当我试图从一个片段导航到另一个片段时,我遇到了新的Android导航架构组件的问题,我得到了这个奇怪的错误:

java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: navigation destination XXX
is unknown to this NavController

其他导航都很好,除了这个。

我使用Fragment的findNavController()函数来访问NavController。

任何帮助都将不胜感激。


当前回答

您可以在导航之前检查请求导航的Fragment是否仍然是当前目的地,从这个要点出发。

它基本上是在片段上设置一个标记,以便稍后进行查找。

/**
 * Returns true if the navigation controller is still pointing at 'this' fragment, or false if it already navigated away.
 */
fun Fragment.mayNavigate(): Boolean {

    val navController = findNavController()
    val destinationIdInNavController = navController.currentDestination?.id
    val destinationIdOfThisFragment = view?.getTag(R.id.tag_navigation_destination_id) ?: destinationIdInNavController

    // check that the navigation graph is still in 'this' fragment, if not then the app already navigated:
    if (destinationIdInNavController == destinationIdOfThisFragment) {
        view?.setTag(R.id.tag_navigation_destination_id, destinationIdOfThisFragment)
        return true
    } else {
        Log.d("FragmentExtensions", "May not navigate: current destination is not the current fragment.")
        return false
    }
}

R.id。Tag_navigation_destination_id只是一个id,必须添加到ids.xml中,以确保它是唯一的。<item name="tag_navigation_destination_id" type="id" />

更多关于bug和解决方案的信息,以及navigateSafe(…)扩展方法在“修复可怕的”…是未知的NavController”

其他回答

我在我的项目中也有同样的问题,首先我试图在视图上触发导航动作的点击,但经过一些实验后,我发现在真正缓慢的设备上,debounce应该是一个非常高的值,导致应用程序对快速设备的用户感到缓慢。

所以我为NavController提出了以下扩展,我认为它符合原始的API,并且易于使用:

fun NavController.safeNavigate(directions: NavDirections) {
    try {
        currentDestination?.getAction(directions.actionId) ?: return
        navigate(directions.actionId, directions.arguments, null)
    } catch (e : Exception) {
        logError("Navigation error", e)
    }
}

fun NavController.safeNavigate(directions: NavDirections, navOptions: NavOptions?) {
    try {
        currentDestination?.getAction(directions.actionId) ?: return
        navigate(directions.actionId, directions.arguments, navOptions)
    } catch (e : Exception) {
        logError("Navigation error", e)
    }
}

fun NavController.safeNavigate(directions: NavDirections, navigatorExtras: Navigator.Extras) {
    try {
        currentDestination?.getAction(directions.actionId) ?: return
        navigate(directions.actionId, directions.arguments, null, navigatorExtras)
    } catch (e : Exception) {
        logError("Navigation error", e)
    }
}

请注意,我正在使用SafeArgs和NavDirections。这些函数检查操作从当前目的地是否有效,并且仅在操作不为空时进行导航。如果Navigation库每次都返回正确的操作,那么try catch部分就不需要了,但我希望消除所有可能的崩溃。

您可以在导航之前检查请求导航的Fragment是否仍然是当前目的地,从这个要点出发。

它基本上是在片段上设置一个标记,以便稍后进行查找。

/**
 * Returns true if the navigation controller is still pointing at 'this' fragment, or false if it already navigated away.
 */
fun Fragment.mayNavigate(): Boolean {

    val navController = findNavController()
    val destinationIdInNavController = navController.currentDestination?.id
    val destinationIdOfThisFragment = view?.getTag(R.id.tag_navigation_destination_id) ?: destinationIdInNavController

    // check that the navigation graph is still in 'this' fragment, if not then the app already navigated:
    if (destinationIdInNavController == destinationIdOfThisFragment) {
        view?.setTag(R.id.tag_navigation_destination_id, destinationIdOfThisFragment)
        return true
    } else {
        Log.d("FragmentExtensions", "May not navigate: current destination is not the current fragment.")
        return false
    }
}

R.id。Tag_navigation_destination_id只是一个id,必须添加到ids.xml中,以确保它是唯一的。<item name="tag_navigation_destination_id" type="id" />

更多关于bug和解决方案的信息,以及navigateSafe(…)扩展方法在“修复可怕的”…是未知的NavController”

