在c#中是否有一些我没有遇到过的罕见的语言构造(比如我最近学过的一些,一些在Stack Overflow上)来获得表示foreach循环的当前迭代的值?
例如,我目前根据具体情况做这样的事情:
int i = 0;
foreach (Object o in collection)
{
// ...
i++;
}
在c#中是否有一些我没有遇到过的罕见的语言构造(比如我最近学过的一些,一些在Stack Overflow上)来获得表示foreach循环的当前迭代的值?
例如,我目前根据具体情况做这样的事情:
int i = 0;
foreach (Object o in collection)
{
// ...
i++;
}
当前回答
我想更理论化地讨论这个问题(因为它已经有了足够多的实际答案)
.net为数据组(又称集合)提供了一个非常好的抽象模型。
在最顶端,也是最抽象的,你有一个IEnumerable它只是一组你可以枚举的数据。你如何枚举并不重要,重要的是你可以枚举一些数据。这个枚举是由一个完全不同的对象完成的,IEnumerator
这些接口定义如下:
//
// Summary:
// Exposes an enumerator, which supports a simple iteration over a non-generic collection.
public interface IEnumerable
{
//
// Summary:
// Returns an enumerator that iterates through a collection.
//
// Returns:
// An System.Collections.IEnumerator object that can be used to iterate through
// the collection.
IEnumerator GetEnumerator();
}
//
// Summary:
// Supports a simple iteration over a non-generic collection.
public interface IEnumerator
{
//
// Summary:
// Gets the element in the collection at the current position of the enumerator.
//
// Returns:
// The element in the collection at the current position of the enumerator.
object Current { get; }
//
// Summary:
// Advances the enumerator to the next element of the collection.
//
// Returns:
// true if the enumerator was successfully advanced to the next element; false if
// the enumerator has passed the end of the collection.
//
// Exceptions:
// T:System.InvalidOperationException:
// The collection was modified after the enumerator was created.
bool MoveNext();
//
// Summary:
// Sets the enumerator to its initial position, which is before the first element
// in the collection.
//
// Exceptions:
// T:System.InvalidOperationException:
// The collection was modified after the enumerator was created.
void Reset();
}
as you might have noticed, the IEnumerator interface doesn't "know" what an index is, it just knows what element it's currently pointing to, and how to move to the next one. now here is the trick: foreach considers every input collection an IEnumerable, even if it is a more concrete implementation like an IList<T> (which inherits from IEnumerable), it will only see the abstract interface IEnumerable. what foreach is actually doing, is calling GetEnumerator on the collection, and calling MoveNext until it returns false. so here is the problem, you want to define a concrete concept "Indices" on an abstract concept "Enumerables", the built in foreach construct doesn't give you that option, so your only way is to define it yourself, either by what you are doing originally (creating a counter manually) or just use an implementation of IEnumerator that recognizes indices AND implement a foreach construct that recognizes that custom implementation.
就我个人而言,我会创建一个这样的扩展方法
public static class Ext
{
public static void FE<T>(this IEnumerable<T> l, Action<int, T> act)
{
int counter = 0;
foreach (var item in l)
{
act(counter, item);
counter++;
}
}
}
像这样使用它
var x = new List<string>() { "hello", "world" };
x.FE((ind, ele) =>
{
Console.WriteLine($"{ind}: {ele}");
});
这也避免了在其他答案中看到的任何不必要的分配。
其他回答
Ian Mercer在Phil Haack的博客上发表了一个类似的解决方案:
foreach (var item in Model.Select((value, i) => new { i, value }))
{
var value = item.value;
var index = item.i;
}
通过重载LINQ的Select函数,你可以得到item (item.value)和它的索引(item.i):
函数[在Select内部]的第二个参数表示源元素的索引。
新的{i, value}正在创建一个新的匿名对象。
如果你使用c# 7.0或更高版本,可以使用ValueTuple来避免堆分配:
foreach (var item in Model.Select((value, i) => ( value, i )))
{
var value = item.value;
var index = item.i;
}
你也可以删除这个项目。通过使用自动解构:
foreach (var (value, i) in Model.Select((value, i) => ( value, i )))
{
// Access `value` and `i` directly here.
}
它只适用于List而不是任何IEnumerable,但在LINQ中有这样的:
IList<Object> collection = new List<Object> {
new Object(),
new Object(),
new Object(),
};
foreach (Object o in collection)
{
Console.WriteLine(collection.IndexOf(o));
}
Console.ReadLine();
@Jonathan我没有说这是一个很好的答案,我只是说这只是表明,他要求的事情是可以做到的:)
@Graphain我不期望它会很快-我不完全确定它是如何工作的,它可以重复整个列表每次找到一个匹配的对象,这将是一个非常大量的比较。
也就是说,List可能保留每个对象的索引和计数。
乔纳森似乎有更好的主意,能详细说说吗?
不过,最好只是记录一下你在foreach中所做的事情,这样更简单,适应性更强。
这是我刚想到的解决这个问题的办法
原始代码:
int index=0;
foreach (var item in enumerable)
{
blah(item, index); // some code that depends on the index
index++;
}
更新代码
enumerable.ForEach((item, index) => blah(item, index));
扩展方法:
public static IEnumerable<T> ForEach<T>(this IEnumerable<T> enumerable, Action<T, int> action)
{
var unit = new Unit(); // unit is a new type from the reactive framework (http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/devlabs/ee794896.aspx) to represent a void, since in C# you can't return a void
enumerable.Select((item, i) =>
{
action(item, i);
return unit;
}).ToList();
return pSource;
}
最好像这样使用关键字继续安全构造
int i=-1;
foreach (Object o in collection)
{
++i;
//...
continue; //<--- safe to call, index will be increased
//...
}
最后,c# 7有一个不错的语法,用于在foreach循环(即元组)中获取索引:
foreach (var (item, index) in collection.WithIndex())
{
Debug.WriteLine($"{index}: {item}");
}
需要一个小扩展方法:
using System.Collections.Generic;
public static class EnumExtension {
public static IEnumerable<(T item, int index)> WithIndex<T>(this IEnumerable<T> self)
=> self.Select((item, index) => (item, index));
}