下面的代码确实按照我需要的方式工作,但它很丑,过多或其他一些事情。我已经看了公式,并试图写一些解决方案,但我最终得到了类似数量的语句。

在这种情况下,是否有一种数学公式对我有益,或者是否可以接受16个if语句?

为了解释代码,这是一款基于同时回合制的游戏。两名玩家各有四个操作按钮,结果来自一个数组(0-3),但变量“1”和“2”可以赋值任何东西,如果这有帮助的话。结果是,0 =双方都不赢,1 = p1赢,2 = p2赢,3 =双方都赢。

public int fightMath(int one, int two) {

    if(one == 0 && two == 0) { result = 0; }
    else if(one == 0 && two == 1) { result = 0; }
    else if(one == 0 && two == 2) { result = 1; }
    else if(one == 0 && two == 3) { result = 2; }
    else if(one == 1 && two == 0) { result = 0; }
    else if(one == 1 && two == 1) { result = 0; }
    else if(one == 1 && two == 2) { result = 2; }
    else if(one == 1 && two == 3) { result = 1; }
    else if(one == 2 && two == 0) { result = 2; }
    else if(one == 2 && two == 1) { result = 1; }
    else if(one == 2 && two == 2) { result = 3; }
    else if(one == 2 && two == 3) { result = 3; }
    else if(one == 3 && two == 0) { result = 1; }
    else if(one == 3 && two == 1) { result = 2; }
    else if(one == 3 && two == 2) { result = 3; }
    else if(one == 3 && two == 3) { result = 3; }

    return result;
}

当前回答

相反,你可以这样做

   public int fightMath(int one, int two) {
    return Calculate(one,two)

    }


    private int Calculate(int one,int two){

    if (one==0){
        if(two==0){
     //return value}
    }else if (one==1){
   // return value as per condtiion
    }

    }

其他回答

使用常量或枚举使代码更具可读性 尝试将代码拆分为更多的函数 试着利用问题的对称性

这里是一个建议,但在这里使用int型仍然有点难看:

static final int BLOCK_HIGH = 0;
static final int BLOCK_LOW = 1;
static final int ATTACK_HIGH = 2;
static final int ATTACK_LOW = 3;

public static int fightMath(int one, int two) {
    boolean player1Wins = handleAttack(one, two);
    boolean player2Wins = handleAttack(two, one);
    return encodeResult(player1Wins, player2Wins); 
}



private static boolean handleAttack(int one, int two) {
     return one == ATTACK_HIGH && two != BLOCK_HIGH
        || one == ATTACK_LOW && two != BLOCK_LOW
        || one == BLOCK_HIGH && two == ATTACK_HIGH
        || one == BLOCK_LOW && two == ATTACK_LOW;

}

private static int encodeResult(boolean player1Wins, boolean player2Wins) {
    return (player1Wins ? 1 : 0) + (player2Wins ? 2 : 0);
}

使用结构化类型作为输入和输出会更好。输入实际上有两个字段:位置和类型(阻挡或攻击)。输出也有两个字段:player1Wins和player2Wins。将其编码为单个整数会使代码更难阅读。

class PlayerMove {
    PlayerMovePosition pos;
    PlayerMoveType type;
}

enum PlayerMovePosition {
    HIGH,LOW
}

enum PlayerMoveType {
    BLOCK,ATTACK
}

class AttackResult {
    boolean player1Wins;
    boolean player2Wins;

    public AttackResult(boolean player1Wins, boolean player2Wins) {
        this.player1Wins = player1Wins;
        this.player2Wins = player2Wins;
    }
}

AttackResult fightMath(PlayerMove a, PlayerMove b) {
    return new AttackResult(isWinningMove(a, b), isWinningMove(b, a));
}

boolean isWinningMove(PlayerMove a, PlayerMove b) {
    return a.type == PlayerMoveType.ATTACK && !successfulBlock(b, a)
            || successfulBlock(a, b);
}

boolean successfulBlock(PlayerMove a, PlayerMove b) {
    return a.type == PlayerMoveType.BLOCK 
            && b.type == PlayerMoveType.ATTACK 
            && a.pos == b.pos;
}