用try-catch(简单的方法)包装你的导航调用,或者确保在短时间内只有一个导航调用。这个问题可能不会消失。复制更大的代码片段在你的应用程序和尝试。

你好。基于上面的一些有用的回答,我想分享我的解决方案,可以扩展。

下面是导致我的应用程序崩溃的代码:

@Override
public void onListItemClicked(ListItem item) {
    Bundle bundle = new Bundle();
    bundle.putParcelable(SomeFragment.LIST_KEY, item);
    Navigation.findNavController(recyclerView).navigate(R.id.action_listFragment_to_listItemInfoFragment, bundle);
}

一个很容易重现这个错误的方法是用多个手指在项目列表上点击,点击每个项目就会在导航到新屏幕上解决(基本上和人们注意到的一样——在很短的时间内点击两次或两次以上)。我注意到:

第一次导航调用总是正常工作; 第二个和所有其他的导航方法调用在IllegalArgumentException中解析。

在我看来,这种情况可能会经常出现。因为重复代码是一种糟糕的做法,有一点影响总是好的,我想到了下一个解决方案:

public class NavigationHandler {

public static void navigate(View view, @IdRes int destination) {
    navigate(view, destination, /* args */null);
}

/**
 * Performs a navigation to given destination using {@link androidx.navigation.NavController}
 * found via {@param view}. Catches {@link IllegalArgumentException} that may occur due to
 * multiple invocations of {@link androidx.navigation.NavController#navigate} in short period of time.
 * The navigation must work as intended.
 *
 * @param view        the view to search from
 * @param destination destination id
 * @param args        arguments to pass to the destination
 */
public static void navigate(View view, @IdRes int destination, @Nullable Bundle args) {
    try {
        Navigation.findNavController(view).navigate(destination, args);
    } catch (IllegalArgumentException e) {
        Log.e(NavigationHandler.class.getSimpleName(), "Multiple navigation attempts handled.");
    }
}

}

因此上面的代码只改变了一行:

Navigation.findNavController(recyclerView).navigate(R.id.action_listFragment_to_listItemInfoFragment, bundle);

:

NavigationHandler.navigate(recyclerView, R.id.action_listFragment_to_listItemInfoFragment, bundle);

它甚至变得更短了一点。代码在发生崩溃的确切位置进行了测试。没有经历过,并将使用相同的解决方案为其他导航,以避免同样的错误进一步。

任何想法都欢迎!

到底是什么导致了崩溃

记住,当我们使用方法navigation . findnavcontroller时,我们使用相同的导航图、导航控制器和后堆栈。

We always get the same controller and graph here. When navigate(R.id.my_next_destination) is called graph and back-stack changes almost instantly while UI is not updated yet. Just not fast enough, but that is ok. After back-stack has changed the navigation system receives the second navigate(R.id.my_next_destination) call. Since back-stack has changed we now operate relative to the top fragment in the stack. The top fragment is the fragment you navigate to by using R.id.my_next_destination, but it does not contain next any further destinations with ID R.id.my_next_destination. Thus you get IllegalArgumentException because of the ID that the fragment knows nothing about.

这个确切的错误可以在NavController.java方法findDestination中找到。

为了避免这种崩溃,我的一个同事写了一个小库,它公开了一个SafeNavController,一个围绕NavController的包装器,并处理由于多个导航命令同时发生崩溃的情况。

这里有一篇关于整个问题和解决方案的短文。

你可以在这里找到图书馆。

I am calling the 2.3.1 Navigation and the same error occurs when the application configuration changes. When the cause of the problem was found through Debug, the GaphId in NavHostFragment did not take effect as the ID currently set by calling navController.setGraph(). The GraphId of NavHostFragment can only be obtained from the <androidx.fragment.app.FragmentContainerView/> tag. At this time, this problem will occur if there are multiple GraphIds dynamically set in your code. When the interface is restored, the Destination cannot be found in the cached GraphId. You can solve this problem by manually specifying the value of mGraphId in NavHostFragment through reflection when switching Graph.

navController.setGraph(R.navigation.home_book_navigation);
try {
    Field graphIdField = hostFragment.getClass().getDeclaredField("mGraphId");
    graphIdField.setAccessible(true);
    graphIdField.set(navHostFragment, R.navigation.home_book_navigation);
} catch (NoSuchFieldException | IllegalAccessException e) {
    e.printStackTrace();
}