在c++中创建类库时,可以在动态(.dll, .so)和静态(.dll, .so)之间进行选择。Lib, .a)库。它们之间的区别是什么?什么时候使用哪个比较合适?
当前回答
您应该仔细考虑随时间的变化、版本控制、稳定性、兼容性等。
如果有两个应用程序使用共享代码,您是否希望强制这些应用程序一起更改,以防它们需要相互兼容?然后使用dll。所有的exe都将使用相同的代码。
或者你想把它们彼此隔离,这样你就可以改变一个,并确信你没有破坏另一个。然后使用静态库。
DLL地狱是当你可能应该使用一个静态库,但你使用了一个DLL代替,并不是所有的前任都与它兼容。
其他回答
如果您的库将在几个可执行文件之间共享,那么将其动态化以减少可执行文件的大小通常是有意义的。否则,一定要让它是静态的。
使用dll有几个缺点。装载和卸载它有额外的开销。还有一个额外的依赖关系。如果您更改dll使其与执行表不兼容,则它们将停止工作。另一方面,如果您更改了静态库,则使用旧版本编译的可执行文件将不会受到影响。
Static libraries are archives that contain the object code for the library, when linked into an application that code is compiled into the executable. Shared libraries are different in that they aren't compiled into the executable. Instead the dynamic linker searches some directories looking for the library(s) it needs, then loads that into memory. More then one executable can use the same shared library at the same time, thus reducing memory usage and executable size. However, there are then more files to distribute with the executable. You need to make sure that the library is installed onto the uses system somewhere where the linker can find it, static linking eliminates this problem but results in a larger executable file.
其他人已经充分解释了静态库是什么,但我想指出一些使用静态库的注意事项,至少在Windows上:
Singletons: If something needs to be global/static and unique, be very careful about putting it in a static library. If multiple DLLs are linked against that static library they will each get their own copy of the singleton. However, if your application is a single EXE with no custom DLLs, this may not be a problem. Unreferenced code removal: When you link against a static library, only the parts of the static library that are referenced by your DLL/EXE will get linked into your DLL/EXE. For example, if mylib.lib contains a.obj and b.obj and your DLL/EXE only references functions or variables from a.obj, the entirety of b.obj will get discarded by the linker. If b.obj contains global/static objects, their constructors and destructors will not get executed. If those constructors/destructors have side effects, you may be disappointed by their absence. Likewise, if the static library contains special entrypoints you may need to take care that they are actually included. An example of this in embedded programming (okay, not Windows) would be an interrupt handler that is marked as being at a specific address. You also need to mark the interrupt handler as an entrypoint to make sure it doesn't get discarded. Another consequence of this is that a static library may contain object files that are completely unusable due to unresolved references, but it won't cause a linker error until you reference a function or variable from those object files. This may happen long after the library is written. Debug symbols: You may want a separate PDB for each static library, or you may want the debug symbols to be placed in the object files so that they get rolled into the PDB for the DLL/EXE. The Visual C++ documentation explains the necessary options. RTTI: You may end up with multiple type_info objects for the same class if you link a single static library into multiple DLLs. If your program assumes that type_info is "singleton" data and uses &typeid() or type_info::before(), you may get undesirable and surprising results.
真正的权衡(在一个大型项目中)是在初始加载时间,库将在某个时间被链接,必须做出的决定是链接是否需要足够长的时间,以至于编译器需要咬紧牙关并提前完成,还是动态链接器可以在加载时完成。
如果你在嵌入式项目或专门的平台上工作,静态库是唯一的方法,而且很多时候它们编译到你的应用程序中不是那么麻烦。同时,拥有包含一切的项目和makefile会让生活更快乐。
推荐文章
- cplusplus.com给出的错误、误解或坏建议是什么?
- 找出质数最快的算法是什么?
- 如何使用Python中的DLL文件?
- c++枚举类可以有方法吗?
- 格式化IO函数(*printf / *scanf)中的转换说明符%i和%d之间的区别是什么?
- 将析构函数设为私有有什么用?
- main()中的Return语句vs exit()
- 为什么c#不提供c++风格的'friend'关键字?
- 在函数的签名中添加关键字
- 我如何在Visual Studio中预处理后看到C/ c++源文件?
- 为什么在标准容器中使用std::auto_ptr<>是错误的?
- 用比较double和0
- 保护可执行文件不受逆向工程的影响?
- 在c++中字符串前面的“L”是什么意思?
- 为什么std::map被实现为红黑树?