给定两个日期范围,确定两个日期是否重叠的最简单或最有效的方法是什么?
例如,假设我们有由DateTime变量StartDate1到EndDate1和StartDate2到EndDate2表示的范围。
给定两个日期范围,确定两个日期是否重叠的最简单或最有效的方法是什么?
例如,假设我们有由DateTime变量StartDate1到EndDate1和StartDate2到EndDate2表示的范围。
当前回答
(起点A<=终点B)和(终点A>=起点B)
证明:让条件A表示日期范围A完全在日期范围B之后
_ |---- DateRange A ------|
|---Date Range B -----| _
(如果StartA>EndB,则为True)
让条件B表示日期范围A完全在日期范围B之前
|---- DateRange A -----| _
_ |---Date Range B ----|
(如果EndA<StartB,则为True)
如果A和B都不为真,则存在重叠-(如果一个范围既不完全在另一个范围之后,也不完全在另一个之前,则它们必须重叠。)
现在,德摩根的一项法律规定:
不是(A或B)<=>不是A也不是B
转换为:(StartA<=EndB)和(EndA>=StartB)
注意:这包括边缘完全重叠的情况。如果你想排除这一点,将>=运算符更改为>,并将<=更改为<
注2.多亏了@宝爸,看看这个博客,实际的重叠最少:{endA startA,endA-startB,endB startA,end B-startB}
(起点A<=终点B)和(终点A>=起点B)(开始A<=结束B)和(开始B<=结束A)
注3.多亏了@tomosius,一个简短的版本写道:DateRangesOverlap=最大值(start1,start2)<最小值(end1,end2)这实际上是一个较长实现的语法快捷方式,它包括额外的检查,以验证开始日期是否在结束日期之前。从上面得出:
如果开始日期和结束日期可能是无序的,即,如果startA>endA或startB>endB是可能的,那么您还必须检查它们是否有序,这意味着您必须添加两个额外的有效性规则:(StartA<=EndB)和(StartB<=EndA)以及或:(开始A<=结束B)和(开始A<=结束A)以及(开始B<=结束A”和(开始B<=结束B”)或(开始A<=最小值(结束A,结束B)和(开始B<=最小(结束A、结束B))或:(最大值(开始A,开始B)<=最小值(结束A,结束B)
但要实现Min()和Max(),必须编写代码(使用C三进制表示简洁):((开始A>开始B)?开始A:开始B)<=((结束A<结束B)?端A:端B)
其他回答
这里有一个可以在本地使用的通用方法。
// Takes a list and returns all records that have overlapping time ranges.
public static IEnumerable<T> GetOverlappedTimes<T>(IEnumerable<T> list, Func<T, bool> filter, Func<T,DateTime> start, Func<T, DateTime> end)
{
// Selects all records that match filter() on left side and returns all records on right side that overlap.
var overlap = from t1 in list
where filter(t1)
from t2 in list
where !object.Equals(t1, t2) // Don't match the same record on right side.
let in1 = start(t1)
let out1 = end(t1)
let in2 = start(t2)
let out2 = end(t2)
where in1 <= out2 && out1 >= in2
let totover = GetMins(in1, out1, in2, out2)
select t2;
return overlap;
}
public static void TestOverlap()
{
var tl1 = new TempTimeEntry() { ID = 1, Name = "Bill", In = "1/1/08 1:00pm".ToDate(), Out = "1/1/08 4:00pm".ToDate() };
var tl2 = new TempTimeEntry() { ID = 2, Name = "John", In = "1/1/08 5:00pm".ToDate(), Out = "1/1/08 6:00pm".ToDate() };
var tl3 = new TempTimeEntry() { ID = 3, Name = "Lisa", In = "1/1/08 7:00pm".ToDate(), Out = "1/1/08 9:00pm".ToDate() };
var tl4 = new TempTimeEntry() { ID = 4, Name = "Joe", In = "1/1/08 3:00pm".ToDate(), Out = "1/1/08 8:00pm".ToDate() };
var tl5 = new TempTimeEntry() { ID = 1, Name = "Bill", In = "1/1/08 8:01pm".ToDate(), Out = "1/1/08 8:00pm".ToDate() };
var list = new List<TempTimeEntry>() { tl1, tl2, tl3, tl4, tl5 };
var overlap = GetOverlappedTimes(list, (TempTimeEntry t1)=>t1.ID==1, (TempTimeEntry tIn) => tIn.In, (TempTimeEntry tOut) => tOut.Out);
Console.WriteLine("\nRecords overlap:");
foreach (var tl in overlap)
Console.WriteLine("Name:{0} T1In:{1} T1Out:{2}", tl.Name, tl.In, tl.Out);
Console.WriteLine("Done");
/* Output:
Records overlap:
Name:Joe T1In:1/1/2008 3:00:00 PM T1Out:1/1/2008 8:00:00 PM
Name:Lisa T1In:1/1/2008 7:00:00 PM T1Out:1/1/2008 9:00:00 PM
Done
*/
}
在Microsoft SQL SERVER中-SQL函数
CREATE FUNCTION IsOverlapDates
(
@startDate1 as datetime,
@endDate1 as datetime,
@startDate2 as datetime,
@endDate2 as datetime
)
RETURNS int
AS
BEGIN
DECLARE @Overlap as int
SET @Overlap = (SELECT CASE WHEN (
(@startDate1 BETWEEN @startDate2 AND @endDate2) -- caters for inner and end date outer
OR
(@endDate1 BETWEEN @startDate2 AND @endDate2) -- caters for inner and start date outer
OR
(@startDate2 BETWEEN @startDate1 AND @endDate1) -- only one needed for outer range where dates are inside.
