may be empty)
    OPTARG="${OPTARG#=}"      # if long option argument, remove assigning `=`
  fi
  case "$OPT" in
    a | alpha )    alpha=true ;;
    b | bravo )    needs_arg; bravo="$OPTARG" ;;
    c | charlie )  needs_arg; charlie="$OPTARG" ;;
    ??* )          die "Illegal option --$OPT" ;;  # bad long option
    ? )            exit 2 ;;  # bad short option (error reported via getopts)
  esac
done
shift $((OPTIND-1)) # remove parsed options and args from $@ list

When the option is a dash (-), it is a long option. getopts will have parsed the actual long option into $OPTARG, e.g. --bravo=foo originally sets OPT='-' and OPTARG='bravo=foo'. The if stanza sets $OPT to the contents of $OPTARG before the first equals sign (bravo in our example) and then removes that from the beginning of $OPTARG (yielding =foo in this step, or an empty string if there is no =). Finally, we strip the argument's leading =. At this point, $OPT is either a short option (one character) or a long option (2+ characters).

The case then matches either short or long options (the pipe, |, indicates that "or" operation. A long-only option like delta ) delta=true ;; doesn't need a pipe). For short options, getopts automatically complains about options and missing arguments, so we have to replicate those manually using the needs_arg function, which fatally exits when $OPTARG is empty. The ??* condition will match any remaining long option (? matches a single character and * matches zero or more, so ??* matches 2+ characters), allowing us to issue the "Illegal option" error before exiting.

与正常的gnu风格的长选项一样,提供——将停止解析,因此- -- --bravo=4将把$alpha设置为true,但$bravo将保持不变,$1将-bravo=4。我不能说我建议用前导破折号来命名文件,但这是表示它们不是选项的方法。


小错误:如果有人给出了一个无效的单字符长选项(它也不是一个短选项),这将退出一个错误,但没有消息(这个实现假设它是一个短选项)。您可以在case之前的条件中使用一个额外的变量来跟踪它,然后在最后的case条件中测试它,但我认为这是一个太麻烦的角落情况。

大写变量名:一般情况下,建议保留全大写变量供系统使用。我将$OPT保留为全大写,以与$OPTARG保持一致,但这确实打破了这种约定。我认为这很合适,因为这是系统应该做的事情,它应该是安全的;我还没有听说过任何使用这个变量名的标准。

要抱怨长选项的非预期实参:用翻转测试模拟needs_argg来抱怨一个非预期实参:

no_arg() { if [ -n "$OPTARG" ]; then die "No arg allowed for --$OPT option"; fi; }

要接受带空格分隔参数的长选项:您可以用eval "ARG_B=\"\$$OPTIND\""(或使用bash的间接展开,ARG_B="${!OPTIND}")拉入下一个参数,然后增加$OPTIND,正如这个答案的旧版本所指出的那样,但它不可靠;getopts可以过早地终止,假设参数超出了它的作用域,并且一些实现不太适合手动操作$OPTIND。

其他回答

我还没有足够的代表来评论或投票他的解决方案,但他的答案对我来说非常有效。我遇到的唯一问题是参数以单引号结尾(所以我把它们去掉了)。

我还添加了一些示例用法和帮助文本。我将在这里附上我略微扩展的版本:

#!/bin/bash

# getopt example
# from: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/402377/using-getopts-in-bash-shell-script-to-get-long-and-short-command-line-options
HELP_TEXT=\
"   USAGE:\n
    Accepts - and -- flags, can specify options that require a value, and can be in any order. A double-hyphen (--) will stop processing options.\n\n

    Accepts the following forms:\n\n

    getopt-example.sh -a -b -c value-for-c some-arg\n
    getopt-example.sh -c value-for-c -a -b some-arg\n
    getopt-example.sh -abc some-arg\n
    getopt-example.sh --along --blong --clong value-for-c -a -b -c some-arg\n
    getopt-example.sh some-arg --clong value-for-c\n
    getopt-example.sh
"

aflag=false
bflag=false
cargument=""

