我在学校里很难理解递归。每当教授谈到它的时候,我似乎都懂了,但当我自己尝试的时候,它完全震撼了我的大脑。

我整晚都在尝试着解决《Towers of Hanoi》这款游戏,结果完全出乎我的意料。我的课本只有大约30页关于递归的内容,所以它不是很有用。有人知道哪些书籍或资源可以帮助澄清这个话题吗?


当前回答

递归函数就像弹簧,每次调用都要压缩一点。在每一步中,您将一些信息(当前上下文)放在堆栈上。当到达最后一步时,释放弹簧,立即收集所有值(上下文)!

不确定这个比喻是否有效…: -)

无论如何,除了经典的例子(阶乘是最糟糕的例子,因为它效率低,很容易被平化,Fibonacci, Hanoi…),这些都有点人为(我很少,如果有的话,在实际编程案例中使用它们),看看它真正被使用的地方是有趣的。

A very common case is to walk a tree (or a graph, but trees are more common, in general). For example, a folder hierarchy: to list the files, you iterate on them. If you find a sub-directory, the function listing the files call itself with the new folder as argument. When coming back from listing this new folder (and its sub-folders!), it resumes its context, to the next file (or folder). Another concrete case is when drawing a hierarchy of GUI components: it is common to have containers, like panes, to hold components which can be panes too, or compound components, etc. The painting routine calls recursively the paint function of each component, which calls the paint function of all the components it holds, etc.

不确定我是否很清楚,但我喜欢展示现实世界中教材的使用,因为这是我过去偶然发现的东西。

其他回答

我认为这个非常简单的方法可以帮助你理解递归。该方法将调用自身,直到某个条件为真,然后返回:

function writeNumbers( aNumber ){
 write(aNumber);
 if( aNumber > 0 ){
  writeNumbers( aNumber - 1 );
 }
 else{
  return;
 }
}

这个函数将输出从你输入的第一个数字到0的所有数字。因此:

writeNumbers( 10 );
//This wil write: 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
//and then stop because aNumber is no longer larger then 0

基本上发生的情况是writeNumbers(10)将写入10,然后调用writeNumbers(9),后者将写入9,然后调用writeNumber(8)等。直到writeNumbers(1)写入1,然后调用writeNumbers(0),这将写入0 butt将不会调用writeNumbers(-1);

这段代码本质上与以下代码相同:

for(i=10; i>0; i--){
 write(i);
}

你可能会问为什么要用递归,如果for循环本质上是一样的。当你需要嵌套for循环但不知道它们嵌套的深度时,你通常会使用递归。例如,当从嵌套数组中打印项目时:

var nestedArray = Array('Im a string', 
                        Array('Im a string nested in an array', 'me too!'),
                        'Im a string again',
                        Array('More nesting!',
                              Array('nested even more!')
                              ),
                        'Im the last string');
function printArrayItems( stringOrArray ){
 if(typeof stringOrArray === 'Array'){
   for(i=0; i<stringOrArray.length; i++){ 
     printArrayItems( stringOrArray[i] );
   }
 }
 else{
   write( stringOrArray );
 }
}

printArrayItems( stringOrArray );
//this will write:
//'Im a string' 'Im a string nested in an array' 'me too' 'Im a string again'
//'More nesting' 'Nested even more' 'Im the last string'

这个函数可以接受一个可以嵌套到100层的数组,而你写一个for循环就需要你嵌套它100次:

for(i=0; i<nestedArray.length; i++){
 if(typeof nestedArray[i] == 'Array'){
  for(a=0; i<nestedArray[i].length; a++){
   if(typeof nestedArray[i][a] == 'Array'){
    for(b=0; b<nestedArray[i][a].length; b++){
     //This would be enough for the nestedAaray we have now, but you would have
     //to nest the for loops even more if you would nest the array another level
     write( nestedArray[i][a][b] );
    }//end for b
   }//endif typeod nestedArray[i][a] == 'Array'
   else{ write( nestedArray[i][a] ); }
  }//end for a
 }//endif typeod nestedArray[i] == 'Array'
 else{ write( nestedArray[i] ); }
}//end for i

如你所见,递归方法要好得多。

Ouch. I tried to figure out the Towers of Hanoi last year. The tricky thing about TOH is it's not a simple example of recursion - you have nested recursions which also change the roles of towers on each call. The only way I could get it to make sense was to literally visualize the movement of the rings in my mind's eye, and verbalize what the recursive call would be. I would start with a single ring, then two, then three. I actually ordered the game on the internet. It took me maybe two or three days of cracking my brains to get it.

http://javabat.com是一个有趣而令人兴奋的练习递归的地方。他们的例子开始时相当简单,然后逐步扩展(如果你想这么做的话)。注意:他们的方法是在实践中学习。这是我写的一个递归函数,用来替换for循环。

for循环:

public printBar(length)
{
  String holder = "";
  for (int index = 0; i < length; i++)
  {
    holder += "*"
  }
  return holder;
}

这是做同样事情的递归。(请注意,我们重载了第一个方法,以确保它像上面那样使用)。我们还有另一种方法来维护索引(类似于上面的for语句)。递归函数必须维护自己的索引。

public String printBar(int Length) // Method, to call the recursive function
{
  printBar(length, 0);
}

public String printBar(int length, int index) //Overloaded recursive method
{
  // To get a better idea of how this works without a for loop
  // you can also replace this if/else with the for loop and
  // operationally, it should do the same thing.
  if (index >= length)
    return "";
  else
    return "*" + printBar(length, index + 1); // Make recursive call
}

简而言之,递归是一种编写更少代码的好方法。在后面的printBar中,请注意我们有一个if语句。如果我们的条件已经达到,我们将退出递归并返回到前一个方法,该方法返回到前一个方法,等等。如果我发送一个printBar(8),我得到********。我希望通过一个简单函数的例子,它做的事情与for循环相同,这可能会有所帮助。不过,您可以在Java Bat中进行更多的练习。

子函数隐式地使用递归,例如:

去迪士尼乐园自驾游

我们到了吗?(没有) 我们到了吗?(很快) 我们到了吗?(快了……) 我们到了吗? 我们到了吗?(!!!!!)

这时孩子就睡着了……

这个倒数函数是一个简单的例子:

倒计时()函数 { 返回(参数[0]> 0 ? ( Console.log(参数[0]),倒计时(参数[0]- 1)): “完成” ); } 倒计时(10);

霍夫施塔特定律也适用于软件项目。

The essence of human language is, according to Chomsky, the ability of finite brains to produce what he considers to be infinite grammars. By this he means not only that there is no upper limit on what we can say, but that there is no upper limit on the number of sentences our language has, there's no upper limit on the size of any particular sentence. Chomsky has claimed that the fundamental tool that underlies all of this creativity of human language is recursion: the ability for one phrase to reoccur inside another phrase of the same type. If I say "John's brother's house", I have a noun, "house", which occurs in a noun phrase, "brother's house", and that noun phrase occurs in another noun phrase, "John's brother's house". This makes a lot of sense, and it's an interesting property of human language.

参考文献

递归与人类思想

当使用递归解时,我总是尝试:

首先建立基本情况,即。 当n = 1的阶乘 试着想出一个一般的规则 对于其他情况

还有不同类型的递归解,分而治之的方法对分形和其他方法很有用。

如果你能先解决一些简单的问题,只是为了掌握窍门,这也会有帮助。一些例子是求解阶乘和生成第n个斐波那契数。

作为参考,我强烈推荐Robert Sedgewick的算法。

希望这能有所帮助。祝你好运。