用JavaScript实现单例模式的最简单/最干净的方法是什么?


当前回答

我的意见:我有一个构造函数(CF),例如,

var A = function(arg1){
  this.arg1 = arg1
};

我只需要这个CF创建的每个对象都是相同的。

var X = function(){
  var instance = {};
  return function(){ return instance; }
}();

Test

var x1 = new X();
var x2 = new X();
console.log(x1 === x2)

其他回答

模块模式:“更具可读性的风格”。您可以很容易地看到哪些方法是公共的,哪些是私有的

var module = (function(_name){
   /* Local Methods & Values */
   var _local = {
      name : _name,
      flags : {
        init : false
      }
   }

   function init(){
     _local.flags.init = true;
   }

   function imaprivatemethod(){
     alert("Hi, I'm a private method");
   }

   /* Public Methods & variables */

   var $r = {}; // This object will hold all public methods.

   $r.methdo1 = function(){
       console.log("method1 calls it");
   }

   $r.method2 = function(){
      imaprivatemethod(); // Calling private method
   }

   $r.init = function(){
      inti(); // Making 'init' public in case you want to init manually and not automatically
   }

   init(); // Automatically calling the init method

   return $r; // Returning all public methods

})("module");

现在你可以使用公共方法,比如

module.method2 ();// ->我正在调用一个私有方法超过一个公共方法警报(“嗨,我是一个私有方法”)

http://jsfiddle.net/ncubica/xMwS9/

简短的回答:

由于JavaScript的非阻塞特性,JavaScript中的单例在使用时非常难看。全局变量将在整个应用程序中为您提供一个实例,而不需要所有这些回调,模块模式将内部隐藏在接口后面。参见Christian C. Salvadó的回答。

但是,既然你想要一个单胞胎……

var singleton = function(initializer) {

  var state = 'initial';
  var instance;
  var queue = [];

  var instanceReady = function(createdInstance) {
    state = 'ready';
    instance = createdInstance;
    while (callback = queue.shift()) {
      callback(instance);
    }
  };

  return function(callback) {
    if (state === 'initial') {
      state = 'waiting';
      queue.push(callback);
      initializer(instanceReady);
    } else if (state === 'waiting') {
      queue.push(callback);
    } else {
      callback(instance);
    }
  };

};

用法:

var singletonInitializer = function(instanceReady) {
  var preparedObject = {property: 'value'};
  // Calling instanceReady notifies the singleton that the instance is ready to use
  instanceReady(preparedObject);
}
var s = singleton(singletonInitializer);

// Get the instance and use it
s(function(instance) {
  instance.doSomething();
});

解释:

单例在整个应用程序中提供了不止一个实例:它们的初始化延迟到第一次使用。当您处理初始化开销很大的对象时,这确实是一个大问题。昂贵通常意味着I/O,在JavaScript中I/O总是意味着回调。

不要相信那些给出instance = singleton.getInstance()这样接口的答案,它们都没有抓住重点。

如果它们没有在实例就绪时运行回调,那么当初始化器执行I/O时,它们将不起作用。

是的,回调看起来总是比函数调用更丑,函数调用会立即返回一个对象实例。但是同样:当你执行I/O时,回调是必须的。如果你不想做任何I/O,那么在程序启动时实例化就足够便宜了。

例1,简单的初始化器:

var simpleInitializer = function(instanceReady) {
  console.log("Initializer started");
  instanceReady({property: "initial value"});
}

var simple = singleton(simpleInitializer);

console.log("Tests started. Singleton instance should not be initalized yet.");

simple(function(inst) {
  console.log("Access 1");
  console.log("Current property value: " + inst.property);
  console.log("Let's reassign this property");
  inst.property = "new value";
});
simple(function(inst) {
  console.log("Access 2");
  console.log("Current property value: " + inst.property);
});

例2,初始化I/O:

在这个例子中,setTimeout模拟了一些昂贵的I/O操作。这说明了为什么JavaScript中的单例真的需要回调。

var heavyInitializer = function(instanceReady) {
  console.log("Initializer started");
  var onTimeout = function() {
    console.log("Initializer did his heavy work");
    instanceReady({property: "initial value"});
  };
  setTimeout(onTimeout, 500);
};

var heavy = singleton(heavyInitializer);

console.log("In this example we will be trying");
console.log("to access singleton twice before it finishes initialization.");

heavy(function(inst) {
  console.log("Access 1");
  console.log("Current property value: " + inst.property);
  console.log("Let's reassign this property");
  inst.property = "new value";
});

heavy(function(inst) {
  console.log("Access 2. You can see callbacks order is preserved.");
  console.log("Current property value: " + inst.property);
});

console.log("We made it to the end of the file. Instance is not ready yet.");

下面是我实现单例模式的演练片段。这是我在面试过程中想到的,我觉得我应该在某个地方捕捉到这一点。

/*************************************************
 *     SINGLETON PATTERN IMPLEMENTATION          *
 *************************************************/

// Since there aren't any classes in JavaScript, every object
// is technically a singleton if you don't inherit from it
// or copy from it.
var single = {};


// Singleton Implementations
//
// Declaring as a global object...you are being judged!

var Logger = function() {
  // global_log is/will be defined in the GLOBAL scope here
  if(typeof global_log === 'undefined'){
    global_log = this;
  }
  return global_log;
};


// The below 'fix' solves the GLOABL variable problem, but
// the log_instance is publicly available and thus can be
// tampered with.
function Logger() {
  if(typeof Logger.log_instance === 'undefined') {
    Logger.log_instance = this;
  }

  return Logger.log_instance;
};


// The correct way to do it to give it a closure!

function logFactory() {
  var log_instance; // Private instance
  var _initLog = function() { // Private init method
    log_instance = 'initialized';
    console.log("logger initialized!")
  }
  return {
    getLog : function(){ // The 'privileged' method
      if(typeof log_instance === 'undefined') {
        _initLog();
      }
      return log_instance;
    }
  };
}


/***** TEST CODE ************************************************

// Using the Logger singleton
var logger = logFactory(); // Did I just give LogFactory a closure?

// Create an instance of the logger
var a = logger.getLog();

// Do some work
// Get another instance of the logger
var b = logger.getLog();

// Check if the two logger instances are same
console.log(a === b); // true
*******************************************************************/

同样可以在我的主旨页面上找到。

如果你正在使用node.JS,那么你可以利用node.JS的缓存机制,你的单例将像这样简单:

class Singleton {
    constructor() {
        this.message = 'I am an instance';
    }
}
module.exports = new Singleton();

请注意,我们导出的不是类Singleton,而是实例Singleton()。

Node.JS将在每次需要时缓存和重用相同的对象。

更多细节请查看:Node.JS和单例模式

var singleton = (function () {

    var singleton = function(){
        // Do stuff
    }
    var instance = new singleton();
    return function(){
        return instance;
    }
})();

一个没有getInstance方法的解决方案。