有人能告诉我同步方法比同步块的优势与一个例子吗?
当前回答
来自Java规范摘要: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/andru/javaspec/17.doc.html
The synchronized statement (§14.17) computes a reference to an object; it then attempts to perform a lock action on that object and does not proceed further until the lock action has successfully completed. ... A synchronized method (§8.4.3.5) automatically performs a lock action when it is invoked; its body is not executed until the lock action has successfully completed. If the method is an instance method, it locks the lock associated with the instance for which it was invoked (that is, the object that will be known as this during execution of the body of the method). If the method is static, it locks the lock associated with the Class object that represents the class in which the method is defined. ...
基于这些描述,我想说以前的大多数答案都是正确的,同步方法可能对静态方法特别有用,否则您必须弄清楚如何获得“表示定义方法的类的Class对象”。
编辑:我原本以为这些是对实际Java规范的引用。澄清一下,本页只是对规范的总结/解释
其他回答
大多数情况下,我使用它来同步对列表或映射的访问,但我不想阻止对对象的所有方法的访问。
在下面的代码中,修改列表的线程不会阻塞等待正在修改映射的线程。如果方法在对象上是同步的,那么每个方法都必须等待,即使它们所做的修改不会冲突。
private List<Foo> myList = new ArrayList<Foo>();
private Map<String,Bar) myMap = new HashMap<String,Bar>();
public void put( String s, Bar b ) {
synchronized( myMap ) {
myMap.put( s,b );
// then some thing that may take a while like a database access or RPC or notifying listeners
}
}
public void hasKey( String s, ) {
synchronized( myMap ) {
myMap.hasKey( s );
}
}
public void add( Foo f ) {
synchronized( myList ) {
myList.add( f );
// then some thing that may take a while like a database access or RPC or notifying listeners
}
}
public Thing getMedianFoo() {
Foo med = null;
synchronized( myList ) {
Collections.sort(myList);
med = myList.get(myList.size()/2);
}
return med;
}
主要的区别是,如果你使用同步块,你可以锁定一个对象,而不是这个,这允许更灵活。
假设您有一个消息队列和多个消息生产者和消费者。我们不希望生产者相互干扰,但是消费者应该能够检索消息,而不必等待生产者。 我们只需要创建一个对象
Object writeLock = new Object();
从现在开始,每当制作人想要添加一条新信息时,我们就会锁定它:
synchronized(writeLock){
// do something
}
因此,消费者可能仍会阅读,而生产者将被锁定。
来自Java规范摘要: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/andru/javaspec/17.doc.html
The synchronized statement (§14.17) computes a reference to an object; it then attempts to perform a lock action on that object and does not proceed further until the lock action has successfully completed. ... A synchronized method (§8.4.3.5) automatically performs a lock action when it is invoked; its body is not executed until the lock action has successfully completed. If the method is an instance method, it locks the lock associated with the instance for which it was invoked (that is, the object that will be known as this during execution of the body of the method). If the method is static, it locks the lock associated with the Class object that represents the class in which the method is defined. ...
基于这些描述,我想说以前的大多数答案都是正确的,同步方法可能对静态方法特别有用,否则您必须弄清楚如何获得“表示定义方法的类的Class对象”。
编辑:我原本以为这些是对实际Java规范的引用。澄清一下,本页只是对规范的总结/解释
关于使用同步块的重要提示:小心你使用的锁对象!
上面user2277816的代码片段说明了这一点,将字符串字面值的引用用作锁定对象。 意识到字符串字面值在Java中是自动互缩的,您应该开始看到问题所在:在字面值“锁”上同步的每段代码都共享同一个锁!这很容易导致完全不相关的代码段发生死锁。
您需要注意的不仅仅是String对象。装箱的原语也是一种危险,因为autoboxing和valueOf方法可以重用相同的对象,这取决于值。
有关更多信息,请参阅: https://www.securecoding.cert.org/confluence/display/java/LCK01-J.+Do+not+synchronize+on+objects+that+may+be+reused
在同步方法的情况下,锁将在对象上获得。但是如果你使用同步块,你可以选择指定一个对象来获取锁。
例子:
Class Example {
String test = "abc";
// lock will be acquired on String test object.
synchronized (test) {
// do something
}
lock will be acquired on Example Object
public synchronized void testMethod() {
// do some thing
}
}
推荐文章
- 在Java中从字符串中提取数字
- 套接字的连接超时和读超时之间的区别是什么?
- Java整数到字节数组
- 如何设置Windows环境下Java的环境变量
- Java Swing revalidate() vs repaint()
- Java中文件中的行数
- 指定的子节点已经有一个父节点。你必须先在子对象的父对象上调用removeView() (Android)
- 对于一个布尔字段,它的getter/setter的命名约定是什么?
- 如何获得当前屏幕方向?
- 如何在Android中渲染PDF文件
- 如何计算一个元素在列表中出现的次数
- c++中类似于java的instanceof
- 我如何解决错误“minCompileSdk(31)指定在一个依赖的AAR元数据”在本机Java或Kotlin?
- 如何POST表单数据与Spring RestTemplate?
- Mockito中检测到未完成的存根