更新:

再次感谢你的例子,它们对我很有帮助,我并不是说 夺走他们的一切。

Aren't the currently given examples, as far as I understand them & state-machines, only half of what we usually understand by a state-machine? In the sense that the examples do change state but that's only represented by changing the value of a variable (and allowing different value- changes in different states), while usually, a state machine should also change its behavior, and behavior not (only) in the sense of allowing different value changes for a variable depending on the state, but in the sense of allowing different methods to be executed for different states.

还是我对状态机及其常用用法有误解?


最初的问题:

我发现了关于c#中的状态机和迭代器块的讨论,以及用于创建状态机和c#的工具,所以我发现了很多抽象的东西,但作为一个新手,所有这些都有点令人困惑。

因此,如果有人能提供一个c#源代码-示例,实现一个简单的状态机,可能只有3,4个状态,那就太好了,只是为了了解它的要点。


当前回答

我刚刚贡献了这个:

https://code.google.com/p/ysharp/source/browse/#svn%2Ftrunk%2FStateMachinesPoC

下面是演示直接和间接发送命令的例子之一,状态为IObserver(信号),因此响应者对信号源IObservable(信号):

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;

namespace Test
{
    using Machines;

    public static class WatchingTvSampleAdvanced
    {
        // Enum type for the transition triggers (instead of System.String) :
        public enum TvOperation { Plug, SwitchOn, SwitchOff, Unplug, Dispose }

        // The state machine class type is also used as the type for its possible states constants :
        public class Television : NamedState<Television, TvOperation, DateTime>
        {
            // Declare all the possible states constants :
            public static readonly Television Unplugged = new Television("(Unplugged TV)");
            public static readonly Television Off = new Television("(TV Off)");
            public static readonly Television On = new Television("(TV On)");
            public static readonly Television Disposed = new Television("(Disposed TV)");

            // For convenience, enter the default start state when the parameterless constructor executes :
            public Television() : this(Television.Unplugged) { }

            // To create a state machine instance, with a given start state :
            private Television(Television value) : this(null, value) { }

            // To create a possible state constant :
            private Television(string moniker) : this(moniker, null) { }

            private Television(string moniker, Television value)
            {
                if (moniker == null)
                {
                    // Build the state graph programmatically
                    // (instead of declaratively via custom attributes) :
                    Handler<Television, TvOperation, DateTime> stateChangeHandler = StateChange;
                    Build
                    (
                        new[]
                        {
                            new { From = Television.Unplugged, When = TvOperation.Plug, Goto = Television.Off, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.Unplugged, When = TvOperation.Dispose, Goto = Television.Disposed, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.Off, When = TvOperation.SwitchOn, Goto = Television.On, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.Off, When = TvOperation.Unplug, Goto = Television.Unplugged, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.Off, When = TvOperation.Dispose, Goto = Television.Disposed, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.On, When = TvOperation.SwitchOff, Goto = Television.Off, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.On, When = TvOperation.Unplug, Goto = Television.Unplugged, With = stateChangeHandler },
                            new { From = Television.On, When = TvOperation.Dispose, Goto = Television.Disposed, With = stateChangeHandler }
                        },
                        false
                    );
                }
                else
                    // Name the state constant :
                    Moniker = moniker;
                Start(value ?? this);
            }

            // Because the states' value domain is a reference type, disallow the null value for any start state value : 
            protected override void OnStart(Television value)
            {
                if (value == null)
                    throw new ArgumentNullException("value", "cannot be null");
            }

            // When reaching a final state, unsubscribe from all the signal source(s), if any :
            protected override void OnComplete(bool stateComplete)
            {
                // Holds during all transitions into a final state
                // (i.e., stateComplete implies IsFinal) :
                System.Diagnostics.Debug.Assert(!stateComplete || IsFinal);

                if (stateComplete)
                    UnsubscribeFromAll();
            }

            // Executed before and after every state transition :
            private void StateChange(IState<Television> state, ExecutionStep step, Television value, TvOperation info, DateTime args)
            {
                // Holds during all possible transitions defined in the state graph
                // (i.e., (step equals ExecutionStep.LeaveState) implies (not state.IsFinal))
                System.Diagnostics.Debug.Assert((step != ExecutionStep.LeaveState) || !state.IsFinal);