# options may be followed by one colon to indicate they have a required argument
if ! options=$(getopt -o abc:h\? -l along,blong,help,clong: -- "$@")
then
    # something went wrong, getopt will put out an error message for us
    exit 1
fi

set -- $options

while [ $# -gt 0 ]
do
    case $1 in
    -a|--along) aflag=true ;;
    -b|--blong) bflag=true ;;
    # for options with required arguments, an additional shift is required
    -c|--clong) cargument="$2" ; shift;;
    -h|--help|-\?) echo -e $HELP_TEXT; exit;;
    (--) shift; break;;
    (-*) echo "$0: error - unrecognized option $1" 1>&2; exit 1;;
    (*) break;;
    esac
    shift
done

# to remove the single quotes around arguments, pipe the output into:
# | sed -e "s/^'\\|'$//g"  (just leading/trailing) or | sed -e "s/'//g"  (all)

echo aflag=${aflag}
echo bflag=${bflag}
echo cargument=${cargument}

while [ $# -gt 0 ]
do
    echo arg=$1
    shift

    if [[ $aflag == true ]]; then
        echo a is true
    fi

done

改进的解决方案:

# translate long options to short
# Note: This enable long options but disable "--?*" in $OPTARG, or disable long options after  "--" in option fields.
for ((i=1;$#;i++)) ; do
    case "$1" in
        --)
            # [ ${args[$((i-1))]} == ... ] || EndOpt=1 ;;& # DIRTY: we still can handle some execptions...
            EndOpt=1 ;;&
        --version) ((EndOpt)) && args[$i]="$1"  || args[$i]="-V";;
        # default case : short option use the first char of the long option:
        --?*) ((EndOpt)) && args[$i]="$1"  || args[$i]="-${1:2:1}";;
        # pass through anything else:
        *) args[$i]="$1" ;;
    esac
    shift
done
# reset the translated args
set -- "${args[@]}"

function usage {
echo "Usage: $0 [options] files" >&2
    exit $1
}

# now we can process with getopt
while getopts ":hvVc:" opt; do
    case $opt in
        h)  usage ;;
        v)  VERBOSE=true ;;
        V)  echo $Version ; exit ;;
        c)  source $OPTARG ;;
        \?) echo "unrecognized option: -$opt" ; usage -1 ;;
        :)
        echo "option -$OPTARG requires an argument"
        usage -1
        ;;
    esac
done

shift $((OPTIND-1))
[[ "$1" == "--" ]] && shift

这需要一些时间,但我想要全部:

短选项 长选项 不管有没有论点 非选项参数(没有“-”或“——”的参数) 顺序不重要(script.sh /file -V或script.sh -V /file) 抓住错误用法 在不同的脚本中使用它作为模块,而不需要更改多行代码

最后,我提出了下面的解决方案,它使用getopt来捕获错误并将非选项移动到列表的末尾,然后再使用getopts来解析短选项和长选项。

所有的选项都会自动解析,将它们的长选项名作为变量名(请看例子):

# create string of short options
opt_short=$(printf "%s" "${!options[@]}")

# create string of long options
opt_long="$(printf ",%s" "${options[@]}")"

# catch wrong options and move non-options to the end of the string
args=$(getopt -l "$opt_long" "$opt_short" "$@" 2> >(sed -e 's/^/stderr/g')) || echo -n "Error: " && echo "$args" | grep -oP "(?<=^stderr).*" && exit 1

# create new array of options
mapfile -t args < <(xargs -n1 <<< "$(echo "$args" | sed -E "s/(--[^ ]+) '/\1='/g")" )

# overwrite $@ (options)
set -- "${args[@]}"

# parse options ([h]=help sets the variable "$opt_help" and [V]="" sets the variable "$opt_V")
while getopts "$opt_short-:" opt; do

  echo "$opt:$OPTARG"

  # long option
  if [[ "$opt" == "-" ]]; then

    # extract long option name
    opt="${OPTARG%%=*}"

    # extract long option argument (may be empty)
    OPTARG="${OPTARG#"$opt"}"

    # remove "=" from long option argument
    OPTARG="${OPTARG#=}"

    # set variable name
    opt=opt_$opt

  # short option without argument uses long option name as variable name
  elif [[ "${options[$opt]+x}" ]] && [[ "${options[$opt]}" ]]; then
    opt=opt_${options[$opt]} 

