什么时候我应该存储订阅实例和调用unsubscribe()在ngOnDestroy生命周期,什么时候我可以简单地忽略它们?

保存所有订阅会给组件代码带来很多麻烦。

HTTP客户端指南忽略这样的订阅:

getHeroes() {
  this.heroService.getHeroes()
                  .subscribe(
                     heroes => this.heroes = heroes,
                     error =>  this.errorMessage = <any>error);
}

同时,《航路指南》指出:

最终,我们会航行到别的地方。路由器将从DOM中移除这个组件并销毁它。在那之前,我们得把自己弄干净。具体来说,我们必须在Angular销毁该组件之前取消订阅。如果不这样做,可能会产生内存泄漏。 我们在ngOnDestroy方法中取消订阅我们的可观察对象。

private sub: any;

ngOnInit() {
  this.sub = this.route.params.subscribe(params => {
     let id = +params['id']; // (+) converts string 'id' to a number
     this.service.getHero(id).then(hero => this.hero = hero);
   });
}

ngOnDestroy() {
  this.sub.unsubscribe();
}

当前回答

对于每一个订阅,你都需要取消订阅。Advantage =>以防止状态变得过于沉重。

例如: 在组件1中:

import {UserService} from './user.service';

private user = {name: 'test', id: 1}

constructor(public userService: UserService) {
    this.userService.onUserChange.next(this.user);
}

在服务:

import {BehaviorSubject} from 'rxjs/BehaviorSubject';

public onUserChange: BehaviorSubject<any> = new BehaviorSubject({});

于component2:

import {Subscription} from 'rxjs/Subscription';
import {UserService} from './user.service';

private onUserChange: Subscription;

constructor(public userService: UserService) {
    this.onUserChange = this.userService.onUserChange.subscribe(user => {
        console.log(user);
    });
}

public ngOnDestroy(): void {
    // note: Here you have to be sure to unsubscribe to the subscribe item!
    this.onUserChange.unsubscribe();
}

其他回答

对于每一个订阅,你都需要取消订阅。Advantage =>以防止状态变得过于沉重。

例如: 在组件1中:

import {UserService} from './user.service';

private user = {name: 'test', id: 1}

constructor(public userService: UserService) {
    this.userService.onUserChange.next(this.user);
}

在服务:

import {BehaviorSubject} from 'rxjs/BehaviorSubject';

public onUserChange: BehaviorSubject<any> = new BehaviorSubject({});

于component2:

import {Subscription} from 'rxjs/Subscription';
import {UserService} from './user.service';

private onUserChange: Subscription;

constructor(public userService: UserService) {
    this.onUserChange = this.userService.onUserChange.subscribe(user => {
        console.log(user);
    });
}

public ngOnDestroy(): void {
    // note: Here you have to be sure to unsubscribe to the subscribe item!
    this.onUserChange.unsubscribe();
}

SubSink包,一个简单而一致的取消订阅的解决方案

由于没有人提到它,我想推荐Ward Bell创建的Subsink包:https://github.com/wardbell/subsink#readme。

我一直在一个项目中使用它,我们有几个开发人员都在使用它。在任何情况下都有一种一致的工作方式是很有帮助的。

下面是我对这个问题的看法,保持我的生活简单,我选择手动方式取消订阅时,组件被破坏。

为此,我创建了一个名为Subscriptor的类,它主要包含静态成员,即:

私有变量subscriptions——它保存所有提供的订阅 订阅设置器——将每个新订阅推送到订阅数组 一个取消订阅方法——如果定义了订阅数组,则取消订阅数组中包含的每个订阅,并清空订阅数组

subscriptor.ts

import { Subscription } from "rxjs";

export class Subscriptor {
    private static subscriptions: Subscription[] = [];

    static set subscription(subscription: Subscription) {
        Subscriptor.subscriptions.push(subscription);
    }

    static unsubscribe() {
        Subscriptor.subscriptions.forEach(subscription => subscription ? subscription.unsubscribe() : 0);
        Subscriptor.subscriptions = [];
    }
}

组件内部的用法如下:

当您想订阅任何服务时,只需将订阅放到Subscriptor的setter中即可。

ngOnInit(): void {
    Subscriptor.subscription = this.userService.getAll().subscribe(users => this.users = users);
    Subscriptor.subscription = this.categoryService.getAll().subscribe(categories => this.categories = categories);
    Subscriptor.subscription = this.postService.getAll().subscribe(posts => this.posts = posts);
}

当您想取消订阅任何服务时,只需调用Subscriptor的unsubscribe方法。

ngOnDestroy(): void {
    Subscriptor.unsubscribe();
}

由于seangwright的解决方案(编辑3)似乎非常有用,我也发现将这个功能打包到基本组件中是一个痛苦的过程,并提示其他项目队友记住在ngOnDestroy上调用super()来激活这个功能。

