有人能告诉我同步方法比同步块的优势与一个例子吗?
当前回答
在同步方法的情况下,锁将在对象上获得。但是如果你使用同步块,你可以选择指定一个对象来获取锁。
例子:
Class Example {
String test = "abc";
// lock will be acquired on String test object.
synchronized (test) {
// do something
}
lock will be acquired on Example Object
public synchronized void testMethod() {
// do some thing
}
}
其他回答
同步的方法
同步方法有两个效果。 首先,当一个线程正在为一个对象执行同步方法时,所有为同一对象调用同步方法的其他线程将阻塞(暂停执行),直到第一个线程处理完该对象。
其次,当同步方法退出时,它自动与同一对象的同步方法的任何后续调用建立happens-before关系。这保证了对对象状态的更改对于所有线程都是可见的。
注意,构造函数不能同步——在构造函数中使用synchronized关键字是一个语法错误。同步构造函数没有意义,因为只有创建对象的线程才能在构造对象时访问它。
同步语句
与同步方法不同,同步语句必须指定提供内在锁的对象:大多数情况下,我使用它来同步对列表或映射的访问,但我不想阻塞对对象的所有方法的访问。
Q:内在锁和同步 同步是围绕一个称为内在锁或监视器锁的内部实体构建的。(API规范通常将此实体简单地称为“监视器”)内在锁在同步的两个方面都发挥作用:强制独占访问对象的状态,并建立对可见性至关重要的happens-before关系。
Every object has an intrinsic lock associated with it. By convention, a thread that needs exclusive and consistent access to an object's fields has to acquire the object's intrinsic lock before accessing them, and then release the intrinsic lock when it's done with them. A thread is said to own the intrinsic lock between the time it has acquired the lock and released the lock. As long as a thread owns an intrinsic lock, no other thread can acquire the same lock. The other thread will block when it attempts to acquire the lock.
package test;
public class SynchTest implements Runnable {
private int c = 0;
public static void main(String[] args) {
new SynchTest().test();
}
public void test() {
// Create the object with the run() method
Runnable runnable = new SynchTest();
Runnable runnable2 = new SynchTest();
// Create the thread supplying it with the runnable object
Thread thread = new Thread(runnable,"thread-1");
Thread thread2 = new Thread(runnable,"thread-2");
// Here the key point is passing same object, if you pass runnable2 for thread2,
// then its not applicable for synchronization test and that wont give expected
// output Synchronization method means "it is not possible for two invocations
// of synchronized methods on the same object to interleave"
// Start the thread
thread.start();
thread2.start();
}
public synchronized void increment() {
System.out.println("Begin thread " + Thread.currentThread().getName());
System.out.println(this.hashCode() + "Value of C = " + c);
// If we uncomment this for synchronized block, then the result would be different
// synchronized(this) {
for (int i = 0; i < 9999999; i++) {
c += i;
}
// }
System.out.println("End thread " + Thread.currentThread().getName());
}
// public synchronized void decrement() {
// System.out.println("Decrement " + Thread.currentThread().getName());
// }
public int value() {
return c;
}
@Override
public void run() {
this.increment();
}
}
用同步方法,块和不同步交叉检查不同的输出。
来自Java规范摘要: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/andru/javaspec/17.doc.html
The synchronized statement (§14.17) computes a reference to an object; it then attempts to perform a lock action on that object and does not proceed further until the lock action has successfully completed. ... A synchronized method (§8.4.3.5) automatically performs a lock action when it is invoked; its body is not executed until the lock action has successfully completed. If the method is an instance method, it locks the lock associated with the instance for which it was invoked (that is, the object that will be known as this during execution of the body of the method). If the method is static, it locks the lock associated with the Class object that represents the class in which the method is defined. ...
