我有一个纯JavaScript承诺(内置实现或poly-fill):

var promise = new promise(函数(解析,拒绝){/*…* /});

从规范来看,Promise可以是:

" settle "和" resolved " “解决”和“拒绝” “等待”

我有一个用例,我希望同步审问承诺并确定:

承诺达成了吗? 如果是,承诺解决了吗?

我知道我可以使用#then()来安排在Promise改变状态后异步执行的工作。我不是在问你该怎么做。

这个问题是关于Promise状态的同步询问。我怎样才能做到这一点呢?


当前回答

对于原生JavaScript承诺,不存在这样的同步检查API。用本土的承诺是不可能做到的。规范没有指定这样的方法。

用户域库可以做到这一点,如果你的目标是一个特定的引擎(比如v8),并且可以访问平台代码(也就是说,你可以在核心中编写代码),那么你可以使用特定的工具(比如私有符号)来实现这一点。这是非常具体的,但不是在用户领域。

其他回答

This is older question but I was trying to do something similar. I need to keep n workers going. They are structured in a promise. I need to scan and see if they are resolved, rejected or still pending. If resolved, I need the value, if rejected do something to correct the issue or pending. If resolved or rejected I need to start another task to keep n going. I can't figure a way to do it with Promise.all or Promise.race as I keep working promises in an array and can find no way to delete them. So I create a worker that does the trick

我需要一个承诺生成器函数,返回一个承诺,根据需要解决或拒绝。它由一个函数调用,该函数设置框架以了解承诺在做什么。

在下面的代码中,生成器只是返回一个基于setTimeout的承诺。

在这里

//argObj should be of form
// {succeed: <true or false, nTimer: <desired time out>}
function promiseGenerator(argsObj) {
  let succeed = argsObj.succeed;          
  let nTimer = argsObj.nTimer;
  return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
    setTimeout(() => {
      if (succeed) {
        resolve('ok');
      }
      else {
        reject(`fail`);
      }
    }, nTimer);
  })

}

function doWork(generatorargs) {
  let sp = { state: `pending`, value: ``, promise: "" };
  let p1 = promiseGenerator(generatorargs)
    .then((value) => {
      sp.state = "resolved";
      sp.value = value;
    })
    .catch((err) => {
      sp.state = "rejected";
      sp.value = err;
    })
  sp.promise = p1;
  return sp;
}

doWork返回一个包含promise及其状态和返回值的对象。

下面的代码运行一个循环,测试状态并创建新的工作线程以保持在3个正在运行的工作线程。

let promiseArray = [];

promiseArray.push(doWork({ succeed: true, nTimer: 1000 }));
promiseArray.push(doWork({ succeed: true, nTimer: 500 }));
promiseArray.push(doWork({ succeed: false, nTimer: 3000 }));

function loopTimerPromise(delay) {
  return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
    setTimeout(() => {
      resolve('ok');
    }, delay)
  })
}

async function looper() {
  let nPromises = 3;      //just for breaking loop
  let nloop = 0;          //just for breaking loop
  let i;
  //let continueLoop = true;
  while (true) {
    await loopTimerPromise(900);  //execute loop every 900ms
    nloop++;
    //console.log(`promiseArray.length = ${promiseArray.length}`);
    for (i = promiseArray.length; i--; i > -1) {
      console.log(`index ${i} state: ${promiseArray[i].state}`);
      switch (promiseArray[i].state) {
        case "pending":
          break;
        case "resolved":
          nPromises++;
          promiseArray.splice(i, 1);
          promiseArray.push(doWork({ succeed: true, nTimer: 1000 }));
          break;
        case "rejected":
          //take recovery action
          nPromises++;
          promiseArray.splice(i, 1);
          promiseArray.push(doWork({ succeed: false, nTimer: 500 }));
          break;
        default:
          console.log(`error bad state in i=${i} state:${promiseArray[i].state} `)
          break;
      }
    }
    console.log(``);
    if (nloop > 10 || nPromises > 10) {
      //should do a Promise.all on remaining promises to clean them up but not for test
      break;
    }
  }
}

looper();

在node.js中测试

顺便说一句,不是在这个问题上,而是在其他类似的问题上,我讨厌有人说“你不明白”或“事情不是这样的”,我通常认为提问者知道他们想要什么。建议一个更好的方法是很好的。耐心地解释承诺如何起作用也会很好。

你可以这样包装你的承诺

function wrapPromise(promise) {
  var value, error,
      settled = false,
      resolved = false,
      rejected = false,
      p = promise.then(function(v) {
        value = v;
        settled = true;
        resolved = true;
        return v;
      }, function(err) {
        error = err;
        settled = true;
        rejected = true;
        throw err;
      });
      p.isSettled = function() {
        return settled;
      };
      p.isResolved = function() {
        return resolved;
      };
      p.isRejected = function() {
        return rejected;
      };
      p.value = function() {
        return value;
      };
      p.error = function() {
        return error;
      };
      var pThen = p.then, pCatch = p.catch;
      p.then = function(res, rej) {
        return wrapPromise(pThen(res, rej));
      };
      p.catch = function(rej) {
        return wrapPromise(pCatch(rej));
      };
      return p;
}

