我喜欢@AntouanK的方法。我经常发现自己提供了一个具有不同数量参数和不同类型的函数。有时他们不服从命令。我用来映射查找参数类型:

findUDPServers: function(socketProperties, success, error) {
    var fqnMap = [];

    fqnMap['undefined'] = fqnMap['function'] = function(success, error) {
        var socketProperties = {name:'HELLO_SERVER'};

        this.searchServers(socketProperties, success, error);
    };

    fqnMap['object'] = function(socketProperties, success, error) {
        var _socketProperties = _.merge({name:'HELLO_SERVER'}, socketProperties || {});

        this.searchServers(_socketProperties, success, error);
    };

    fqnMap[typeof arguments[0]].apply(this, arguments);
}

你现在可以在ECMAScript 2018中进行函数重载，而无需填充，检查var长度/类型等，只需使用扩展语法。

function foo(var1, var2, opts){ // set default values for parameters const defaultOpts = { a: [1,2,3], b: true, c: 0.3289, d: "str", } // merge default and passed-in parameters // defaultOpts must go first! const mergedOpts = {...defaultOpts, ...opts}; // you can now refer to parameters like b as mergedOpts.b, // or just assign mergedOpts.b to b console.log(mergedOpts.a); console.log(mergedOpts.b); console.log(mergedOpts.c); console.log(mergedOpts.d); } // the parameters you passed in override the default ones // all JS types are supported: primitives, objects, arrays, functions, etc. let var1, var2="random var"; foo(var1, var2, {a: [1,2], d: "differentString"}); // parameter values inside foo: //a: [1,2] //b: true //c: 0.3289 //d: "differentString"

什么是扩展语法?

ECMAScript提案的Rest/Spread Properties(阶段4)将扩展属性添加到对象字面量中。它将自己的可枚举属性从提供的对象复制到新对象上。 更多关于mdn

注意:对象字面量中的扩展语法在Edge和IE中不起作用，这是一个实验特性。查看浏览器兼容性

最好的方法取决于函数和参数。你的每个选择在不同的情况下都是一个好主意。我通常按照以下顺序尝试这些方法，直到其中一个有效为止:

Using optional arguments like y = y || 'default'. This is convenient if you can do it, but it may not always work practically, e.g. when 0/null/undefined would be a valid argument. Using number of arguments. Similar to the last option but may work when #1 doesn't work. Checking types of arguments. This can work in some cases where the number of arguments is the same. If you can't reliably determine the types, you may need to use different names. Using different names in the first place. You may need to do this if the other options won't work, aren't practical, or for consistency with other related functions.

JavaScript是一种无类型语言，我认为只有在参数数量方面重载方法/函数才有意义。因此，我建议检查参数是否已经定义:

myFunction = function(a, b, c) {
     if (b === undefined && c === undefined ){
          // do x...
     }
     else {
          // do y...
     }
};

我经常这样做:

C#:

public string CatStrings(string p1)                  {return p1;}
public string CatStrings(string p1, int p2)          {return p1+p2.ToString();}
public string CatStrings(string p1, int p2, bool p3) {return p1+p2.ToString()+p3.ToString();}

CatStrings("one");        // result = one
CatStrings("one",2);      // result = one2
CatStrings("one",2,true); // result = one2true

JavaScript相当于:

function CatStrings(p1, p2, p3)
{
  var s = p1;
  if(typeof p2 !== "undefined") {s += p2;}
  if(typeof p3 !== "undefined") {s += p3;}
  return s;
};

CatStrings("one");        // result = one
CatStrings("one",2);      // result = one2
CatStrings("one",2,true); // result = one2true

This particular example is actually more elegant in javascript than C#. Parameters which are not specified are 'undefined' in javascript, which evaluates to false in an if statement. However, the function definition does not convey the information that p2 and p3 are optional. If you need a lot of overloading, jQuery has decided to use an object as the parameter, for example, jQuery.ajax(options). I agree with them that this is the most powerful and clearly documentable approach to overloading, but I rarely need more than one or two quick optional parameters.

编辑:根据Ian的建议更改IF测试

在JS中没有实际的重载，无论如何我们仍然可以用几种方式模拟方法重载:

方法# 1: 使用对象

function test(x,options){
  if("a" in options)doSomething();
  else if("b" in options)doSomethingElse();
}
test("ok",{a:1});
test("ok",{b:"string"});

方法# 2: 使用rest (spread)参数

function test(x,...p){
 if(p[2])console.log("3 params passed"); //or if(typeof p[2]=="string")
else if (p[1])console.log("2 params passed");
else console.log("1 param passed");
}

方法# 3: 使用未定义的

function test(x, y, z){
 if(typeof(z)=="undefined")doSomething();
}

方法# 4: 类型检查

function test(x){
 if(typeof(x)=="string")console.log("a string passed")
 else ...
}