使用电子邮件地址作为主键的缺点:

Slower when doing joins. Any other record with a posted foreign key now has a larger value, taking up more disk space. (Given the cost of disk space today, this is probably a trivial issue, except to the extent that the record now takes longer to read. See #1.) An email address could change, which forces all records using this as a foreign key to be updated. As email address don't change all that often, the performance problem is probably minor. The bigger problem is that you have to make sure to provide for it. If you have to write the code, this is more work and introduces the possibility of bugs. If your database engine supports "on update cascade", it's a minor issue.

使用电邮地址作主键的优点:

You may be able to completely eliminate some joins. If all you need from the "master record" is the email address, then with an abstract integer key you would have to do a join to retrieve it. If the key is the email address, then you already have it and the join is unnecessary. Whether this helps you any depends on how often this situation comes up. When you are doing ad hoc queries, it's easy for a human being to see what master record is being referenced. This can be a big help when trying to track down data problems. You almost certainly will need an index on the email address anyway, so making it the primary key eliminates one index, thus improving the performance of inserts as they now have only one index to update instead of two.

在我看来，这两种情况都不是十拿九稳的。当有实用的键时，我倾向于使用自然键，因为它们更容易使用，而且在大多数情况下，缺点并不太重要。

你的同事是对的:使用一个自动递增的整数作为你的主键。

您可以在应用程序级别实现电子邮件唯一性，或者您可以将电子邮件地址列标记为惟一，并在该列上添加索引。

将字段添加为唯一字段只会在插入到该表时花费字符串比较的成本，而不会在执行连接和外键约束检查时花费字符串比较成本。

当然，您必须注意，在数据库级别向应用程序添加任何约束都可能导致应用程序变得不灵活。在仅仅因为应用程序需要某个字段是唯一的或非空的，就将它设置为“唯一的”或“非空的”之前，一定要充分考虑。

就我个人而言，我在设计数据库时不使用任何信息作为主键，因为我很可能在以后需要更改任何信息。我提供主键的唯一原因是，它方便从客户端执行大多数SQL操作，我的选择一直是自动增加整数类型。

您应该使用整数主键。如果你需要电子邮件列是唯一的，为什么不简单地在该列上设置一个唯一索引呢?

我不知道这在您的设置中是否可能是一个问题，但根据您的RDBMS，列的值可能是区分大小写的。PostgreSQL文档说:“如果你声明一个列为UNIQUE或PRIMARY KEY，隐式生成的索引是区分大小写的”。换句话说，如果您在一个以email为主键的表中接受用户输入进行搜索，并且用户提供“John@Doe.com”，那么您将找不到“john@doe.com”。

主键应该选择一个静态属性。由于电子邮件地址不是静态的，可以被多个候选人共享，因此使用它们作为主键并不是一个好主意。此外，电子邮件地址通常是一定长度的字符串，可能大于唯一id，我们想使用[len(email_address)>len(unique_id)]，所以它将需要更多的空间，甚至最糟糕的是，它们被多次存储为外键。因此会导致性能下降。