我想看看哪种方法最快。总的来说,check_replace函数给出了最佳和最一致的结果。check_exception函数给出了最快的结果,但前提是没有触发异常——这意味着它的代码是最有效的,但抛出异常的开销非常大。
请注意,检查成功的强制转换是唯一准确的方法,例如,这与check_exception一起工作,但其他两个测试函数将为有效的float返回False:
huge_number = float('1e+100')
以下是基准代码:
import time, re, random, string
ITERATIONS = 10000000
class Timer:
def __enter__(self):
self.start = time.clock()
return self
def __exit__(self, *args):
self.end = time.clock()
self.interval = self.end - self.start
def check_regexp(x):
return re.compile("^\d*\.?\d*$").match(x) is not None
def check_replace(x):
return x.replace('.','',1).isdigit()
def check_exception(s):
try:
float(s)
return True
except ValueError:
return False
to_check = [check_regexp, check_replace, check_exception]
print('preparing data...')
good_numbers = [
str(random.random() / random.random())
for x in range(ITERATIONS)]
bad_numbers = ['.' + x for x in good_numbers]
strings = [
''.join(random.choice(string.ascii_uppercase + string.digits) for _ in range(random.randint(1,10)))
for x in range(ITERATIONS)]
print('running test...')
for func in to_check:
with Timer() as t:
for x in good_numbers:
res = func(x)
print('%s with good floats: %s' % (func.__name__, t.interval))
with Timer() as t:
for x in bad_numbers:
res = func(x)
print('%s with bad floats: %s' % (func.__name__, t.interval))
with Timer() as t:
for x in strings:
res = func(x)
print('%s with strings: %s' % (func.__name__, t.interval))
以下是2017年MacBook Pro 13上Python 2.7.10的结果:
check_regexp with good floats: 12.688639
check_regexp with bad floats: 11.624862
check_regexp with strings: 11.349414
check_replace with good floats: 4.419841
check_replace with bad floats: 4.294909
check_replace with strings: 4.086358
check_exception with good floats: 3.276668
check_exception with bad floats: 13.843092
check_exception with strings: 15.786169
以下是2017年MacBook Pro 13上Python 3.6.5的结果:
check_regexp with good floats: 13.472906000000009
check_regexp with bad floats: 12.977665000000016
check_regexp with strings: 12.417542999999995
check_replace with good floats: 6.011045999999993
check_replace with bad floats: 4.849356
check_replace with strings: 4.282754000000011
check_exception with good floats: 6.039081999999979
check_exception with bad floats: 9.322753000000006
check_exception with strings: 9.952595000000002
以下是2017年MacBook Pro 13上PyPy 2.7.13的结果:
check_regexp with good floats: 2.693217
check_regexp with bad floats: 2.744819
check_regexp with strings: 2.532414
check_replace with good floats: 0.604367
check_replace with bad floats: 0.538169
check_replace with strings: 0.598664
check_exception with good floats: 1.944103
check_exception with bad floats: 2.449182
check_exception with strings: 2.200056