下面哪个比较好?

a instanceof B

or

B.class.isAssignableFrom(a.getClass())

我所知道的唯一区别是,当'a'为空时,第一个返回false,而第二个抛出异常。除此之外,它们总是给出相同的结果吗?


当前回答

在使用instanceof时,您需要在编译时知道B的类。当使用isAssignableFrom()时,它可以是动态的,并在运行时更改。

其他回答

我们在团队中做的一些测试表明,A.class. isassignablefrom (B. getclass())比B instanceof a工作得更快,如果你需要对大量元素进行检查,这是非常有用的。

更直接的等价于B的实例是

B.class.isInstance(a)

当a为空时,这也可以工作(返回false)。

还有另一个区别:

不管X是什么,null instanceof X都是假的

null.getClass().isAssignableFrom(X)将抛出NullPointerException

除了上面提到的基本区别之外,在类中的instanceof操作符和isAssignableFrom方法之间还有一个核心的微妙区别。

Read instanceof as “is this (the left part) the instance of this or any subclass of this (the right part)” and read x.getClass().isAssignableFrom(Y.class) as “Can I write X x = new Y()”. In other words, instanceof operator checks if the left object is same or subclass of right class, while isAssignableFrom checks if we can assign object of the parameter class (from) to the reference of the class on which the method is called. Note that both of these consider the actual instance not the reference type.

考虑一个A、B和C三个类的例子,其中C扩展了B, B扩展了A。

B b = new C();

System.out.println(b instanceof A); //is b (which is actually class C object) instance of A, yes. This will return true.  
System.out.println(b instanceof B); // is b (which is actually class C object) instance of B, yes. This will return true.  
System.out.println(b instanceof C); // is b (which is actually class C object) instance of C, yes. This will return true. If the first statement would be B b = new B(), this would have been false.
System.out.println(b.getClass().isAssignableFrom(A.class));//Can I write C c = new A(), no. So this is false.
System.out.println(b.getClass().isAssignableFrom(B.class)); //Can I write C c = new B(), no. So this is false.
System.out.println(b.getClass().isAssignableFrom(C.class)); //Can I write C c = new C(), Yes. So this is true.

考虑以下情况。假设你想检查类型A是否是obj类型的超类,你也可以这样做

... A.class.isAssignableFrom(obj.getClass()) ...

OR

... A . obj instanceof ...

但是isAssignableFrom解决方案要求obj的类型在这里是可见的。如果不是这样(例如,obj的类型可能是一个私有内部类),则该选项无效。然而,instanceof solution总是可以工作的。