二进制信号量和互斥量之间有区别吗?或者它们本质上是相同的?


当前回答

“二进制信号量”是一种编程语言规避使用«信号量»,如«互斥量»。显然有两个非常大的区别:

你称呼他们的方式。 标识符的最大长度。

其他回答

互斥锁用于阻塞关键区域,而信号量用于计数。

它们的同步语义非常不同:

互斥对象允许对给定资源的序列化访问,即多个线程等待一个锁,一次一个,正如前面所说,线程拥有锁,直到锁完成:只有这个特定的线程可以解锁它。 二进制信号量是一个值为0和1的计数器:任务阻塞在它上,直到任何任务执行sem_post。信号量宣布资源可用,并提供等待机制,直到发出可用信号。

因此,可以将互斥锁视为在任务之间传递的令牌,将信号量视为交通红灯(它向某人发出信号,表示可以继续进行)。

在看了上面的帖子后,这个概念对我来说很清楚。但仍有一些挥之不去的问题。所以,我写了一小段代码。

当我们试图给出一个信号量而不接收它时,它就会通过。但是,当你试图给出一个互斥量而不获取它时,它会失败。我在Windows平台上进行了测试。启用USE_MUTEX使用MUTEX运行相同的代码。

#include <stdio.h>
#include <windows.h>
#define xUSE_MUTEX 1
#define MAX_SEM_COUNT 1

DWORD WINAPI Thread_no_1( LPVOID lpParam );
DWORD WINAPI Thread_no_2( LPVOID lpParam );

HANDLE Handle_Of_Thread_1 = 0;
HANDLE Handle_Of_Thread_2 = 0;
int Data_Of_Thread_1 = 1;
int Data_Of_Thread_2 = 2;
HANDLE ghMutex = NULL;
HANDLE ghSemaphore = NULL;


int main(void)
{

#ifdef USE_MUTEX
    ghMutex = CreateMutex( NULL, FALSE, NULL);
    if (ghMutex  == NULL) 
    {
        printf("CreateMutex error: %d\n", GetLastError());
        return 1;
    }
#else
    // Create a semaphore with initial and max counts of MAX_SEM_COUNT
    ghSemaphore = CreateSemaphore(NULL,MAX_SEM_COUNT,MAX_SEM_COUNT,NULL);
    if (ghSemaphore == NULL) 
    {
        printf("CreateSemaphore error: %d\n", GetLastError());
        return 1;
    }
#endif
    // Create thread 1.
    Handle_Of_Thread_1 = CreateThread( NULL, 0,Thread_no_1, &Data_Of_Thread_1, 0, NULL);  
    if ( Handle_Of_Thread_1 == NULL)
    {
        printf("Create first thread problem \n");
        return 1;
    }

    /* sleep for 5 seconds **/
    Sleep(5 * 1000);

    /*Create thread 2 */
    Handle_Of_Thread_2 = CreateThread( NULL, 0,Thread_no_2, &Data_Of_Thread_2, 0, NULL);  
    if ( Handle_Of_Thread_2 == NULL)
    {
        printf("Create second thread problem \n");
        return 1;
    }

    // Sleep for 20 seconds
    Sleep(20 * 1000);

    printf("Out of the program \n");
    return 0;
}


int my_critical_section_code(HANDLE thread_handle)
{

#ifdef USE_MUTEX
    if(thread_handle == Handle_Of_Thread_1)
    {
        /* get the lock */
        WaitForSingleObject(ghMutex, INFINITE);
        printf("Thread 1 holding the mutex \n");
    }
#else
    /* get the semaphore */
    if(thread_handle == Handle_Of_Thread_1)
    {
        WaitForSingleObject(ghSemaphore, INFINITE);
        printf("Thread 1 holding semaphore \n");
    }
#endif

    if(thread_handle == Handle_Of_Thread_1)
    {
        /* sleep for 10 seconds */
        Sleep(10 * 1000);
#ifdef USE_MUTEX
        printf("Thread 1 about to release mutex \n");
#else
        printf("Thread 1 about to release semaphore \n");
#endif
    }
    else
    {
        /* sleep for 3 secconds */
        Sleep(3 * 1000);
    }

#ifdef USE_MUTEX
    /* release the lock*/
    if(!ReleaseMutex(ghMutex))
    {
        printf("Release Mutex error in thread %d: error # %d\n", (thread_handle == Handle_Of_Thread_1 ? 1:2),GetLastError());
    }
#else
    if (!ReleaseSemaphore(ghSemaphore,1,NULL) )      
    {
        printf("ReleaseSemaphore error in thread %d: error # %d\n",(thread_handle == Handle_Of_Thread_1 ? 1:2), GetLastError());
    }
#endif

    return 0;
}

DWORD WINAPI Thread_no_1( LPVOID lpParam ) 
{ 
    my_critical_section_code(Handle_Of_Thread_1);
    return 0;
}


DWORD WINAPI Thread_no_2( LPVOID lpParam ) 
{
    my_critical_section_code(Handle_Of_Thread_2);
    return 0;
}

信号量允许您发出“使用资源完成”的信号,即使它从未拥有该资源,这一事实使我认为在信号量的情况下,拥有和发出信号之间存在非常松散的耦合。

虽然互斥量和信号量被用作同步原语,但它们之间有很大的区别。 在互斥锁的情况下,只有锁定或获得互斥锁的线程才能解锁它。 在信号量的情况下,等待信号量的线程可以由另一个线程发出信号。 一些操作系统支持在进程之间使用互斥量和信号量。通常使用是在共享内存中创建的。

I think most of the answers here were confusing especially those saying that mutex can be released only by the process that holds it but semaphore can be signaled by ay process. The above line is kind of vague in terms of semaphore. To understand we should know that there are two kinds of semaphore one is called counting semaphore and the other is called a binary semaphore. In counting semaphore handles access to n number of resources where n can be defined before the use. Each semaphore has a count variable, which keeps the count of the number of resources in use, initially, it is set to n. Each process that wishes to uses a resource performs a wait() operation on the semaphore (thereby decrementing the count). When a process releases a resource, it performs a release() operation (incrementing the count). When the count becomes 0, all the resources are being used. After that, the process waits until the count becomes more than 0. Now here is the catch only the process that holds the resource can increase the count no other process can increase the count only the processes holding a resource can increase the count and the process waiting for the semaphore again checks and when it sees the resource available it decreases the count again. So in terms of binary semaphore, only the process holding the semaphore can increase the count, and count remains zero until it stops using the semaphore and increases the count and other process gets the chance to access the semaphore.

二进制信号量和互斥量之间的主要区别在于,信号量是一种信号机制,而互斥量是一种锁定机制,但二进制信号量的功能似乎与互斥量类似,这造成了混乱,但两者是适用于不同类型工作的不同概念。