我为我的应用程序不期望的每个条件创建了异常。UserNameNotValidException, PasswordNotCorrectException等。
然而,我被告知我不应该为这些条件创造例外。在我的UML中,那些是主要流程的异常,那么为什么它不应该是异常呢?
是否有创建异常的指导或最佳实践?
我为我的应用程序不期望的每个条件创建了异常。UserNameNotValidException, PasswordNotCorrectException等。
然而,我被告知我不应该为这些条件创造例外。在我的UML中,那些是主要流程的异常,那么为什么它不应该是异常呢?
是否有创建异常的指导或最佳实践?
当前回答
一个经验法则是在您通常无法预测的情况下使用异常。例如数据库连接、磁盘上丢失的文件等。对于您可以预测的场景,例如用户试图使用错误的密码登录,您应该使用返回布尔值的函数,并知道如何优雅地处理这种情况。您不希望仅仅因为有人输入了密码错误而抛出异常,从而突然结束执行。
其他回答
在决定异常是否合适时,需要考虑一些有用的事情:
what level of code you want to have run after the exception candidate occurs - that is, how many layers of the call stack should unwind. You generally want to handle an exception as close as possible to where it occurs. For username/password validation, you would normally handle failures in the same block of code, rather than letting an exception bubble up. So an exception is probably not appropriate. (OTOH, after three failed login attempts, control flow may shift elsewhere, and an exception may be appropriate here.) Is this event something you would want to see in an error log? Not every exception is written to an error log, but it's useful to ask whether this entry in an error log would be useful - i.e., you would try to do something about it, or would be the garbage you ignore.
一般来说,你想要为应用程序中可能发生的任何异常抛出一个"异常"
在您的示例中,这两个异常看起来都是通过密码/用户名验证调用的。在这种情况下,有人会输入错误的用户名/密码并不是什么例外。
它们是UML主要流程的“例外”,但在处理过程中是更多的“分支”。
如果您试图访问您的passwd文件或数据库,但无法访问,这将是一个异常情况,并需要抛出异常。
我有三种情况。
Bad or missing input should not be an exception. Use both client side js and server side regex to detect, set attributes and forward back to the same page with messages. The AppException. This is usually an exception that you detect and throw with in your code. In other words these are ones you expect (the file does not exist). Log it, set the message, and forward back to the general error page. This page usually has a bit of info about what happened. The unexpected Exception. These are the ones you don't know about. Log it with details and forward them to a general error page.
希望这能有所帮助
我想说的是,如果发生了意想不到的行为,应该抛出异常。
比如试图更新或删除一个不存在的实体。它应该在异常可以处理并且有意义的地方被捕获。如果要以另一种方式继续工作,请在Api级别上添加日志记录或返回特定的结果。
如果您期望某些事情是这样的,那么您应该构建代码来检查并确保它是正确的。
You may use a little bit generic exceptions for that conditions. For e.g. ArgumentException is meant to be used when anything goes wrong with the parameters to a method (with the exception of ArgumentNullException). Generally you would not need exceptions like LessThanZeroException, NotPrimeNumberException etc. Think of the user of your method. The number of the conditions that she will want to handle specifically is equal to the number of the type of the exceptions that your method needs to throw. This way, you can determine how detailed exceptions you will have.
顺便说一下,总是尝试为库的用户提供一些避免异常的方法。TryParse就是一个很好的例子,它的存在使你不必使用int。解析并捕获异常。在您的情况下,您可能希望提供一些方法来检查用户名是否有效或密码是否正确,这样您的用户(或您)就不必进行大量异常处理。这将有望产生更易于阅读的代码和更好的性能。