今天早上有个帖子问有多少人禁用JavaScript。然后我开始想知道可以使用什么技术来确定用户是否禁用了它。

有人知道一些简单的方法来检测JavaScript是否被禁用吗?我的意图是给一个警告,如果浏览器没有启用JS,站点将无法正常运行。

最终,我想把它们重定向到能够在没有JS的情况下工作的内容,但我需要这个检测作为一个占位符来开始。


当前回答

下面是一个PHP脚本,它可以在生成任何输出之前包含一次。它不是完美的,但在大多数情况下,它工作得足够好,以避免交付客户端不会使用的内容或代码。标题注释解释了它是如何工作的。

<?php
/*****************************************************************************
 * JAVASCRIPT DETECTION                                                      *
 *****************************************************************************/

// Progressive enhancement and graceful degradation are not sufficient if we
// want to avoid sending HTML or JavaScript code that won't be useful on the
// client side.  A normal HTTP request will not include any explicit indicator
// that JavaScript is enabled in the client.  So a "preflight response" is
// needed to prompt the client to provide an indicator in a follow-up request.
// Once the state of JavaScript availability has been received the state of
// data received in the original request must be restored before proceding.
// To the user, this handshake should be as invisible as possible.
// 
// The most convenient place to store the original data is in a PHP session.
// The PHP session extension will try to use a cookie to pass the session ID
// but if cookies are not enabled it will insert it into the query string.
// This violates our preference for invisibility.  When Javascript is not
// enabled the only way to effect a client side redirect is with a "meta"
// element with its "http-equiv" attribute set to "refresh".  In this case
// modifying the URL is the only way to pass the session ID back.
//
// But when cookies are disabled and JavaScript is enabled then a client side
// redirect can be effected by setting the "window.onload" method to a function
// which submits a form.  The form has a "method" attribute of "post" and an
// "action" attribute set to the original URL.  The form contains two hidden
// input elements, one in which the session ID is stored and one in which the
// state of JavaScript availability is stored.  Both values are thereby passed
// back to the server in a POST request while the URL remains unchanged.  The
// follow-up request will be a POST even if the original request was a GET, but
// since the original request data is restored, the containing script ought to
// process the request as though it were a GET.

// In order to ensure that the constant SID is defined as the caller of this
// script would expect, call session_start if it hasn't already been called.
$session = isset($_SESSION);
if (!$session) session_start();

// Use a separate session for Javascript detection.  Save the caller's session
// name and ID.  If this is the followup request then close the caller's
// session and reopen the Javascript detection session.  Otherwise, generate a
// new session ID, close the caller's session and create a new session for
// Javascript detection.
$session_name = session_name();
$session_id = session_id();
session_write_close();
session_name('JS_DETECT');
if (isset($_COOKIE['JS_DETECT'])) {
    session_id($_COOKIE['JS_DETECT']);
} elseif (isset($_REQUEST['JS_DETECT'])) {
    session_id($_REQUEST['JS_DETECT']);
} else {
    session_id(sha1(mt_rand()));
}
session_start();