) THEN 1 ELSE 0 END
)
RETURN @Overlap
END
GO
--Execution of the above code
DECLARE @startDate1 as datetime
DECLARE @endDate1 as datetime
DECLARE @startDate2 as datetime
DECLARE @endDate2 as datetime
DECLARE @Overlap as int
SET @startDate1 = '2014-06-01 01:00:00'
SET @endDate1 = '2014-06-01 02:00:00'
SET @startDate2 = '2014-06-01 01:00:00'
SET @endDate2 = '2014-06-01 01:30:00'
SET @Overlap = [dbo].[IsOverlapDates] (@startDate1, @endDate1, @startDate2, @endDate2)
SELECT Overlap = @Overlap
最简单的
最简单的方法是使用精心设计的专用库进行日期时间工作。
someInterval.overlaps( anotherInterval )
java.time&ThreeTen额外
业务中最好的是内置在Java8和更高版本中的java.time框架。添加ThreeTen Extra项目,该项目用额外的类来补充java.time,特别是我们这里需要的Interval类。
至于这个问题上的语言不可知标签,两个项目的源代码都可以在其他语言中使用(注意它们的许可证)。
间隔
org.threeten.extra.Interval类很方便,但需要日期时间瞬间(java.time.Instant对象),而不是仅日期值。因此,我们继续使用UTC中的一天的第一刻来表示日期。
Instant start = Instant.parse( "2016-01-01T00:00:00Z" );
Instant stop = Instant.parse( "2016-02-01T00:00:00Z" );
创建一个间隔来表示该时间跨度。
Interval interval_A = Interval.of( start , stop );
我们也可以用开始时刻加上持续时间来定义间隔。
Instant start_B = Instant.parse( "2016-01-03T00:00:00Z" );
Interval interval_B = Interval.of( start_B , Duration.of( 3 , ChronoUnit.DAYS ) );
比较和测试重叠很容易。
Boolean overlaps = interval_A.overlaps( interval_B );
您可以将“间隔”与另一个“间隔”或“即时”进行比较:
邻接,邻接包含外壳等于在之后是之前重叠,重叠
所有这些都使用半开放的方法来定义一段时间,其中开始是包容性的,结束是排他性的。
这是我的解决方案,当值不重叠时返回真值:
X开始1Y端1
开始2B端2
TEST1: (X <= A || X >= B)
&&
TEST2: (Y >= B || Y <= A)
&&
TEST3: (X >= B || Y <= A)
X-------------Y
A-----B
TEST1: TRUE
TEST2: TRUE
TEST3: FALSE
RESULT: FALSE
---------------------------------------
X---Y
A---B
TEST1: TRUE
TEST2: TRUE
TEST3: TRUE
RESULT: TRUE
---------------------------------------
X---Y
A---B
TEST1: TRUE
TEST2: TRUE
TEST3: TRUE
RESULT: TRUE
---------------------------------------
X----Y
A---------------B
TEST1: FALSE
TEST2: FALSE
TEST3: FALSE
RESULT: FALSE
适合我的紧凑公式
class ValidityRuleRange {
private final Date from;
private final Date to;
...
private boolean isOverlap(ValidityRuleRange vrr) {
int c1 = from.compareTo(vrr.getTo());
int c2 = to.compareTo(vrr.getFrom());
return c1 == 0 || c2 == 0 || c1 + c2 == 0;
}