                // Holds in instance (i.e., non-static) transition handlers like this one :
                System.Diagnostics.Debug.Assert(this == state);

                switch (step)
                {
                    case ExecutionStep.LeaveState:
                        var timeStamp = ((args != default(DateTime)) ? String.Format("\t\t(@ {0})", args) : String.Empty);
                        Console.WriteLine();
                        // 'value' is the state value that we are transitioning TO :
                        Console.WriteLine("\tLeave :\t{0} -- {1} -> {2}{3}", this, info, value, timeStamp);
                        break;
                    case ExecutionStep.EnterState:
                        // 'value' is the state value that we have transitioned FROM :
                        Console.WriteLine("\tEnter :\t{0} -- {1} -> {2}", value, info, this);
                        break;
                    default:
                        break;
                }
            }

            public override string ToString() { return (IsConstant ? Moniker : Value.ToString()); }
        }

        public static void Run()
        {
            Console.Clear();

            // Create a signal source instance (here, a.k.a. "remote control") that implements
            // IObservable<TvOperation> and IObservable<KeyValuePair<TvOperation, DateTime>> :
            var remote = new SignalSource<TvOperation, DateTime>();

            // Create a television state machine instance (automatically set in a default start state),
            // and make it subscribe to a compatible signal source, such as the remote control, precisely :
            var tv = new Television().Using(remote);
            bool done;

            // Always holds, assuming the call to Using(...) didn't throw an exception (in case of subscription failure) :
            System.Diagnostics.Debug.Assert(tv != null, "There's a bug somewhere: this message should never be displayed!");

            // As commonly done, we can trigger a transition directly on the state machine :
            tv.MoveNext(TvOperation.Plug, DateTime.Now);

            // Alternatively, we can also trigger transitions by emitting from the signal source / remote control
            // that the state machine subscribed to / is an observer of :
            remote.Emit(TvOperation.SwitchOn, DateTime.Now);
            remote.Emit(TvOperation.SwitchOff);
            remote.Emit(TvOperation.SwitchOn);
            remote.Emit(TvOperation.SwitchOff, DateTime.Now);

            done =
                (
                    tv.
                        MoveNext(TvOperation.Unplug).
                        MoveNext(TvOperation.Dispose) // MoveNext(...) returns null iff tv.IsFinal == true
                    == null
                );

            remote.Emit(TvOperation.Unplug); // Ignored by the state machine thanks to the OnComplete(...) override above

            Console.WriteLine();
            Console.WriteLine("Is the TV's state '{0}' a final state? {1}", tv.Value, done);

            Console.WriteLine();
            Console.WriteLine("Press any key...");
            Console.ReadKey();
        }
    }
}

注意:这个例子是相当人工的,主要是为了演示一些正交的特征。应该很少有真正需要通过一个完整的类来实现状态值域本身,使用CRTP(参见:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curiously_recurring_template_pattern)。

下面是一个当然更简单,可能更常见的实现用例(使用一个简单的枚举类型作为状态值域),用于相同的状态机,并使用相同的测试用例:

https://code.google.com/p/ysharp/source/browse/trunk/StateMachinesPoC/WatchingTVSample.cs

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;

namespace Test
{
    using Machines;

    public static class WatchingTvSample
    {
        public enum Status { Unplugged, Off, On, Disposed }

        public class DeviceTransitionAttribute : TransitionAttribute
        {
            public Status From { get; set; }
            public string When { get; set; }
            public Status Goto { get; set; }
            public object With { get; set; }
        }

