是否可以在ES6类中创建私有属性?

举个例子。 如何阻止访问instance.property?

class Something {
  constructor(){
    this.property = "test";
  }
}

var instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> "test"

当前回答

Yes totally can, and pretty easily too. This is done by exposing your private variables and functions by returning the prototype object graph in the constructor. This is nothing new, but take a bit of js foo to understand the elegance of it. This way does not use global scoped, or weakmaps. It is a form of reflection built into the language. Depending on how you leverage this; one can either force an exception which interrupts the call stack, or bury the exception as an undefined. This is demonstarted below, and can read more about these features here

class Clazz { constructor() { var _level = 1 function _private(x) { return _level * x; } return { level: _level, public: this.private, public2: function(x) { return _private(x); }, public3: function(x) { return _private(x) * this.public(x); }, }; } private(x) { return x * x; } } var clazz = new Clazz(); console.log(clazz._level); //undefined console.log(clazz._private); // undefined console.log(clazz.level); // 1 console.log(clazz.public(1)); //1 console.log(clazz.public2(2)); //2 console.log(clazz.public3(3)); //27 console.log(clazz.private(0)); //error

其他回答

读了前面的答案,我认为这个例子可以总结以上的解决方案

const friend = Symbol('friend');

const ClassName = ((hidden, hiddenShared = 0) => {

    class ClassName {
        constructor(hiddenPropertyValue, prop){
            this[hidden] = hiddenPropertyValue * ++hiddenShared;
            this.prop = prop
        }

        get hidden(){
            console.log('getting hidden');
            return this[hidden];
        }

        set [friend](v){
            console.log('setting hiddenShared');
            hiddenShared = v;
        }

        get counter(){
            console.log('getting hiddenShared');
            return hiddenShared;
        }

        get privileged(){
            console.log('calling privileged method');
            return privileged.bind(this);
        }
    }

    function privileged(value){
        return this[hidden] + value;
    }

    return ClassName;
})(Symbol('hidden'), 0);

const OtherClass = (() => class OtherClass extends ClassName {
    constructor(v){
        super(v, 100);
        this[friend] = this.counter - 1;
    }
})();

更新

现在有可能使真正的私有属性和方法(至少在基于chrome的浏览器现在)。

语法非常简洁

class MyClass {
    #privateProperty = 1
    #privateMethod() { return 2 }
    static #privateStatic = 3
    static #privateStaticMethod(){return 4}
    static get #privateStaticGetter(){return 5}

    // also using is quite straightforward
    method(){
        return (
            this.#privateMethod() +
            this.#privateProperty +
            MyClass.#privateStatic +
            MyClass.#privateStaticMethod() +
            MyClass.#privateStaticGetter
        )
    }
}

new MyClass().method()
// returns 15

注意,对于检索静态引用,不能使用this.constructor。#private,因为它会终止它的子类。你必须使用一个对适当类的引用来检索它的静态私有引用(只能在该类的方法中使用),即MyClass.#private。

答案是“不”。但是你可以像这样创建对属性的私有访问:

使用模块。模块中的所有内容都是私有的,除非使用export关键字将其设为公有。 在模块内部,使用函数闭包:http://www.kirupa.com/html5/closures_in_javascript.htm

(可以使用符号来确保隐私的建议在ES6规范的早期版本中是正确的,但现在不再是这样:https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/es-discuss/2014-January/035604.html和https://stackoverflow.com/a/22280202/1282216。有关符号和隐私的详细讨论,请参阅:https://curiosity-driven.org/private-properties-in-javascript)

除了给出的答案之外,您还可以使用代理来创建“私有属性”,使代理只对公共代码可用。实例只对构造函数、绑定方法和作为接收者的Proxy本身可用。

这比使用符号和弱映射有一些优势。

符号是可枚举的,可以用代理捕获。 当实例被代理为实例时,WeakMaps失败!== new Proxy(instance)

