我有一个纯JavaScript承诺(内置实现或poly-fill):

var promise = new promise(函数(解析,拒绝){/*…* /});

从规范来看,Promise可以是:

" settle "和" resolved " “解决”和“拒绝” “等待”

我有一个用例,我希望同步审问承诺并确定:

承诺达成了吗? 如果是,承诺解决了吗?

我知道我可以使用#then()来安排在Promise改变状态后异步执行的工作。我不是在问你该怎么做。

这个问题是关于Promise状态的同步询问。我怎样才能做到这一点呢?


当前回答

这一基本功能的缺失确实令人恼火。如果你正在使用node.js,那么我知道有两种变通方法,它们都不太漂亮。下面的两个代码段实现了相同的API:

> Promise.getInfo( 42 )                         // not a promise
{ status: 'fulfilled', value: 42 }
> Promise.getInfo( Promise.resolve(42) )        // fulfilled
{ status: 'fulfilled', value: 42 }
> Promise.getInfo( Promise.reject(42) )         // rejected
{ status: 'rejected', value: 42 }
> Promise.getInfo( p = new Promise(() => {}) )  // unresolved
{ status: 'pending' }
> Promise.getInfo( Promise.resolve(p) )         // resolved but pending
{ status: 'pending' }

用这两种方法似乎都无法区分最后两种承诺状态。

1. 使用V8调试API

这和util是一样的。检查使用。

const Debug = require('vm').runInDebugContext('Debug');

Promise.getInfo = function( arg ) {
    let mirror = Debug.MakeMirror( arg, true );
    if( ! mirror.isPromise() )
        return { status: 'fulfilled', value: arg };
    let status = mirror.status();
    if( status === 'pending' )
        return { status };
    if( status === 'resolved' )  // fix terminology fuck-up
        status = 'fulfilled';
    let value = mirror.promiseValue().value();
    return { status, value };
};

2. 同步运行微任务

这避免了调试API,但是会导致所有挂起的微任务和进程,从而产生一些可怕的语义。nextTick回调将同步运行。它还有一个副作用,就是防止被检查的承诺触发“未处理的承诺拒绝”错误。

Promise.getInfo = function( arg ) {
    const pending = {};
    let status, value;
    Promise.race([ arg, pending ]).then(
        x => { status = 'fulfilled'; value = x; },
        x => { status = 'rejected'; value = x; }
    );
    process._tickCallback();  // run microtasks right now
    if( value === pending )
        return { status: 'pending' };
    return { status, value };
};

其他回答

对于原生JavaScript承诺,不存在这样的同步检查API。用本土的承诺是不可能做到的。规范没有指定这样的方法。

用户域库可以做到这一点,如果你的目标是一个特定的引擎(比如v8),并且可以访问平台代码(也就是说,你可以在核心中编写代码),那么你可以使用特定的工具(比如私有符号)来实现这一点。这是非常具体的,但不是在用户领域。

你可以和Promise.resolve赛跑 它不是同步的,但现在就发生了

function promiseState(p, isPending, isResolved, isRejected) {
  Promise.race([p, Promise.resolve('a value that p should not return')]).then(function(value) {
    if (value == 'a value that p should not return') {
      (typeof(isPending) === 'function') && isPending();
    }else {
      (typeof(isResolved) === 'function') && isResolved(value);
    }
  }, function(reason) {
    (typeof(isRejected) === 'function') && isRejected(reason);
  });
}

一个用于测试的小脚本,并理解异步的含义

var startTime = Date.now() - 100000;//padding trick "100001".slice(1) => 00001
function log(msg) {
  console.log((""+(Date.now() - startTime)).slice(1) + ' ' + msg);
  return msg;//for chaining promises
};

function prefix(pref) { return function (value) { log(pref + value); return value; };}

function delay(ms) {
  return function (value) {
    var startTime = Date.now();
    while(Date.now() - startTime < ms) {}
    return value;//for chaining promises
  };
}
setTimeout(log, 0,'timeOut 0 ms');
setTimeout(log, 100,'timeOut 100 ms');
setTimeout(log, 200,'timeOut 200 ms');

var p1 = Promise.resolve('One');
var p2 = new Promise(function(resolve, reject) { setTimeout(resolve, 100, "Two"); });
var p3 = Promise.reject("Three");

p3.catch(delay(200)).then(delay(100)).then(prefix('delayed L3 : '));

promiseState(p1, prefix('p1 Is Pending '), prefix('p1 Is Resolved '), prefix('p1 Is Rejected '));
promiseState(p2, prefix('p2 Is Pending '), prefix('p2 Is Resolved '), prefix('p2 Is Rejected '));
promiseState(p3, prefix('p3 Is Pending '), prefix('p3 Is Resolved '), prefix('p3 Is Rejected '));

p1.then(prefix('Level 1 : ')).then(prefix('Level 2 : ')).then(prefix('Level 3 : '));
p2.then(prefix('Level 1 : ')).then(prefix('Level 2 : ')).then(prefix('Level 3 : '));
p3.catch(prefix('Level 1 : ')).then(prefix('Level 2 : ')).then(prefix('Level 3 : '));
log('end of promises');
delay(100)();
log('end of script');

