要创建一个带有公共方法的JavaScript类,我可以这样做:

function Restaurant() {}

Restaurant.prototype.buy_food = function(){
   // something here
}

Restaurant.prototype.use_restroom = function(){
   // something here
}

这样,我类的用户就可以:

var restaurant = new Restaurant();
restaurant.buy_food();
restaurant.use_restroom();

如何创建一个私有方法,可以由buy_food和use_restroom方法调用,但不能由类的用户外部调用?

换句话说,我希望我的方法实现能够做到:

Restaurant.prototype.use_restroom = function() {
   this.private_stuff();
}

但这是行不通的:

var r = new Restaurant();
r.private_stuff();

如何将private_stuff定义为私有方法,使两者都成立?

我读过Doug Crockford的文章几次,但它似乎不像“私有”方法可以被公共方法调用,而“特权”方法可以被外部调用。


当前回答

就我个人而言,我更喜欢用JavaScript创建类的以下模式:

var myClass = (function() {
    // Private class properties go here

    var blueprint = function() {
        // Private instance properties go here
        ...
    };

    blueprint.prototype = { 
        // Public class properties go here
        ...
    };

    return  {
         // Public class properties go here
        create : function() { return new blueprint(); }
        ...
    };
})();

如您所见,它允许您定义类属性和实例属性,每个属性都可以是公共的和私有的。


Demo

var Restaurant = function() { var totalfoodcount = 0; // Private class property var totalrestroomcount = 0; // Private class property var Restaurant = function(name){ var foodcount = 0; // Private instance property var restroomcount = 0; // Private instance property this.name = name this.incrementFoodCount = function() { foodcount++; totalfoodcount++; this.printStatus(); }; this.incrementRestroomCount = function() { restroomcount++; totalrestroomcount++; this.printStatus(); }; this.getRestroomCount = function() { return restroomcount; }, this.getFoodCount = function() { return foodcount; } }; Restaurant.prototype = { name : '', buy_food : function(){ this.incrementFoodCount(); }, use_restroom : function(){ this.incrementRestroomCount(); }, getTotalRestroomCount : function() { return totalrestroomcount; }, getTotalFoodCount : function() { return totalfoodcount; }, printStatus : function() { document.body.innerHTML += '<h3>Buying food at '+this.name+'</h3>' + '<ul>' + '<li>Restroom count at ' + this.name + ' : '+ this.getRestroomCount() + '</li>' + '<li>Food count at ' + this.name + ' : ' + this.getFoodCount() + '</li>' + '<li>Total restroom count : '+ this.getTotalRestroomCount() + '</li>' + '<li>Total food count : '+ this.getTotalFoodCount() + '</li>' + '</ul>'; } }; return { // Singleton public properties create : function(name) { return new Restaurant(name); }, printStatus : function() { document.body.innerHTML += '<hr />' + '<h3>Overview</h3>' + '<ul>' + '<li>Total restroom count : '+ Restaurant.prototype.getTotalRestroomCount() + '</li>' + '<li>Total food count : '+ Restaurant.prototype.getTotalFoodCount() + '</li>' + '</ul>' + '<hr />'; } }; }(); var Wendys = Restaurant.create("Wendy's"); var McDonalds = Restaurant.create("McDonald's"); var KFC = Restaurant.create("KFC"); var BurgerKing = Restaurant.create("Burger King"); Restaurant.printStatus(); Wendys.buy_food(); Wendys.use_restroom(); KFC.use_restroom(); KFC.use_restroom(); Wendys.use_restroom(); McDonalds.buy_food(); BurgerKing.buy_food(); Restaurant.printStatus(); BurgerKing.buy_food(); Wendys.use_restroom(); McDonalds.buy_food(); KFC.buy_food(); Wendys.buy_food(); BurgerKing.buy_food(); McDonalds.buy_food(); Restaurant.printStatus();

看看这小提琴。

其他回答

我已经创建了一个新工具,允许您在原型上拥有真正的私有方法 https://github.com/TremayneChrist/ProtectJS

例子:

var MyObject = (function () {

  // Create the object
  function MyObject() {}

  // Add methods to the prototype
  MyObject.prototype = {

    // This is our public method
    public: function () {
      console.log('PUBLIC method has been called');
    },

    // This is our private method, using (_)
    _private: function () {
      console.log('PRIVATE method has been called');
    }
  }

  return protect(MyObject);

})();

// Create an instance of the object
var mo = new MyObject();

// Call its methods
mo.public(); // Pass
mo._private(); // Fail

将所有代码包装在匿名函数中:然后,所有函数将是私有的,只有函数附加到窗口对象:

(function(w,nameSpacePrivate){
     w.Person=function(name){
         this.name=name;   
         return this;
     };

     w.Person.prototype.profilePublic=function(){
          return nameSpacePrivate.profile.call(this);
     };  

     nameSpacePrivate.profile=function(){
       return 'My name is '+this.name;
     };

})(window,{});

用这个:

  var abdennour=new Person('Abdennour');
  abdennour.profilePublic();

小提琴

我想到了这个:编辑:实际上,有人已经链接到一个相同的解决方案。咄!

var Car = function() {
}

Car.prototype = (function() {
    var hotWire = function() {
        // Private code *with* access to public properties through 'this'
        alert( this.drive() ); // Alerts 'Vroom!'
    }

    return {
        steal: function() {
            hotWire.call( this ); // Call a private method
        },
        drive: function() {
            return 'Vroom!';
        }
    };
})();

var getAwayVechile = new Car();

hotWire(); // Not allowed
getAwayVechile.hotWire(); // Not allowed
getAwayVechile.steal(); // Alerts 'Vroom!'

老问题,但这是一个相当简单的任务,可以用核心JS正确解决…没有ES6的Class抽象。事实上,据我所知,类抽象甚至不能解决这个问题。

我们既可以使用老的构造函数,也可以使用Object.create()更好地完成这项工作。让我们先从构造函数开始。这本质上是一个与georgebrock的答案相似的解决方案,georgebrock的答案受到了批评,因为所有由Restaurant构造函数创建的餐厅都将具有相同的私有方法。我会努力克服这个限制。

function restaurantFactory(name,menu){ function Restaurant(name){ this.name = name; } function prototypeFactory(menu){ // This is a private function function calculateBill(item){ return menu[item] || 0; } // This is the prototype to be return { constructor: Restaurant , askBill : function(...items){ var cost = items.reduce((total,item) => total + calculateBill(item) ,0) return "Thank you for dining at " + this.name + ". Total is: " + cost + "\n" } , callWaiter : function(){ return "I have just called the waiter at " + this.name + "\n"; } } } Restaurant.prototype = prototypeFactory(menu); return new Restaurant(name,menu); } var menu = { water: 1 , coke : 2 , beer : 3 , beef : 15 , rice : 2 }, name = "Silver Scooop", rest = restaurantFactory(name,menu); console.log(rest.callWaiter()); console.log(rest.askBill("beer", "beef"));

现在显然我们不能从外部访问菜单,但我们可以很容易地重命名餐厅的name属性。

这也可以用object .create()来完成,在这种情况下,我们跳过构造函数,简单地像var rest = object .create(prototypeFactory(menu))那样做,然后像rest.name = name那样将name属性添加到rest对象。

模块模式的典范:揭示模块模式

一个非常健壮的模式的简洁的小扩展。