if (isset($_SESSION['_SERVER'])) {
    // Preflight response already sent.
    // Store the JavaScript availability status in a constant.
    define('JS_ENABLED', 0+$_REQUEST['JS_ENABLED']);
    // Store the cookie availability status in a constant.
    define('COOKIES_ENABLED', isset($_COOKIE['JS_DETECT']));
    // Expire the cookies if they exist.
    setcookie('JS_DETECT', 0, time()-3600);
    setcookie('JS_ENABLED', 0, time()-3600);
    // Restore the original request data.
    $_GET = $_SESSION['_GET'];
    $_POST = $_SESSION['_POST'];
    $_FILES = $_SESSION['_FILES'];
    $_COOKIE = $_SESSION['_COOKIE'];
    $_SERVER = $_SESSION['_SERVER'];
    $_REQUEST = $_SESSION['_REQUEST'];
    // Ensure that uploaded files will be deleted if they are not moved or renamed.
    function unlink_uploaded_files () {
        foreach (array_keys($_FILES) as $k)
            if (file_exists($_FILES[$k]['tmp_name']))
                unlink($_FILES[$k]['tmp_name']);
    }
    register_shutdown_function('unlink_uploaded_files');
    // Reinitialize the superglobal.
    $_SESSION = array();
    // Destroy the Javascript detection session.
    session_destroy();
    // Reopen the caller's session.
    session_name($session_name);
    session_id($session_id);
    if ($session) session_start();
    unset($session, $session_name, $session_id, $tmp_name);
    // Complete the request.
} else {
    // Preflight response not sent so send it.
    // To cover the case where cookies are enabled but JavaScript is disabled,
    // initialize the cookie to indicate that JavaScript is disabled.
    setcookie('JS_ENABLED', 0);
    // Prepare the client side redirect used when JavaScript is disabled.
    $content = '0; url='.$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'];
    if (!$_GET['JS_DETECT']) {
        $content .= empty($_SERVER['QUERY_STRING']) ? '?' : '&';
        $content .= 'JS_DETECT='.session_id();
    }
    // Remove request data which should only be used here.
    unset($_GET['JS_DETECT'],$_GET['JS_ENABLED'],
            $_POST['JS_DETECT'],$_POST['JS_ENABLED'],
            $_COOKIE['JS_DETECT'],$_COOKIE['JS_ENABLED'],
            $_REQUEST['JS_DETECT'],$_REQUEST['JS_ENABLED']);
    // Save all remaining request data in session data.
    $_SESSION['_GET'] = $_GET;
    $_SESSION['_POST'] = $_POST;
    $_SESSION['_FILES'] = $_FILES;
    $_SESSION['_COOKIE'] = $_COOKIE;
    $_SESSION['_SERVER'] = $_SERVER;
    $_SESSION['_REQUEST'] = $_REQUEST;
    // Rename any uploaded files so they won't be deleted by PHP.  When using
    // a clustered web server, upload_tmp_dir must point to shared storage.
    foreach (array_keys($_FILES) as $k) {
        $tmp_name = $_FILES[$k]['tmp_name'].'x';
        if (move_uploaded_file($_FILES[$k]['tmp_name'], $tmp_name))
            $_SESSION['_FILES'][$k]['tmp_name'] = $tmp_name;
    }
// Have the client inform the server as to the status of Javascript.
?>
<!DOCTYPE html>
<html>
<head>
    <script>
        document.cookie = 'JS_ENABLED=1';
// location.reload causes a confirm box in FireFox
//      if (document.cookie) { location.reload(true); }
        if (document.cookie) { location.href = location; }
    </script>
    <meta http-equiv="refresh" content="<?=$content?>" />
</head>
<body>
    <form id="formid" method="post" action="" >
        <input type="hidden" name="<?=$session_name?>" value="<?=$session_id?>" />
        <input type="hidden" name="JS_DETECT" value="<?=session_id()?>" />
        <input type="hidden" name="JS_ENABLED" value="1" />
    </form>
    <script>
        document.getElementById('formid').submit();
    </script>
</body>
</html>
<?php
    exit;
}
?>

其他回答

<noscript>甚至不是必需的,更不用说在XHTML中不受支持了。

工作的例子:

<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Frameset//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-frameset.dtd">
<html>
<head>
    <title>My website</title>
    <style>
      #site {
          display: none;
      }
    </style>
    <script src="http://code.jquery.com/jquery-latest.min.js "></script>
    <script>
      $(document).ready(function() {
          $("#noJS").hide();
          $("#site").show();
      });
    </script>
</head>
<body>
    <div id="noJS">Please enable JavaScript...</div>
    <div id="site">JavaScript dependent content here...</div>
</body>
</html>

在本例中,如果启用了JavaScript,则可以看到站点。如果没有,则会看到“请启用JavaScript”消息。测试JavaScript是否启用的最好方法是简单地尝试和使用JavaScript!如果它工作,它被启用,如果没有,那么它不是…

我想添加我的解决方案,以获得可靠的统计数据,有多少真正的用户访问我的网站与javascript禁用的总用户。每节课只检查一次,有以下好处:

访问100个页面或仅访问1个页面的用户每人算1个。这允许只关注单个用户,而不是页面。 不打破页面流,结构或语义在任何方式 可以记录用户代理的日志。这允许排除机器人统计,如谷歌机器人和bing机器人通常有JS禁用!也可以记录IP,时间等… 每个会话只检查一次(最小的过载)

我的代码使用PHP, mysql和jquery与ajax,但可以适应其他语言:

在你的数据库中创建一个像这样的表:

CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `log_JS` (
  `logJS_id` int(11) NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `data_ins` timestamp NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_TIMESTAMP,
  `session_id` varchar(50) NOT NULL,
  `JS_ON` tinyint(1) NOT NULL DEFAULT '0',
  `agent` varchar(255) DEFAULT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`logJS_id`)
) ENGINE=MyISAM  DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8;

在使用session_start()或等效(jquery必需)后将此添加到每个页面:

<?  if (!isset($_SESSION["JSTest"]))
    { 
        mysql_query("INSERT INTO log_JS (session_id, agent) VALUES ('" . mysql_real_escape_string(session_id()) . "', '" . mysql_real_escape_string($_SERVER['HTTP_USER_AGENT']). "')"); 
        $_SESSION["JSTest"] = 1; // One time per session
        ?>
        <script type="text/javascript">
            $(document).ready(function() { $.get('JSOK.php'); });
        </script>
        <?
    }
?>

像这样创建页面JSOK.php:

<?
include_once("[DB connection file].php");   
mysql_query("UPDATE log_JS SET JS_ON = 1 WHERE session_id = '" . mysql_real_escape_string(session_id()) . "'");

在什么地方发现它?JavaScript ?那是不可能的。如果只是为了记录日志,可以使用某种跟踪方案,其中每个页面都有JavaScript,将对一个特殊资源(可能是一个非常小的gif或类似的文件)发出请求。这样,您就可以获取唯一页面请求和跟踪文件请求之间的差异。

更新2022

这个问题已经有30多个答案,但似乎没有一个答案清楚或准确地说明必须做什么。

服务器端框架使用- ASP。网络核心 客户端-香草js

在BaseController上,也就是应用的第一个入口点OnActionExecutionAsync上,我有这个逻辑。

基本上默认情况下,我假设客户端没有启用javascript并设置此标志。

Response.Cookies.Append("jsEnabled", "false");

现在,在客户端初始加载后,我有一个javascript函数,将这个标志更新为true。 这个函数只有在环境中有javascript时才会运行

完整的解在这里。

客户端

在初始负载上添加此函数

function detectIfJavascriptIsEnabled() {
    // if this function run's which means js is enabled
    var jsEnabled = getCookie('jsEnabled');
    if (jsEnabled === 'false') {
        setCookie('jsEnabled', 'true');
        location.reload();
    }
}

服务器

private bool ValidateIfEnvironmentHasJavascript() {
  if (HttpContext.Request.Cookies != null && HttpContext.Request.Cookies.Count > 0) {
    Boolean.TryParse(HttpContext.Request.Cookies["jsEnabled"], out
      var hasJavascriptEnabled);
    return hasJavascriptEnabled;
  } else {
    Response.Cookies.Append("jsEnabled", "false",
      new CookieOptions() {
        IsEssential = true, Expires = DateTime.UtcNow.AddHours(24)
      });
  }

  return false;
}

这就是得到结果的方法

var environmentHasJavascript = ValidateIfEnvironmentHasJavascript();

为什么需要知道服务器端是否启用了JavaScript ?浏览器支持哪种变体有关系吗?它是否需要理解关键字let或者只是var ?

我建议发送可读的内容,不需要任何JavaScript可访问,然后只是尝试加载JS文件添加所有你想要的JS行为。

For example, the UI might end up missing Login or Modify button if JS is not enabled and it might include a small text at the bottom (using <noscript> or some element with CSS animation that shows the text after a small delay if JS code doesn't remove the whole element soon enough) saying "To login/modify this content, you must enable JavaScript support in your browser." If you do this well, the reader may not even notice that anything is missing unless he or she is trying to login or modify the content.

作为一种优化,你可以用JavaScript设置cookie,如果你想异步获取它,服务器可以避免发送非JavaScript可读的内容。只是要确保在JS代码运行完成至少一次之后才设置这个cookie,而不是在JS代码开始运行时立即设置它,以确保当JS代码由于任何原因失败时(不是如果!)最终用户不会以空白屏幕结束。

(请注意,异步加载初始页面状态不会更快地将内容传递给最终用户。但是,如果没有JavaScript,您只能发送全部内容的一部分。这可以更快地呈现“优先”,然后使用JS代码异步加载页面的其余部分。)

作为一个额外的好处,搜索引擎仍然可以在不启用任何JavaScript的情况下索引您的站点。