封装和抽象之间的确切区别是什么?
当前回答
抽象是广义的术语。即封装是抽象的子集。
Abstraction | Encapsulation |
---|---|
It solves an issue at the design level. | Encapsulation solves an issue at implementation level. |
hides the unnecessary detail but shows the essential information. | It hides the code and data into a single entity or unit so that the data can be protected from the outside world. |
Focuses on the external lookout. | Focuses on internal working. |
Lets focus on what an object does instead of how it does it. | Lets focus on how an object does something. |
Example: Outer look of mobile, like it has a display screen and buttons. | Example: Inner details of mobile, how button and display screen connect with each other using circuits. |
示例:解决方案架构师是创建整个解决方案的高级抽象技术设计的人,然后将该设计移交给开发团队进行实现。 在这里,解决方案架构师充当抽象,而开发团队充当封装。
举例:用户数据的封装(组网)
图片由
Abstraction (or modularity) – Types enable programmers to think at a higher level than the bit or byte, not bothering with low-level implementation. For example, programmers can begin to think of a string as a set of character values instead of as a mere array of bytes. Higher still, types enable programmers to think about and express interfaces between two of any-sized subsystems. This enables more levels of localization so that the definitions required for interoperability of the subsystems remain consistent when those two subsystems communicate. Source
Java示例
其他回答
这里的大多数答案都关注于OOP,但封装开始得更早:
Every function is an encapsulation; in pseudocode: point x = { 1, 4 } point y = { 23, 42 } numeric d = distance(x, y) Here, distance encapsulates the calculation of the (Euclidean) distance between two points in a plane: it hides implementation details. This is encapsulation, pure and simple. Abstraction is the process of generalisation: taking a concrete implementation and making it applicable to different, albeit somewhat related, types of data. The classical example of abstraction is C’s qsort function to sort data: The thing about qsort is that it doesn't care about the data it sorts — in fact, it doesn’t know what data it sorts. Rather, its input type is a typeless pointer (void*) which is just C’s way of saying “I don't care about the type of data” (this is also called type erasure). The important point is that the implementation of qsort always stays the same, regardless of data type. The only thing that has to change is the compare function, which differs from data type to data type. qsort therefore expects the user to provide said compare function as a function argument.
封装和抽象是密切相关的,因此您可以认为它们确实是不可分割的。就实际而言,这可能是对的;也就是说,这里有一个不太抽象的封装:
class point {
numeric x
numeric y
}
我们封装了点的坐标,但是我们没有实质性地将它们抽象出来,只是在逻辑上对它们进行分组。
这里有一个抽象的例子,它不是封装:
T pi<T> = 3.1415926535
这是一个具有给定值(π)的泛型变量pi,声明并不关心变量的确切类型。诚然,我很难在真实的代码中找到这样的东西:抽象实际上总是使用封装。然而,上面的内容在c++(14)中确实存在,通过变量模板(=变量的通用模板);使用稍微复杂一点的语法,例如:
template <typename T> constexpr T pi = T{3.1415926535};
让我用简单的代码示例来尝试一下
抽象=数据隐藏+封装
// Abstraction
interface IOperation
{
int GetSumOfNumbers();
}
internal class OperationEven : IOperation
{
// data hiding
private IEnumerable<int> numbers;
public OperationEven(IEnumerable<int> numbers)
{
this.numbers = numbers;
}
// Encapsulation
public int GetSumOfNumbers()
{
return this.numbers.Where(i => i % 2 == 0).Sum();
}
}
抽象让您关注对象做了什么,而不是它是如何做的 封装意味着隐藏对象如何做某事的内部细节或机制。
就像你开车时,你知道油门踏板的作用,但你可能不知道它背后的过程,因为它是封装的。
让我用c#举个例子。假设你有一个整数:
int Number = 5;
string aStrNumber = Number.ToString();
你可以使用像number . tostring()这样的方法,它返回数字5的字符表示,并将其存储在字符串对象中。该方法告诉您它做了什么,而不是如何做。
另一个例子:
假设我创建了一个不可变的Rectangle类,如下所示:
class Rectangle {
public:
Rectangle(int width, int height) : width_(width), height_(height) {}
int width() const { return width_; }
int height() const { return height_; }
private:
int width_;
int height_;
}
现在很明显,我已经封装了宽度和高度(访问受到某种限制),但我没有抽象任何东西(好吧,也许我忽略了矩形在坐标空间中的位置,但这是示例的缺陷)。
好的抽象通常意味着好的封装。
一个好的抽象例子是通用数据库连接类。它的公共接口与数据库无关,非常简单,但允许我对连接做我想做的事情。你看到了吗?这里还有封装,因为类内部必须有所有低级句柄和调用。
抽象:抽象的意思是显示功能的哪一部分。
封装:封装意味着隐藏功能的How部分。
让我们举一个非常简单的例子
/// <summary>
/// We have an Employee class having two properties EmployeeName and EmployeeCode
/// </summary>
public class Employee
{
public string EmplpyeeName { get; set; }
public string EmployeeCode { get; set; }
// Add new employee to DB is the main functionality, so are making it public so that we can expose it to external environment
// This is ABSTRACTION
public void AddEmployee(Employee obj)
{
// "Creation of DB connection" and "To check if employee exists" are internal details which we have hide from external environment
// You can see that these methods are private, external environment just need "What" part only
CreateDBConnection();
CheckIfEmployeeExists();
}
// ENCAPLUSATION using private keyword
private bool CheckIfEmployeeExists()
{
// Here we can validate if the employee already exists
return true;
}
// ENCAPLUSATION using private keyword
private void CreateDBConnection()
{
// Create DB connection code
}
}
控制台应用程序程序类
class Program
{
static void Main(string[] args)
{
Employee obj = new Employee();
obj.EmplpyeeName = "001";
obj.EmployeeCode = "Raj";
// We have exposed only what part of the functionality
obj.AddEmployee(obj);
}
}