基于这些描述,我想说以前的大多数答案都是正确的,同步方法可能对静态方法特别有用,否则您必须弄清楚如何获得“表示定义方法的类的Class对象”。
编辑:我原本以为这些是对实际Java规范的引用。澄清一下,本页只是对规范的总结/解释
In general these are mostly the same other than being explicit about the object's monitor that's being used vs the implicit this object. One downside of synchronized methods that I think is sometimes overlooked is that in using the "this" reference to synchronize on you are leaving open the possibility of external objects locking on the same object. That can be a very subtle bug if you run into it. Synchronizing on an internal explicit Object or other existing field can avoid this issue, completely encapsulating the synchronization.
谁能告诉我同步方法比同步块的优势与一个例子?谢谢。
与块相比,使用同步方法并没有明显的优势。
也许唯一的一点(但我不认为这是优点)是您不需要包含对象引用this。
方法:
public synchronized void method() { // blocks "this" from here....
...
...
...
} // to here
布洛克:
public void method() {
synchronized( this ) { // blocks "this" from here ....
....
....
....
} // to here...
}
看到了吗?一点好处都没有。
块确实比方法有优势,主要是灵活性,因为你可以使用另一个对象作为锁,而同步方法将锁定整个对象。
比较:
// locks the whole object
...
private synchronized void someInputRelatedWork() {
...
}
private synchronized void someOutputRelatedWork() {
...
}
vs.
// Using specific locks
Object inputLock = new Object();
Object outputLock = new Object();
private void someInputRelatedWork() {
synchronized(inputLock) {
...
}
}
private void someOutputRelatedWork() {
synchronized(outputLock) {
...
}
}
另外,如果方法增长了,你仍然可以保持同步段的分离:
private void method() {
... code here
... code here
... code here
synchronized( lock ) {
... very few lines of code here
}
... code here
... code here
... code here
... code here
}
唯一的区别是:同步块允许颗粒状锁定,不像同步方法
基本上同步块或方法被用来编写线程安全的代码,以避免内存不一致的错误。
这个问题很老了,在过去的7年里,很多事情都发生了变化。 为了线程安全,引入了新的编程结构。
您可以通过使用高级并发API而不是同步块来实现线程安全。该文档页提供了实现线程安全的良好编程结构。
锁对象支持简化许多并发应用程序的锁定习惯用法。
executor为启动和管理线程定义了高级API。concurrent提供的执行器实现提供了适合大型应用程序的线程池管理。
并发集合使管理大型数据集合变得更容易,并且可以大大减少同步的需要。
原子变量具有最小化同步和帮助避免内存一致性错误的特性。
ThreadLocalRandom(在JDK 7中)提供了从多个线程有效生成伪随机数的功能。
更好的synchronized替代品是ReentrantLock,它使用Lock API
一个可重入互斥锁,其基本行为和语义与使用同步方法和语句访问的隐式监视锁相同,但具有扩展功能。
锁的例子:
class X {
private final ReentrantLock lock = new ReentrantLock();
// ...
public void m() {
lock.lock(); // block until condition holds
try {
// ... method body
} finally {
lock.unlock()
}
}
}
其他编程结构也可以参考java.util.concurrent和java.util.concurrent.atomic包。
参考这个相关的问题:
同步vs锁定
推荐文章
- 在Java中从字符串中提取数字
- 套接字的连接超时和读超时之间的区别是什么?
- Java整数到字节数组
- 如何设置Windows环境下Java的环境变量
- Java Swing revalidate() vs repaint()
- Java中文件中的行数
- 指定的子节点已经有一个父节点。你必须先在子对象的父对象上调用removeView() (Android)
- 对于一个布尔字段,它的getter/setter的命名约定是什么?
- 如何获得当前屏幕方向?
- 如何在Android中渲染PDF文件
- 如何计算一个元素在列表中出现的次数
- c++中类似于java的instanceof
- 我如何解决错误“minCompileSdk(31)指定在一个依赖的AAR元数据”在本机Java或Kotlin?
- 如何POST表单数据与Spring RestTemplate?
- Mockito中检测到未完成的存根