WeakMap失败。

const map = new WeakMap()

const instance = new SomeClass()
map.set(instance, 'foo')
// somewhere along the way in 3rd party code
const proxy = new Proxy(instance, {})
assert(map.set(instance) === map.get(proxy)) // fail
const proxy2 = new Proxy(proxy, {})
// more headache

使用代理用私有道具验证来装饰实例

getProxy = (instance) => new Proxy(instance, {

    get: (target, name, receiver) => {
        console.log('get', { target, name, receiver })
        if (name[0] === '_') throw new Error('Cannot access private property ' + name)
        return Reflect.get(target, name, receiver) 
    },
    set: (target, name, value, receiver) => {
        console.log('set', { target, name, value, receiver })
        if (name[0] === '_') throw new Error('Cannot set private property ' + name)
        return Reflect.set(target, name, value, receiver) 
    }
    
})


class PublicClass {

    constructor() {
        Object.defineProperty(this, '_privateProp', { enumerable: false, writable: true, configurable: false })
        return getProxy(this) // can be moved out as a decorator
    }

    getPrivatePropFail() {
        return this._privateProp // fail
    }

    getPrivateProp = () => {
        return this._privateProp // ok
    }

    setPrivateProp = (value) => {
        return this._privateProp = value // ok
    }

}


pub = new PublicClass()

try {
    console.log('get pub._privateProp', pub._privateProp)
} catch(e) {
    console.error(e) 
}
try {
    console.log('set pub._privateProp', pub._privateProp = 'you fail')
} catch(e) {
    console.error(e) 
}
pub.setPrivateProp('you ok')
console.log('pub.getPrivateProp()', pub.getPrivateProp())
console.log('pub', Object.keys(pub))

这种方法的优点

私有属性访问验证被装饰在实例上(可选)。 私有属性可以在控制台、调试器和测试环境中检查,属性简单(没有符号或映射) 您可以控制验证和错误处理

的缺点

代理增加了开销和抽象级别 调试将显示包装对象的Proxy() 访问私有道具的方法需要是箭头函数 当无意中暴露实例时,可能会泄漏私有道具。添加一个方法getSelf = () => this

注:

考虑到开销,这种方法可以用于属性封装和调试的清晰度超过开销的场景。例如,当从存储中填充模型时。如。setjson (json)将确保没有私有道具被破坏。

通过使用WeakMap和Proxy来确保“私有”属性不可见,同时允许在每个作用域上使用相同实例访问WeakMap,可以进一步调整此方法以提供更好的封装。然而,这牺牲了可读性和调试。

我现在听到的建议是使用WeakMaps来保存私人数据,以供其他看客参考。

下面是一个更清晰、有效的例子:

function storePrivateProperties(a, b, c, d) {
  let privateData = new WeakMap;
  // unique object as key, weak map can only accept object as key, when key is no longer referened, garbage collector claims the key-value 
  let keyA = {}, keyB = {}, keyC = {}, keyD = {};

  privateData.set(keyA, a);
  privateData.set(keyB, b);
  privateData.set(keyC, c);
  privateData.set(keyD, d);

  return {
    logPrivateKey(key) {
      switch(key) {
      case "a":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyA));
        break;
      case "b":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyB));
        break;
      case "c":
        console.log(privateData.get(keyC));
        break;
      case "d":
        console.log(privateData.set(keyD));
        break;
      default:
        console.log(`There is no value for ${key}`)
      }
    }
  }
}

现在大多数浏览器都支持私有类特性。

class Something {
  #property;

  constructor(){
    this.#property = "test";
  }

  #privateMethod() {
    return 'hello world';
  }

  getPrivateMessage() {
      return this.#property;
  }
}

const instance = new Something();
console.log(instance.property); //=> undefined
console.log(instance.privateMethod); //=> undefined
console.log(instance.getPrivateMessage()); //=> test
console.log(instance.#property); //=> Syntax error