不幸的是,Java并不擅长表达这类数据类型。

我没有使用Java的经验,所以可能会有一些错字。请将此代码视为伪代码。

我会选择一个简单的开关。为此,您需要一个单一的数字求值。然而,对于这种情况,由于0 <= one < 4 <= 9和0 <= two < 4 <= 9,我们可以将这两个整型都转换为简单的整型,方法是1乘以10再加上2。然后在结果数字中使用一个开关,就像这样:

public int fightMath(int one, int two) {
    // Convert one and two to a single variable in base 10
    int evaluate = one * 10 + two;

    switch(evaluate) {
        // I'd consider a comment in each line here and in the original code
        // for clarity
        case 0: result = 0; break;
        case 1: result = 0; break;
        case 1: result = 0; break;
        case 2: result = 1; break;
        case 3: result = 2; break;
        case 10: result = 0; break;
        case 11: result = 0; break;
        case 12: result = 2; break;
        case 13: result = 1; break;
        case 20: result = 2; break;
        case 21: result = 1; break;
        case 22: result = 3; break;
        case 23: result = 3; break;
        case 30: result = 1; break;
        case 31: result = 2; break;
        case 32: result = 3; break;
        case 33: result = 3; break;
    }

    return result;
}

还有另一个简单的方法,我只是想指出一个理论代码。然而,我不会使用它,因为它有一些额外的复杂性,你通常不想处理。额外的复杂性来自于以4为基数,因为计数是0、1、2、3、10、11、12、13、20,……

public int fightMath(int one, int two) {
    // Convert one and two to a single variable in base 4
    int evaluate = one * 4 + two;

    allresults = new int[] { 0, 0, 1, 2, 0, 0, 2, 1, 2, 1, 3, 3, 1, 2, 3, 3 };

    return allresults[evaluate];
}

这只是额外的说明,以防我在Java中遗漏了一些东西。在PHP中我会这样做:

function fightMath($one, $two) {
    // Convert one and two to a single variable in base 4
    $evaluate = $one * 10 + $two;

    $allresults = array(
         0 => 0,  1 => 0,  2 => 1,  3 => 2,
        10 => 0, 11 => 0, 12 => 2, 13 => 1,
        20 => 2, 21 => 1, 22 => 3, 23 => 3,
        30 => 1, 31 => 2, 32 => 3, 33 => 3 );

    return $allresults[$evaluate];
}
((two&2)*(1+((one^two)&1))+(one&2)*(2-((one^two)&1)))/2

我会使用Map, HashMap或TreeMap

特别是当参数不是0 <= X < N形式时

就像一组随机的正整数。

Code

public class MyMap
{
    private TreeMap<String,Integer> map;

    public MyMap ()
    {
        map = new TreeMap<String,Integer> ();
    }

    public void put (int key1, int key2, Integer value)
    {
        String key = (key1+":"+key2);

        map.put(key, new Integer(value));
    }

    public Integer get (int key1, int key2)
    {
        String key = (key1+":"+key2);

        return map.get(key);
    }
}

除了JAB之外,我不喜欢任何提出的解决方案。其他方法都不容易阅读代码和理解正在计算的内容。

以下是我如何编写这段代码——我只会c#,不懂Java,但你可以想象:

const bool t = true;
const bool f = false;
static readonly bool[,] attackResult = {
    { f, f, t, f }, 
    { f, f, f, t },
    { f, t, t, t },
    { t, f, t, t }
};
[Flags] enum HitResult 
{ 
    Neither = 0,
    PlayerOne = 1,
    PlayerTwo = 2,
    Both = PlayerOne | PlayerTwo
}
static HitResult ResolveAttack(int one, int two)
{
    return 
        (attackResult[one, two] ? HitResult.PlayerOne : HitResult.Neither) | 
        (attackResult[two, one] ? HitResult.PlayerTwo : HitResult.Neither);
}    

现在,这里计算的内容更加清楚了:这强调了我们正在计算谁受到了什么攻击,并返回两个结果。

然而,这可能会更好;布尔数组有点不透明。我喜欢表格查找方法,但我更倾向于以一种能够明确游戏语义的方式来编写它。也就是说,与其“攻击为零,防御为一,结果是没有命中”,不如找到一种方法,让代码更清楚地暗示“低踢攻击和低阻挡防御,结果是没有命中”。让代码反映游戏的业务逻辑。