这里是一个更充实的QueryablePromise的es6版本,允许在第一次解析后进行链接和捕获,并立即解析或拒绝以保持api与本机Promise一致。

const PROMISE = Symbol('PROMISE') const tap = fn => x => (fn(x), x) const trace = label => tap(x => console.log(label, x)) class QueryablePromise { resolved = false rejected = false fulfilled = false catchFns = [] constructor(fn) { this[PROMISE] = new Promise(fn) .then(tap(() => { this.fulfilled = true this.resolved = true })) .catch(x => { this.fulfilled = true this.rejected = true return Promise.reject(x) }) } then(fn) { this[PROMISE].then(fn) return this } catch(fn) { this[PROMISE].catch(fn) return this } static resolve(x) { return new QueryablePromise((res) => res(x)) } static reject(x) { return new QueryablePromise((_, rej) => rej(x)) } } const resolvedPromise = new QueryablePromise((res) => { setTimeout(res, 200, 'resolvedPromise') }) const rejectedPromise = new QueryablePromise((_, rej) => { setTimeout(rej, 200, 'rejectedPromise') }) // ensure our promises have not been fulfilled console.log('test 1 before: is resolved', resolvedPromise.resolved) console.log('test 2 before: is rejected', rejectedPromise.rejected) setTimeout(() => { // check to see the resolved status of our promise console.log('test 1 after: is resolved', resolvedPromise.resolved) console.log('test 2 after: is rejected', rejectedPromise.rejected) }, 300) // make sure we can immediately resolve a QueryablePromise const immediatelyResolvedPromise = QueryablePromise.resolve('immediatelyResolvedPromise') // ensure we can chain then .then(trace('test 3 resolved')) .then(trace('test 3 resolved 2')) .catch(trace('test 3 rejected')) // make sure we can immediately reject a QueryablePromise const immediatelyRejectedPromise = QueryablePromise.reject('immediatelyRejectedPromise') .then(trace('test 4 resolved')) .catch(trace('test 4 rejected')) <script src="https://codepen.io/synthet1c/pen/KyQQmL.js"></script>

似乎没有人想出一个不需要任何技巧的最简单的解决方案:

定义一个变量来指示承诺正在运行 在promise中添加.finally子句,将变量设置为false(可以在promise创建后的任何时间执行) 之后,在代码中检查上述变量是否为真或假,以查看Promise是否仍在运行。

如果你不只是想知道它是否完成了,那么除了.finally之外,还要添加.then和.catch子句,将变量设置为"resolved"或"rejected"。

唯一的缺点是,在添加子句时,状态变量不会立即(同步地)设置,以防承诺已经完成。因此,最好将其添加到创建承诺后最早的位置。

例子:

async function worker(){
  // wait a very short period of time
  await (new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, 100)))
  //...
}

const w1=worker()


let w1_running=true
w1.finally( ()=> {w1_running=false});

//...
//Then check if it's running

(async ()=>{
  while(true){
    if (w1_running) {
      console.log("Still Busy :(")
    } else {
      console.log("All done :)")
      break
    }
    await (new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, 10)))
  }
})()

// Note we need some async action started otherwise the event loop would never reach the code in the function `worker` or in the `.finally` clause

你可以在Promise.prototype中添加一个方法。它是这样的:

编辑:第一个解决方案不能正常工作,就像这里的大多数答案一样。它返回“pending”直到异步函数“。然后”被调用,这不是立即发生的。(使用Promise.race的解决方案也是如此)。我的第二个解决方案解决了这个问题。

if (window.Promise) {
    Promise.prototype.getState = function () {
        if (!this.state) {
            this.state = "pending";
            var that = this;
            this.then(
                function (v) {
                    that.state = "resolved";
                    return v;
                },
                function (e) {
                    that.state = "rejected";
                    return e;
                });
        }
        return this.state;
    };
}

你可以在任何承诺上使用它。为例:

myPromise = new Promise(myFunction);
console.log(myPromise.getState()); // pending|resolved|rejected

第二个(也是正确的)解决方案:

if (window.Promise) {
    Promise.stateable = function (func) {
        var state = "pending";
        var pending = true;
        var newPromise = new Promise(wrapper);
        newPromise.state = state;
        return newPromise;
        function wrapper(resolve, reject) {
            func(res, rej);
            function res(e) {
                resolve(e);
                if (pending) {
                    if (newPromise)
                        newPromise.state = "resolved";
                    else
                        state = "resolved";
                    pending = false;
                }
            }
            function rej(e) {
                reject(e);
                if (pending) {
                    if (newPromise)
                        newPromise.state = "rejected";
                    else
                        state = "rejected";
                    pending = false;
                }
            }
        }
    };
}

并使用它:

注意:在这个解决方案中,您不必使用“new”操作符。

myPromise = Promise.stateable(myFunction);
console.log(myPromise.state); // pending|resolved|rejected