  # short option with argument uses long option name as variable name
  elif [[ "${options[$opt:]+x}" ]] && [[ "${options[$opt:]}" ]]; then
    opt=opt_${options[$opt:]} 

  # short option without long option name uses short option name as variable name
  else
    opt=opt_$opt
  fi

  # remove double colon
  opt="${opt%:}" 

  # options without arguments are set to 1
  [[ ! $OPTARG ]] && OPTARG=1 

  # replace hyphen against underscore
  opt="${opt//-/_}"

  # set variable variables (replaces hyphen against underscore)
  printf -v "$opt" '%s' "$OPTARG" 

done

现在,我只需要定义所需的选项名称和源代码脚本:

# import options module
declare -A options=( [h]=help [f:]=file: [V]=verbose [0]=long_only: [s]="" )
source "/usr/local/bin/inc/options.sh";

# display help text
if [[ $opt_help ]]; then
  echo "help text"
  exit
fi

# output
echo "opt_help:$opt_help"
echo "opt_file:$opt_file"
echo "opt_verbose:$opt_verbose"
echo "opt_long_only:$opt_long_only"
echo "opt_short_only:$opt_s"
echo "opt_path:$1"
echo "opt_mail:$2"

在调用脚本时,可以完全随机地传递所有选项和非选项:

#             $opt_file     $1        $2       $opt_V  $opt_long_only $opt_s
# /demo.sh --file=file.txt /dir info@example.com -V --long_only=yes -s
opt_help:1
opt_file:file.txt
opt_verbose:1
opt_long_only:yes
opt_short_only:1
opt_path=/dir
opt_mail:info@example.com

笔记

在选项数组中,在选项名称后添加:以启用参数。 如果没有给出较长的选项名,则变量名将是$opt_X,其中X是较短的选项名。 如果您希望使用较长的选项名而不定义较短的选项名,则将数组索引设置为一个数字,如上面示例中使用[0]=long_only所做的那样。当然,每个数组下标必须是唯一的。

使用的技术

不使用临时文件捕获stderr 将字符串转换为数组 使用:来解析getopt参数 使用getopts解析长选项名

内置的getopts只解析短选项(ksh93除外), 但是您仍然可以添加几行脚本来使getopts处理长选项。

以下是在http://www.uxora.com/unix/shell-script/22-handle-long-options-with-getopts中找到的部分代码

  #== set short options ==#
SCRIPT_OPTS=':fbF:B:-:h'
  #== set long options associated with short one ==#
typeset -A ARRAY_OPTS
ARRAY_OPTS=(
    [foo]=f
    [bar]=b
    [foobar]=F
    [barfoo]=B
    [help]=h
    [man]=h
)

  #== parse options ==#
while getopts ${SCRIPT_OPTS} OPTION ; do
    #== translate long options to short ==#
    if [[ "x$OPTION" == "x-" ]]; then
        LONG_OPTION=$OPTARG
        LONG_OPTARG=$(echo $LONG_OPTION | grep "=" | cut -d'=' -f2)
        LONG_OPTIND=-1
        [[ "x$LONG_OPTARG" = "x" ]] && LONG_OPTIND=$OPTIND || LONG_OPTION=$(echo $OPTARG | cut -d'=' -f1)
        [[ $LONG_OPTIND -ne -1 ]] && eval LONG_OPTARG="\$$LONG_OPTIND"
        OPTION=${ARRAY_OPTS[$LONG_OPTION]}
        [[ "x$OPTION" = "x" ]] &&  OPTION="?" OPTARG="-$LONG_OPTION"

        if [[ $( echo "${SCRIPT_OPTS}" | grep -c "${OPTION}:" ) -eq 1 ]]; then
            if [[ "x${LONG_OPTARG}" = "x" ]] || [[ "${LONG_OPTARG}" = -* ]]; then 
                OPTION=":" OPTARG="-$LONG_OPTION"
            else
                OPTARG="$LONG_OPTARG";
                if [[ $LONG_OPTIND -ne -1 ]]; then
                    [[ $OPTIND -le $Optnum ]] && OPTIND=$(( $OPTIND+1 ))
                    shift $OPTIND
                    OPTIND=1
                fi
            fi
        fi
    fi

