测试两个范围是否重叠的最有效方法是什么?

给定两个包含范围[x1:x2]和[y1:y2]，其中x1≤x2和y1≤y2，测试这两个范围是否有重叠的最有效方法是什么?

一个简单的实现如下:

bool testOverlap(int x1, int x2, int y1, int y2) {
  return (x1 >= y1 && x1 <= y2) ||
         (x2 >= y1 && x2 <= y2) ||
         (y1 >= x1 && y1 <= x2) ||
         (y2 >= x1 && y2 <= x2);
}

但是我希望有更有效的方法来计算这个。

就最少的操作而言，哪种方法是最有效的?

当前回答

如果你正在处理，给定两个范围[x1:x2]和[y1:y2]，自然/反自然顺序范围同时存在:

自然顺序:x1 <= x2 && y1 <= y2或反自然顺序:x1 >= x2 && y1 >= y2

然后你可能想用这个来检查:

它们重叠<=> (y2 - x1) * (x2 - y1) >= 0

其中只涉及四个操作:

2倍一个乘法一个比较

2016-12-27 21:49:59

其他回答

反过来思考:如何使这两个范围不重叠?给定[x1, x2]，则[y1, y2]应在[x1, x2]之外，即y1 < y2 < x1或x2 < y1 < y2，这等价于y2 < x1或x2 < y1。

因此，使两个范围重叠的条件是:不(y2 < x1或x2 < y1)，这相当于y2 >= x1和x2 >= y1(与Simon接受的答案相同)。

2019-01-20 23:51:40

重叠(X, Y):= if (X1 <= Y1) then (Y1 <= X2) else (X1 <= Y2)。

证明:

考虑X在Y之前或与Y左对齐的情况，即X1 <= Y1。那么Y要么在X内部开始，要么在X的末尾开始，即Y1 <= X2;或者Y远离x，第一个条件是重叠;第二个，不是。

在互补的情况下，Y在X之前，同样的逻辑适用于交换的实体。

So,

重叠(X, Y):= if (X1 <= Y) then (Y1 <= X2) else重叠(Y, X)。

但这似乎并不完全正确。在递归调用中，第一个测试是多余的，因为我们已经从第一个调用的第一个测试中知道了实体的相对位置。因此，我们实际上只需要测试第二个条件，即交换后(X1 <= Y2)。所以,

重叠(X, Y):= if (X1 <= Y1) then (Y1 <= X2) else (X1 <= Y2)。

QED.

Ada的实现:

   type Range_T is array (1 .. 2) of Integer;

   function Overlap (X, Y: Range_T) return Boolean is
     (if X(1) <= Y(1) then Y(1) <= X(2) else X(1) <= Y(2));

测试程序:

with Ada.Text_IO; use Ada.Text_IO;

procedure Main is

   type Range_T is array (1 .. 2) of Integer;

   function Overlap (X, Y: Range_T) return Boolean is
     (if X(1) <= Y(1) then Y(1) <= X(2) else X(1) <= Y(2));

   function Img (X: Range_T) return String is
     (" [" & X(1)'Img & X(2)'Img & " ] ");

   procedure Test (X, Y: Range_T; Expect: Boolean) is
      B: Boolean := Overlap (X, Y);
   begin
      Put_Line
        (Img (X) & " and " & Img (Y) &
         (if B then " overlap .......... "
               else " do not overlap ... ") &
         (if B = Expect then "PASS" else "FAIL"));
   end;
         
begin
   Test ( (1, 2), (2, 3), True);  --  chained
   Test ( (2, 3), (1, 2), True);

   Test ( (4, 9), (5, 7), True);  --  inside
   Test ( (5, 7), (4, 9), True);

   Test ( (1, 5), (3, 7), True);  --  proper overlap
   Test ( (3, 7), (1, 5), True);

   Test ( (1, 2), (3, 4), False);  -- back to back
   Test ( (3, 4), (1, 2), False);

   Test ( (1, 2), (5, 7), False);  -- disjoint
   Test ( (5, 7), (1, 2), False);
end;

以上程序输出:

 [ 1 2 ]  and  [ 2 3 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 2 3 ]  and  [ 1 2 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 4 9 ]  and  [ 5 7 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 5 7 ]  and  [ 4 9 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 1 5 ]  and  [ 3 7 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 3 7 ]  and  [ 1 5 ]  overlap .......... PASS
 [ 1 2 ]  and  [ 3 4 ]  do not overlap ... PASS
 [ 3 4 ]  and  [ 1 2 ]  do not overlap ... PASS
 [ 1 2 ]  and  [ 5 7 ]  do not overlap ... PASS
 [ 5 7 ]  and  [ 1 2 ]  do not overlap ... PASS

2021-12-19 20:00:42

考虑到: (x1, x2) (y1, y2) 那么x1 <= y2 || x2 >= y1总是成立的。作为