是否可以在ES6类中创建私有属性?
举个例子。 如何阻止访问instance.property?
class Something {
constructor(){
this.property = "test";
}
}
var instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"
是否可以在ES6类中创建私有属性?
举个例子。 如何阻止访问instance.property?
class Something {
constructor(){
this.property = "test";
}
}
var instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"
当前回答
我现在听到的建议是使用WeakMaps来保存私人数据,以供其他看客参考。
下面是一个更清晰、有效的例子:
function storePrivateProperties(a, b, c, d) {
let privateData = new WeakMap;
// unique object as key, weak map can only accept object as key, when key is no longer referened, garbage collector claims the key-value
let keyA = {}, keyB = {}, keyC = {}, keyD = {};
privateData.set(keyA, a);
privateData.set(keyB, b);
privateData.set(keyC, c);
privateData.set(keyD, d);
return {
logPrivateKey(key) {
switch(key) {
case "a":
console.log(privateData.get(keyA));
break;
case "b":
console.log(privateData.get(keyB));
break;
case "c":
console.log(privateData.get(keyC));
break;
case "d":
console.log(privateData.set(keyD));
break;
default:
console.log(`There is no value for ${key}`)
}
}
}
}
其他回答
答案是“不”。但是你可以像这样创建对属性的私有访问:
使用模块。模块中的所有内容都是私有的,除非使用export关键字将其设为公有。 在模块内部,使用函数闭包:http://www.kirupa.com/html5/closures_in_javascript.htm
(可以使用符号来确保隐私的建议在ES6规范的早期版本中是正确的,但现在不再是这样:https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/es-discuss/2014-January/035604.html和https://stackoverflow.com/a/22280202/1282216。有关符号和隐私的详细讨论,请参阅:https://curiosity-driven.org/private-properties-in-javascript)
不同的“私人”方式
Instead of fighting against the fact that private visibility is currently unavailable in ES6, I decided to take a more practical approach that does just fine if your IDE supports JSDoc (e.g., Webstorm). The idea is to use the @private tag. As far as development goes, the IDE will prevent you from accessing any private member from outside its class. Works pretty well for me and it's been really useful for hiding internal methods so the auto-complete feature shows me just what the class really meant to expose. Here's an example:
class Something {
constructor(){
var _property = "test";
Object.defineProperty(this, "property", {
get: function(){ return _property}
});
}
}
var instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"
instance.property = "can read from outside, but can't write";
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"
在JS中获得真正隐私的唯一方法是通过作用域,因此不可能有一个属性是this的成员,只能在组件内部访问。在ES6中存储真正私有数据的最佳方法是使用WeakMap。
const privateProp1 = new WeakMap();
const privateProp2 = new WeakMap();
class SomeClass {
constructor() {
privateProp1.set(this, "I am Private1");
privateProp2.set(this, "I am Private2");
this.publicVar = "I am public";
this.publicMethod = () => {
console.log(privateProp1.get(this), privateProp2.get(this))
};
}
printPrivate() {
console.log(privateProp1.get(this));
}
}
显然,这可能是一个缓慢的,肯定是丑陋的,但它确实提供了隐私。
请记住,即使这样也不是完美的,因为Javascript是动态的。有人仍然可以这样做
var oldSet = WeakMap.prototype.set;
WeakMap.prototype.set = function(key, value){
// Store 'this', 'key', and 'value'
return oldSet.call(this, key, value);
};
为了在值被存储时捕获它们,所以如果你想格外小心的话,你需要捕获一个对.set和.get的本地引用来显式使用,而不是依赖于可覆盖的原型。
const {set: WMSet, get: WMGet} = WeakMap.prototype;
const privateProp1 = new WeakMap();
const privateProp2 = new WeakMap();
class SomeClass {
constructor() {
WMSet.call(privateProp1, this, "I am Private1");
WMSet.call(privateProp2, this, "I am Private2");
this.publicVar = "I am public";
this.publicMethod = () => {
console.log(WMGet.call(privateProp1, this), WMGet.call(privateProp2, this))
};
}
printPrivate() {
console.log(WMGet.call(privateProp1, this));
}
}
我有一个解决办法,它很简单…虽然性能不是问题…但它确实有效,而且效果很好。
诀窍在于,在私有属性和函数被建立和标准化/采用之前,需要另一种解决方案,这是另一种解决方案…
class ClassPrivateProperties {
constructor(instance) {
const $this = instance;
let properties = {};
this.prop = (key, value = undefined) => {
if (!value) {
return properties[key];
} else {
properties[key] = value;
}
};
this.clear = instance => {
if ($this === instance) {
properties = {};
return true;
} else {
return false;
}
}
}
}
这是一个示例用法,可以是什么(如果你使用上面的感觉自由,使它更好)
class Test {
constructor() {
this._privateProps = new ClassPrivateProperties(this);
}
property(key, value = undefined) {
if (!value) {
return this._privateProps.prop(key);
} else {
this._privateProps.prop(key, value);
}
}
clear() { return this._privateProps.clear(this); }
}
const test = new test;
test.property('myKey','some value here');
console.log(test.property('myKey'));
就像我提到的,这个问题不是最好的,但它工作,使属性真正的私有。