        // State<Status> is a shortcut for / derived from State<Status, string>,
        // which in turn is a shortcut for / derived from State<Status, string, object> :
        public class Device : State<Status>
        {
            // Executed before and after every state transition :
            protected override void OnChange(ExecutionStep step, Status value, string info, object args)
            {
                if (step == ExecutionStep.EnterState)
                {
                    // 'value' is the state value that we have transitioned FROM :
                    Console.WriteLine("\t{0} -- {1} -> {2}", value, info, this);
                }
            }

            public override string ToString() { return Value.ToString(); }
        }

        // Since 'Device' has no state graph of its own, define one for derived 'Television' :
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.Unplugged, When = "Plug", Goto = Status.Off)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.Unplugged, When = "Dispose", Goto = Status.Disposed)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.Off, When = "Switch On", Goto = Status.On)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.Off, When = "Unplug", Goto = Status.Unplugged)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.Off, When = "Dispose", Goto = Status.Disposed)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.On, When = "Switch Off", Goto = Status.Off)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.On, When = "Unplug", Goto = Status.Unplugged)]
        [DeviceTransition(From = Status.On, When = "Dispose", Goto = Status.Disposed)]
        public class Television : Device { }

        public static void Run()
        {
            Console.Clear();

            // Create a television state machine instance, and return it, set in some start state :
            var tv = new Television().Start(Status.Unplugged);
            bool done;

            // Holds iff the chosen start state isn't a final state :
            System.Diagnostics.Debug.Assert(tv != null, "The chosen start state is a final state!");

            // Trigger some state transitions with no arguments
            // ('args' is ignored by this state machine's OnChange(...), anyway) :
            done =
                (
                    tv.
                        MoveNext("Plug").
                        MoveNext("Switch On").
                        MoveNext("Switch Off").
                        MoveNext("Switch On").
                        MoveNext("Switch Off").
                        MoveNext("Unplug").
                        MoveNext("Dispose") // MoveNext(...) returns null iff tv.IsFinal == true
                    == null
                );

            Console.WriteLine();
            Console.WriteLine("Is the TV's state '{0}' a final state? {1}", tv.Value, done);

            Console.WriteLine();
            Console.WriteLine("Press any key...");
            Console.ReadKey();
        }
    }
}

'HTH

其他回答

在NuGet中有两个流行的状态机包。

Appccelerate。StateMachine (13.6K下载量+ 3.82K遗留版本(bbv.Common.StateMachine))

中文工具箱(1.56K downloads)

Appccelerate库有很好的文档,但是它不支持。net 4,所以我选择了StateMachineToolkit作为我的项目。

下面是一个非常经典的有限状态机的例子,它模拟了一个非常简化的电子设备(比如电视)

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;

namespace fsm
{
class Program
{
    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        var fsm = new FiniteStateMachine();
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        fsm.ProcessEvent(FiniteStateMachine.Events.PlugIn);
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        fsm.ProcessEvent(FiniteStateMachine.Events.TurnOn);
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        fsm.ProcessEvent(FiniteStateMachine.Events.TurnOff);
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        fsm.ProcessEvent(FiniteStateMachine.Events.TurnOn);
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        fsm.ProcessEvent(FiniteStateMachine.Events.RemovePower);
        Console.WriteLine(fsm.State);
        Console.ReadKey();
    }

    class FiniteStateMachine
    {
        public enum States { Start, Standby, On };
        public States State { get; set; }

        public enum Events { PlugIn, TurnOn, TurnOff, RemovePower };

        private Action[,] fsm;

        public FiniteStateMachine()
        {
            this.fsm = new Action[3, 4] { 
                //PlugIn,       TurnOn,                 TurnOff,            RemovePower
                {this.PowerOn,  null,                   null,               null},              //start
                {null,          this.StandbyWhenOff,    null,               this.PowerOff},     //standby
                {null,          null,                   this.StandbyWhenOn, this.PowerOff} };   //on
        }
        public void ProcessEvent(Events theEvent)
        {
            this.fsm[(int)this.State, (int)theEvent].Invoke();
        }

        private void PowerOn() { this.State = States.Standby; }
        private void PowerOff() { this.State = States.Start; }
        private void StandbyWhenOn() { this.State = States.Standby; }
        private void StandbyWhenOff() { this.State = States.On; }
    }
}
}