延迟(0)的结果(注释在延迟中的while)

00001 end of promises
00001 end of script
00001 Level 1 : One
00001 Level 1 : Three
00001 p1 Is Resolved One
00001 p2 Is Pending undefined
00001 p3 Is Rejected Three
00001 Level 2 : One
00001 Level 2 : Three
00001 delayed L3 : Three
00002 Level 3 : One
00002 Level 3 : Three
00006 timeOut 0 ms
00100 timeOut 100 ms
00100 Level 1 : Two
00100 Level 2 : Two
00101 Level 3 : Two
00189 timeOut 200 ms

与firefox(chrome保持顺序)测试的结果

00000 end of promises
00100 end of script
00300 Level 1 : One
00300 Level 1 : Three
00400 p1 Is Resolved One
00400 p2 Is Pending undefined
00400 p3 Is Rejected Three
00400 Level 2 : One
00400 Level 2 : Three
00400 delayed L3 : Three
00400 Level 3 : One
00400 Level 3 : Three
00406 timeOut 0 ms
00406 timeOut 100 ms
00406 timeOut 200 ms
00406 Level 1 : Two
00407 Level 2 : Two
00407 Level 3 : Two

promise estate make .race and .then:第二级

我浏览了这个问题的解决方案,没有找到一个与我在Node.js中使用的简单方法相对应的解决方案。

我已经定义了一个简单的类PromiseMonitor,它将承诺作为其构造函数的单个参数,并具有一个字符串属性.status,它返回与承诺状态对应的标准字符串值,“pending”,“resolved”或“rejected”,以及四个布尔属性.pending, .resolved, .rejected和.error。只有当.rejected为true并且拒绝回调被传递一个Error对象时,属性. Error才被设置为true。

该类只是在promise上使用.then()来在promise被解决或拒绝时更改PromiseMonitor的状态。它不会干扰原始承诺的任何其他使用。代码如下:

class PromiseMonitor {
    constructor(prm){
        this._status = "pending";
        this._pending = true;
        this._resolved = false;
        this._rejected = false;
        this._error = false;
        prm
            .then( ()=>{  
                        this._status = "resolved"; 
                        this._resolved = true; 
                        this._pending = false; 
                    } 
                , (err)=>{ 
                        this._status = "rejected";
                        this._pending = false;
                        this._rejected = true;
                        this._error = err instanceof Error ? true: false ; 
                    } 
                );
    }

    get status(){ return this._status; };
    get pending(){ return this._pending; };
    get resolved(){ return this._resolved; };
    get rejected(){ return this._rejected; };
    get error(){ return this._error };
};

要监视Promise的状态,只需创建一个PromiseMonitor实例,将Promise作为参数传入,例如:

let promiseObject = functionThatReturnsAPromise();
let promiseMonitor = new PromiseMonitor( promiseObject );

现在您可以同步检查promiseMonitor的所有属性,它将跟踪原始承诺的状态。下面是一个测试脚本,它演示了正在监视的承诺的三种可能的解决方案。

let ticks = 0;
let tickerID = setInterval( ()=>{++ticks; console.log(`..tick ${ticks}`)}, 1000);

async function run(){
    console.log("Start");

    let delay = prmDelay(2000);
    let delayMonitor = new PromiseMonitor(delay);

    // normal handling of delay promise
    delay.then((result)=>( console.log("Normal resolution of delay using .then()") ) );

    console.log("delay at start:\n", delay);
    console.log("delayMonitor at start:\n", delayMonitor);
    await delay;
    console.log("delay finished:\n", delay);
    console.log("delayMonitor finished:\n", delayMonitor);


    console.log("\n\n TEST2: Rejection without an Error test ================================")
    let rejDelay = prmDelay(3000, "reject");
    let rejMonitor = new PromiseMonitor(rejDelay);