这个答案提供了一种从super调用中释放的方法,并使"componentDestroyed$"成为base component的核心。

class BaseClass {
    protected componentDestroyed$: Subject<void> = new Subject<void>();
    constructor() {

        /// wrap the ngOnDestroy to be an Observable. and set free from calling super() on ngOnDestroy.
        let _$ = this.ngOnDestroy;
        this.ngOnDestroy = () => {
            this.componentDestroyed$.next();
            this.componentDestroyed$.complete();
            _$();
        }
    }

    /// placeholder of ngOnDestroy. no need to do super() call of extended class.
    ngOnDestroy() {}
}

然后你可以自由地使用这个功能,例如:

@Component({
    selector: 'my-thing',
    templateUrl: './my-thing.component.html'
})
export class MyThingComponent extends BaseClass implements OnInit, OnDestroy {
    constructor(
        private myThingService: MyThingService,
    ) { super(); }

    ngOnInit() {
        this.myThingService.getThings()
            .takeUntil(this.componentDestroyed$)
            .subscribe(things => console.log(things));
    }

    /// optional. not a requirement to implement OnDestroy
    ngOnDestroy() {
        console.log('everything works as intended with or without super call');
    }

}

官方的Edit #3答案(及其变体)工作得很好,但让我困惑的是围绕可观察订阅的业务逻辑的“混乱”。

下面是使用包装器的另一种方法。

警告:实验代码

文件subscribeAndGuard。ts用于创建一个新的Observable扩展来包装.subscribe(),并在其中包装ngOnDestroy()。 用法与.subscribe()相同,除了附加的第一个参数引用了组件。

import { Observable } from 'rxjs/Observable';
import { Subscription } from 'rxjs/Subscription';

const subscribeAndGuard = function(component, fnData, fnError = null, fnComplete = null) {

  // Define the subscription
  const sub: Subscription = this.subscribe(fnData, fnError, fnComplete);

  // Wrap component's onDestroy
  if (!component.ngOnDestroy) {
    throw new Error('To use subscribeAndGuard, the component must implement ngOnDestroy');
  }
  const saved_OnDestroy = component.ngOnDestroy;
  component.ngOnDestroy = () => {
    console.log('subscribeAndGuard.onDestroy');
    sub.unsubscribe();
    // Note: need to put original back in place
    // otherwise 'this' is undefined in component.ngOnDestroy
    component.ngOnDestroy = saved_OnDestroy;
    component.ngOnDestroy();

  };

  return sub;
};

// Create an Observable extension
Observable.prototype.subscribeAndGuard = subscribeAndGuard;

// Ref: https://www.typescriptlang.org/docs/handbook/declaration-merging.html
declare module 'rxjs/Observable' {
  interface Observable<T> {
    subscribeAndGuard: typeof subscribeAndGuard;
  }
}

下面是一个带有两个订阅的组件,一个带有包装器,另一个没有。唯一需要注意的是,它必须实现OnDestroy(如果需要的话,它的主体是空的),否则Angular就不知道调用被包装的版本。

import { Component, OnInit, OnDestroy } from '@angular/core';
import { Observable } from 'rxjs/Observable';
import 'rxjs/Rx';
import './subscribeAndGuard';

@Component({
  selector: 'app-subscribing',
  template: '<h3>Subscribing component is active</h3>',
})
export class SubscribingComponent implements OnInit, OnDestroy {

  ngOnInit() {

    // This subscription will be terminated after onDestroy
    Observable.interval(1000)
      .subscribeAndGuard(this,
        (data) => { console.log('Guarded:', data); },
        (error) => { },
        (/*completed*/) => { }
      );

    // This subscription will continue after onDestroy
    Observable.interval(1000)
      .subscribe(
        (data) => { console.log('Unguarded:', data); },
        (error) => { },
        (/*completed*/) => { }
      );
  }

  ngOnDestroy() {
    console.log('SubscribingComponent.OnDestroy');
  }
}

演示活塞在这里

附加说明: Re Edit 3 -“官方”解决方案,这可以通过在订阅前使用takeWhile()而不是takeUntil()来简化,以及一个简单的布尔值而不是ngOnDestroy中的另一个Observable。

@Component({...})
export class SubscribingComponent implements OnInit, OnDestroy {

  iAmAlive = true;
  ngOnInit() {

    Observable.interval(1000)
      .takeWhile(() => { return this.iAmAlive; })
      .subscribe((data) => { console.log(data); });
  }

  ngOnDestroy() {
    this.iAmAlive = false;
  }
}