    #== options follow by another option instead of argument ==#
    if [[ "x${OPTION}" != "x:" ]] && [[ "x${OPTION}" != "x?" ]] && [[ "${OPTARG}" = -* ]]; then 
        OPTARG="$OPTION" OPTION=":"
    fi

    #== manage options ==#
    case "$OPTION" in
        f  ) foo=1 bar=0                    ;;
        b  ) foo=0 bar=1                    ;;
        B  ) barfoo=${OPTARG}               ;;
        F  ) foobar=1 && foobar_name=${OPTARG} ;;
        h ) usagefull && exit 0 ;;
        : ) echo "${SCRIPT_NAME}: -$OPTARG: option requires an argument" >&2 && usage >&2 && exit 99 ;;
        ? ) echo "${SCRIPT_NAME}: -$OPTARG: unknown option" >&2 && usage >&2 && exit 99 ;;
    esac
done
shift $((${OPTIND} - 1))

下面是一个测试:

# Short options test
$ ./foobar_any_getopts.sh -bF "Hello world" -B 6 file1 file2
foo=0 bar=1
barfoo=6
foobar=1 foobar_name=Hello world
files=file1 file2

# Long and short options test
$ ./foobar_any_getopts.sh --bar -F Hello --barfoo 6 file1 file2
foo=0 bar=1
barfoo=6
foobar=1 foobar_name=Hello
files=file1 file2

另外,在最近的Korn Shell ksh93中,getopts可以自然地解析长选项,甚至显示类似的手册页。(参见http://www.uxora.com/unix/shell-script/20-getopts-with-man-page-and-long-options)

发明了另一个版本的轮子……

这个函数(希望)是一个posix兼容的普通bourne shell替换GNU getopt。它支持短/长选项,可以接受强制/可选/无参数,并且指定选项的方式几乎与GNU getopt相同,因此转换是微不足道的。

当然,要放入脚本中,这仍然是相当大的代码块,但它大约是众所周知的getopt_long shell函数的一半行数,并且在您只想替换现有的GNU getopt使用的情况下可能更可取。

这是相当新的代码,所以是YMMV(如果因为某种原因它实际上与POSIX不兼容,请务必告诉我——可移植性是一开始的意图,但我没有一个有用的POSIX测试环境)。

代码和示例用法如下:

#!/bin/sh
# posix_getopt shell function
# Author: Phil S.
# Version: 1.0
# Created: 2016-07-05
# URL: http://stackoverflow.com/a/37087374/324105

# POSIX-compatible argument quoting and parameter save/restore
# http://www.etalabs.net/sh_tricks.html
# Usage:
# parameters=$(save "$@") # save the original parameters.
# eval "set -- ${parameters}" # restore the saved parameters.
save () {
    local param
    for param; do
        printf %s\\n "$param" \
            | sed "s/'/'\\\\''/g;1s/^/'/;\$s/\$/' \\\\/"
    done
    printf %s\\n " "
}

# Exit with status $1 after displaying error message $2.
exiterr () {
    printf %s\\n "$2" >&2
    exit $1
}

# POSIX-compatible command line option parsing.
# This function supports long options and optional arguments, and is
# a (largely-compatible) drop-in replacement for GNU getopt.
#
# Instead of:
# opts=$(getopt -o "$shortopts" -l "$longopts" -- "$@")
# eval set -- ${opts}
#
# We instead use:
# opts=$(posix_getopt "$shortopts" "$longopts" "$@")
# eval "set -- ${opts}"
posix_getopt () { # args: "$shortopts" "$longopts" "$@"
    local shortopts longopts \
          arg argtype getopt nonopt opt optchar optword suffix