    // normal handling of reject result on promise
    rejDelay.then((result)=>( console.log("Normal resolution of rejDelay using .then will not happen") ) 
                    , (err)=>( console.log("Rejection of rejDelay handled using .then")));

    console.log("rejDelay at start:\n", rejDelay);
    console.log("rejMonitor at start:\n", rejMonitor);

    await rejDelay.catch( (err)=>{ console.log( "Caught error using .catch on rejDelay" ); });

    console.log("rejDelay finished:\n", rejDelay);
    console.log("rejMonitor finished:\n", rejMonitor);


    console.log("\n\n TEST3: Rejection with an Error test ================================")
    let errMonitor ;
    let errDelay;
    try{

        errDelay = prmDelay(1000, "error");
        errMonitor = new PromiseMonitor(errDelay);
        
        // normal handling of results of the original promise
        errDelay.then(
            (result)=>{ 
                console.log("Normal expiry of errDelay");
                console.log("Monitor Status is " + errMonitor.status )
            } 
            , (err)=>{
                console.log("** Rejection of errDelay handled using .then()");
                console.log("   Monitor Status is " + errMonitor.status )
            }
        );

        console.log("errDelay at start:\n", errDelay);
        console.log("errMonitor at start:\n", errMonitor);

        await errDelay;

        console.log("**** This should never be run");

    } catch(err) { 

        console.log( "** Caught error on errDelay using try{}catch{}:" ); 
        console.log( "   Monitor Status is " + errMonitor.status )

    };

    console.log("errDelay finished:\n", errDelay);
    console.log("errMonitor finished:\n", errMonitor);
    

    clearInterval(tickerID);


}

/**
 * Creates a new promise with a specific result
 * @param {*} tt 
 * @param {*} exitType ("resolve", "reject" or "error")
 */
function prmDelay (tt, exitType) {
    
    return new Promise(function(resolve, reject) {
        if( exitType == 'reject' ){
            setTimeout(()=>{ reject("REJECTED")}, tt);
        } else if( exitType== 'error'){
            setTimeout(()=>{ reject(new Error( "ERROR Rejection") ); }, tt);
        } else {
            setTimeout(()=>{ resolve("RESOLVED") }, tt);
        } ;
    });
};


run();

这里是一个更充实的QueryablePromise的es6版本,允许在第一次解析后进行链接和捕获,并立即解析或拒绝以保持api与本机Promise一致。

const PROMISE = Symbol('PROMISE') const tap = fn => x => (fn(x), x) const trace = label => tap(x => console.log(label, x)) class QueryablePromise { resolved = false rejected = false fulfilled = false catchFns = [] constructor(fn) { this[PROMISE] = new Promise(fn) .then(tap(() => { this.fulfilled = true this.resolved = true })) .catch(x => { this.fulfilled = true this.rejected = true return Promise.reject(x) }) } then(fn) { this[PROMISE].then(fn) return this } catch(fn) { this[PROMISE].catch(fn) return this } static resolve(x) { return new QueryablePromise((res) => res(x)) } static reject(x) { return new QueryablePromise((_, rej) => rej(x)) } } const resolvedPromise = new QueryablePromise((res) => { setTimeout(res, 200, 'resolvedPromise') }) const rejectedPromise = new QueryablePromise((_, rej) => { setTimeout(rej, 200, 'rejectedPromise') }) // ensure our promises have not been fulfilled console.log('test 1 before: is resolved', resolvedPromise.resolved) console.log('test 2 before: is rejected', rejectedPromise.rejected) setTimeout(() => { // check to see the resolved status of our promise console.log('test 1 after: is resolved', resolvedPromise.resolved) console.log('test 2 after: is rejected', rejectedPromise.rejected) }, 300) // make sure we can immediately resolve a QueryablePromise const immediatelyResolvedPromise = QueryablePromise.resolve('immediatelyResolvedPromise') // ensure we can chain then .then(trace('test 3 resolved')) .then(trace('test 3 resolved 2')) .catch(trace('test 3 rejected')) // make sure we can immediately reject a QueryablePromise const immediatelyRejectedPromise = QueryablePromise.reject('immediatelyRejectedPromise') .then(trace('test 4 resolved')) .catch(trace('test 4 rejected')) <script src="https://codepen.io/synthet1c/pen/KyQQmL.js"></script>

在节点中,写入未记录的内部进程。

> process.binding('util').getPromiseDetails(Promise.resolve({data: [1,2,3]}));
[ 1, { data: [ 1, 2, 3 ] } ]

> process.binding('util').getPromiseDetails(Promise.reject(new Error('no')));
[ 2, Error: no ]

> process.binding('util').getPromiseDetails(new Promise((resolve) => {}));
[ 0, <1 empty item> ]