二进制信号量和互斥量之间有区别吗?或者它们本质上是相同的?


当前回答

互斥锁用于阻塞关键区域,而信号量用于计数。

其他回答

你可以通过以下方法清楚地记住不同之处:

互斥锁:用于保护关键区域, 互斥锁不能跨进程使用,只能在单个进程中使用 信号量:用于信号资源的可用性。 信号量既可以跨进程使用,也可以跨进程使用。

互斥锁:假设我们有临界区线程T1想要访问它,然后按照以下步骤进行。 T1:

锁 使用临界区 解锁

二进制信号量:它基于信号等待和信号工作。 等待将“s”的值减少1,通常“s”的值初始化为值“1”, 信号(s)使“s”值加1。如果“s”值为1表示没有人在使用临界区,当“s”值为0时表示临界区正在使用。 假设线程T2正在使用临界区,那么它遵循以下步骤。 T2:

Wait (s)//最初的s值是1,调用Wait后,它的值减少了1,即0 利用临界区 信号(s) //现在s值增加,变成1

Main difference between Mutex and Binary semaphore is in Mutext if thread lock the critical section then it has to unlock critical section no other thread can unlock it, but in case of Binary semaphore if one thread locks critical section using wait(s) function then value of s become "0" and no one can access it until value of "s" become 1 but suppose some other thread calls signal(s) then value of "s" become 1 and it allows other function to use critical section. hence in Binary semaphore thread doesn't have ownership.

厕所的例子是一个有趣的类比:

Mutex: Is a key to a toilet. One person can have the key - occupy the toilet - at the time. When finished, the person gives (frees) the key to the next person in the queue. Officially: "Mutexes are typically used to serialise access to a section of re-entrant code that cannot be executed concurrently by more than one thread. A mutex object only allows one thread into a controlled section, forcing other threads which attempt to gain access to that section to wait until the first thread has exited from that section." Ref: Symbian Developer Library (A mutex is really a semaphore with value 1.) Semaphore: Is the number of free identical toilet keys. Example, say we have four toilets with identical locks and keys. The semaphore count - the count of keys - is set to 4 at beginning (all four toilets are free), then the count value is decremented as people are coming in. If all toilets are full, ie. there are no free keys left, the semaphore count is 0. Now, when eq. one person leaves the toilet, semaphore is increased to 1 (one free key), and given to the next person in the queue. Officially: "A semaphore restricts the number of simultaneous users of a shared resource up to a maximum number. Threads can request access to the resource (decrementing the semaphore), and can signal that they have finished using the resource (incrementing the semaphore)." Ref: Symbian Developer Library

互斥锁用于“锁定机制”。每次只有一个进程可以使用共享资源

信号量用于“信号机制” 比如“我完成了,现在可以继续了”

互斥锁只能由获得它的线程释放。 二进制信号量可以由任何线程(或进程)发出信号。

因此,信号量更适合于一些同步问题,如生产者-消费者。

在Windows上,二进制信号量更像事件对象而不是互斥对象。