    shortopts="$1"
    longopts="$2"
    shift 2

    getopt=
    nonopt=
    while [ $# -gt 0 ]; do
        opt=
        arg=
        argtype=
        case "$1" in
            # '--' means don't parse the remaining options
            ( -- ) {
                getopt="${getopt}$(save "$@")"
                shift $#
                break
            };;
            # process short option
            ( -[!-]* ) {         # -x[foo]
                suffix=${1#-?}   # foo
                opt=${1%$suffix} # -x
                optchar=${opt#-} # x
                case "${shortopts}" in
                    ( *${optchar}::* ) { # optional argument
                        argtype=optional
                        arg="${suffix}"
                        shift
                    };;
                    ( *${optchar}:* ) { # required argument
                        argtype=required
                        if [ -n "${suffix}" ]; then
                            arg="${suffix}"
                            shift
                        else
                            case "$2" in
                                ( -* ) exiterr 1 "$1 requires an argument";;
                                ( ?* ) arg="$2"; shift 2;;
                                (  * ) exiterr 1 "$1 requires an argument";;
                            esac
                        fi
                    };;
                    ( *${optchar}* ) { # no argument
                        argtype=none
                        arg=
                        shift
                        # Handle multiple no-argument parameters combined as
                        # -xyz instead of -x -y -z. If we have just shifted
                        # parameter -xyz, we now replace it with -yz (which
                        # will be processed in the next iteration).
                        if [ -n "${suffix}" ]; then
                            eval "set -- $(save "-${suffix}")$(save "$@")"
                        fi
                    };;
                    ( * ) exiterr 1 "Unknown option $1";;
                esac
            };;
            # process long option
            ( --?* ) {            # --xarg[=foo]
                suffix=${1#*=}    # foo (unless there was no =)
                if [ "${suffix}" = "$1" ]; then
                    suffix=
                fi
                opt=${1%=$suffix} # --xarg
                optword=${opt#--} # xarg
                case ",${longopts}," in
                    ( *,${optword}::,* ) { # optional argument
                        argtype=optional
                        arg="${suffix}"
                        shift
                    };;
                    ( *,${optword}:,* ) { # required argument
                        argtype=required
                        if [ -n "${suffix}" ]; then
                            arg="${suffix}"
                            shift
                        else
                            case "$2" in
                                ( -* ) exiterr 1 \
                                       "--${optword} requires an argument";;
                                ( ?* ) arg="$2"; shift 2;;
                                (  * ) exiterr 1 \
                                       "--${optword} requires an argument";;
                            esac
                        fi
                    };;
                    ( *,${optword},* ) { # no argument
                        if [ -n "${suffix}" ]; then
                            exiterr 1 "--${optword} does not take an argument"
                        fi
                        argtype=none
                        arg=
                        shift
                    };;
                    ( * ) exiterr 1 "Unknown option $1";;
                esac
            };;
            # any other parameters starting with -
            ( -* ) exiterr 1 "Unknown option $1";;
            # remember non-option parameters
            ( * ) nonopt="${nonopt}$(save "$1")"; shift;;
        esac

        if [ -n "${opt}" ]; then
            getopt="${getopt}$(save "$opt")"
            case "${argtype}" in
                ( optional|required ) {
                    getopt="${getopt}$(save "$arg")"
                };;
            esac
        fi
    done

    # Generate function output, suitable for:
    # eval "set -- $(posix_getopt ...)"
    printf %s "${getopt}"
    if [ -n "${nonopt}" ]; then
        printf %s "$(save "--")${nonopt}"
    fi
}

使用示例:

# Process command line options
shortopts="hvd:c::s::L:D"
longopts="help,version,directory:,client::,server::,load:,delete"
#opts=$(getopt -o "$shortopts" -l "$longopts" -n "$(basename $0)" -- "$@")
opts=$(posix_getopt "$shortopts" "$longopts" "$@")
if [ $? -eq 0 ]; then
    #eval set -- ${opts}
    eval "set -- ${opts}"
    while [ $# -gt 0 ]; do
        case "$1" in
            ( --                ) shift; break;;
            ( -h|--help         ) help=1; shift; break;;
            ( -v|--version      ) version_help=1; shift; break;;
            ( -d|--directory    ) dir=$2; shift 2;;
            ( -c|--client       ) useclient=1; client=$2; shift 2;;
            ( -s|--server       ) startserver=1; server_name=$2; shift 2;;
            ( -L|--load         ) load=$2; shift 2;;
            ( -D|--delete       ) delete=1; shift;;
        esac
    done
else
    shorthelp=1 # getopt returned (and reported) an error.
fi