列表的另一个状态机是我的:https://github.com/IanMercer/Abodit.StateMachine

除了具有进入和退出操作的简单状态,以及每个转换上的操作之外,这个是为在异步代码中使用而设计的。它还支持分层状态和复合状态机。所以不是很“简单”,但在使用中,它很容易编码状态和过渡。

static OpenClosedStateMachine()
{
    Closed
       .When(Fridge.eDoorOpens, (m, s, e, c) => Task.FromResult(Open));

    Open
        .When(Fridge.eDoorCloses, (m, s, e, c) => Task.FromResult(Closed));
}

不像其他的,它还支持时间转换,所以很容易过渡到不同的状态后,一个给定的时期或在给定的时间。

记住状态机是一种抽象是很有用的,创建状态机不需要特定的工具,但是工具是有用的。

例如,你可以用函数实现一个状态机:

void Hunt(IList<Gull> gulls)
{
    if (gulls.Empty())
       return;

    var target = gulls.First();
    TargetAcquired(target, gulls);
}

void TargetAcquired(Gull target, IList<Gull> gulls)
{
    var balloon = new WaterBalloon(weightKg: 20);

    this.Cannon.Fire(balloon);

    if (balloon.Hit)
    {
       TargetHit(target, gulls);
    }
    else
       TargetMissed(target, gulls);
}

void TargetHit(Gull target, IList<Gull> gulls)
{
    Console.WriteLine("Suck on it {0}!", target.Name);
    Hunt(gulls);
}

void TargetMissed(Gull target, IList<Gull> gulls)
{
    Console.WriteLine("I'll get ya!");
    TargetAcquired(target, gulls);
}

这台机器会捕捉海鸥,并试图用水球击中它们。如果它没有命中,它将尝试发射一个直到命中为止(可以有一些现实的期望;)),否则它将在控制台幸灾乐祸。它继续捕猎,直到没有海鸥可以骚扰为止。

每个函数对应于每个状态;没有显示开始和结束(或接受)状态。其中的状态可能比函数所模拟的要多。例如,在发射气球后,机器实际上处于与之前不同的状态,但我认为这种区分是不切实际的。

常用的方法是使用类来表示状态,然后以不同的方式将它们连接起来。

您可以编写一个迭代器块,使您能够以编排的方式执行代码块。代码块是如何分解的并不一定要对应于任何东西,这只是你想要如何编码它。例如:

IEnumerable<int> CountToTen()
{
    System.Console.WriteLine("1");
    yield return 0;
    System.Console.WriteLine("2");
    System.Console.WriteLine("3");
    System.Console.WriteLine("4");
    yield return 0;
    System.Console.WriteLine("5");
    System.Console.WriteLine("6");
    System.Console.WriteLine("7");
    yield return 0;
    System.Console.WriteLine("8");
    yield return 0;
    System.Console.WriteLine("9");
    System.Console.WriteLine("10");
}

在本例中,当调用CountToTen时,还没有实际执行任何东西。您得到的实际上是一个状态机生成器,您可以为它创建一个状态机的新实例。可以通过调用GetEnumerator()来实现。生成的IEnumerator实际上是一个状态机,您可以通过调用MoveNext(…)来驱动它。

因此,在本例中,第一次调用MoveNext(…)时,您将看到“1”写入控制台,下一次调用MoveNext(…)时,您将看到2、3、4,然后是5、6、7、8,然后是9、10。正如您所看到的,这是一种编排事情应该如何发生的有用机制。