Emacs和Vim之间有什么实际的、客观的区别?例如,使用一个可以做而另一个不行(或者使用一个比另一个更容易做)?为了选择一门课程,我应该知道些什么?
当前回答
Emacs的好处
Emacs has both non-modal interface (by default) and modal one (e.g. it can emulate vim and vi through Evil, Viper, or Vimpulse). One of the most ported computer programs. It runs in text mode and under graphical user interfaces on a wide variety of operating systems, including most Unix-like systems (Linux, the various BSDs, Solaris, AIX, IRIX, macOSetc.), MS-DOS, Microsoft Windows, AmigaOS, and OpenVMS. Unix systems, both free and proprietary, frequently provide Emacs bundled with the operating system. Emacs server architecture allows multiple clients to attach to the same Emacs instance and share the buffer list, kill ring, undo history and other state. Pervasive online help system with keybindings, functions and commands documented on the fly. Extensible and customizable Lisp programming language variant (Emacs Lisp), with features that include: A powerful and extensible file manager (dired), integrated debugger, and a large set of development and other tools. Having every command be an Emacs Lisp function enables commands to DWIM (Do What I Mean) by programmatically responding to past actions and document state. For example, a switch-or-split-window command could switch to another window if one exists, or create one if needed. This cuts down on the number of keystrokes and commands a user must remember. "An OS inside an OS". Emacs Lisp enables Emacs to be programmed far beyond editing features. Even a base install contains several dozen applications, including two web browsers, news readers, several mail agents, four IRC clients, a version of ELIZA, and a variety of games. All of these applications are available anywhere Emacs runs, with the same user interface and functionality. Starting with version 24, Emacs includes a package manager, making it easy to install additional applications including alternate web browsers, EMMS (Emacs Multimedia System), and more. Also available are numerous packages for programming, including some targeted at specific language/library combinations or coding styles.
vi类编辑器的好处
Edit commands are composable Vi has a modal interface (which Emacs can emulate) Historically, vi loads faster than Emacs. While deeply associated with UNIX tradition, it runs on all systems that can implement the standard C library, including UNIX, Linux, AmigaOS, DOS, Windows, Mac, BeOS, OpenVMS, IRIX, AIX, HP-UX, BSD and POSIX-compliant systems. Extensible and customizable through Vim script or APIs for interpreted languages such as Python, Ruby, Perl, and Lua Ubiquitous. Essentially all Unix and Unix-like systems come with vi (or a variant) built-in. Vi (and ex, but not vim) is specified in the POSIX standard. System rescue environments, embedded systems (notably those with busybox) and other constrained environments often include vi, but not emacs.
来源:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Editor_war
其他回答
VI总是可用的,并且将在最残缺的、单用户模式、坏的图形、没有键图、慢的链接机器上运行——因此,仅仅为了系统管理任务,了解如何在它中编辑简单的文件是值得的。
Emacs是一个编辑器中的完整用户界面。其思想是在启动机器时启动Emacs,并且永远不要离开它。可能会有数千个会话。
与使用GUI编辑器/IDE和使用python/awk/等来完成额外任务相比,学习Emacs的功能是否值得,取决于你自己。
现在你甚至不需要考虑这两者之间的区别,因为Spacemacs。它是一个社区驱动的Emacs发行版。
正如它所说,
最好的编辑器既不是Emacs也不是vim,而是Emacs和vim。
Spacemacs结合了Emacs和Vim的优点,使您的生活和工作更加轻松。
请看下面的截图,
(来源:spacemacs.org)
Vim是一个方便的编辑器,你只需输入Vim的文件名来打开文件,编辑,保存和关闭。
Emacs是一个伪装成编辑器的“操作系统”,你可以评估代码来改变它的行为,并按你的喜好扩展它。在emacs上接收/发送电子邮件的模式类似于操作系统上的电子邮件软件。
当进行简单的编辑时,例如,修改配置文件,我使用vim。
否则,我永远不会离开emacs。
对于我来说,选择使用emacs而不是vim的最大区别是emacs内置的gdb支持。Vim的默认发行版中并没有包含这个功能,而且用于集成gdb和Vim的项目几乎不可能使用MacVim
Vim:
作为一个简单的编辑器更好(简单任务所需的键更少) 更活跃的脚本社区-内部语言:vimscript 一个集中的脚本、插件、配色方案…… 在python、ruby中也可扩展 可移植(emacs在这方面存在一些问题)
Emacs:
non modal by default (most of today's editors have taken this approach). Though there is evil-mode which emulates vim behavior. more powerful language for extending it (elisp is a full blown language, and in emacs you can practically redefine everything; while in vim you cannot redefine build in functions of the editor. On the downside, vimscript is relatively similar to today's dynamic languages while elisp doesn't resemble pretty much anything) more extendible excellent support for GNU tools (the bunch of them)
就我个人而言,我更喜欢vim——它很小,做了它应该做的事情,当我想要一个完整的IDE时,我打开它VS. Emacs的方法是一个编辑器,它想成为一个IDE(或者我应该说,一个操作系统),但并不完全,在我看来,过时了。以前有电子邮件客户端、ftp客户端、俄罗斯方块……一个包(emacs)中的东西是有意义的……如今,它不再是了。
然而,这两者都是程序员和超级用户社区用户之间的宗教讨论话题,在这方面,如果接触(在同一句话/问题中),两者都很适合开始激烈的战争。