我想用Python编写一个函数,根据输入索引的值返回不同的固定值。
在其他语言中,我会使用switch或case语句,但Python似乎没有switch语句。在此场景中,推荐的Python解决方案是什么?
我想用Python编写一个函数,根据输入索引的值返回不同的固定值。
在其他语言中,我会使用switch或case语句,但Python似乎没有switch语句。在此场景中,推荐的Python解决方案是什么?
当前回答
# simple case alternative
some_value = 5.0
# this while loop block simulates a case block
# case
while True:
# case 1
if some_value > 5:
print ('Greater than five')
break
# case 2
if some_value == 5:
print ('Equal to five')
break
# else case 3
print ( 'Must be less than 5')
break
其他回答
Python 3.10(2021)引入了match-case语句,该语句提供了Pythons“switch”的一流实现。例如:
def f(x):
match x:
case 'a':
return 1
case 'b':
return 2
case _:
return 0 # 0 is the default case if x is not found
match-case语句比这个简单的示例强大得多。
以下原始答案写于2008年,当时还未提供匹配案例:
你可以用字典:
def f(x):
return {
'a': 1,
'b': 2,
}[x]
虽然已经有了足够的答案,但我想指出一个更简单、更强大的解决方案:
class Switch:
def __init__(self, switches):
self.switches = switches
self.between = len(switches[0]) == 3
def __call__(self, x):
for line in self.switches:
if self.between:
if line[0] <= x < line[1]:
return line[2]
else:
if line[0] == x:
return line[1]
return None
if __name__ == '__main__':
between_table = [
(1, 4, 'between 1 and 4'),
(4, 8, 'between 4 and 8')
]
switch_between = Switch(between_table)
print('Switch Between:')
for i in range(0, 10):
if switch_between(i):
print('{} is {}'.format(i, switch_between(i)))
else:
print('No match for {}'.format(i))
equals_table = [
(1, 'One'),
(2, 'Two'),
(4, 'Four'),
(5, 'Five'),
(7, 'Seven'),
(8, 'Eight')
]
print('Switch Equals:')
switch_equals = Switch(equals_table)
for i in range(0, 10):
if switch_equals(i):
print('{} is {}'.format(i, switch_equals(i)))
else:
print('No match for {}'.format(i))
输出:
Switch Between:
No match for 0
1 is between 1 and 4
2 is between 1 and 4
3 is between 1 and 4
4 is between 4 and 8
5 is between 4 and 8
6 is between 4 and 8
7 is between 4 and 8
No match for 8
No match for 9
Switch Equals:
No match for 0
1 is One
2 is Two
No match for 3
4 is Four
5 is Five
No match for 6
7 is Seven
8 is Eight
No match for 9
这里的大多数答案都很陈旧,尤其是那些被接受的答案,因此似乎值得更新。
首先,官方的Python常见问题解答涵盖了这一点,并为简单案例推荐elif链,为更大或更复杂的案例推荐dict。它还建议在某些情况下使用一组visit_方法(许多服务器框架使用的样式):
def dispatch(self, value):
method_name = 'visit_' + str(value)
method = getattr(self, method_name)
method()
FAQ还提到了PEP275,它是为了让官方一劳永逸地决定添加C风格切换语句而编写的。但PEP实际上被推迟到了Python 3,它只是作为一个单独的提案PEP3103被正式拒绝。答案当然是否定的,但如果你对原因或历史感兴趣的话,这两位政治公众人物可以获得更多信息。
有一件事多次出现(在PEP 275中可以看到,尽管它是作为实际推荐删除的),那就是如果你真的为处理4种情况而烦恼的是8行代码,而不是C或Bash中的6行代码,你总是可以这样写:
if x == 1: print('first')
elif x == 2: print('second')
elif x == 3: print('third')
else: print('did not place')
这并不是PEP 8所鼓励的,但它是可读的,并不是太单一。
自PEP 3103被拒绝以来的十多年里,C风格的案例陈述,甚至围棋中稍微更强大的版本,都被认为已经过时;每当有人提出python想法或-dev时,他们都会参考旧的决定。
然而,完全ML样式的模式匹配的想法每隔几年就会出现一次,特别是在Swift和Rust等语言采用它之后。问题是,如果没有代数数据类型,很难充分利用模式匹配。虽然圭多一直赞同这个想法,但没有人提出一个非常适合Python的方案。(你可以阅读我2014年的strawman作为一个例子。)这可能会随着3.7中的dataclass和一些零星的建议而改变,比如使用更强大的枚举来处理sum类型,或者使用不同类型的语句本地绑定的各种建议(如PEP3150,或者当前正在讨论的一组建议-ideas)。但到目前为止,它还没有。
偶尔也会有关于Perl 6样式匹配的建议,这基本上是从elif到regex到单分派类型切换的混合。
我最喜欢的是一个非常好的食谱。这是我见过的最接近实际switchcase语句的语句,尤其是在特性中。
class switch(object):
def __init__(self, value):
self.value = value
self.fall = False
def __iter__(self):
"""Return the match method once, then stop"""
yield self.match
raise StopIteration
def match(self, *args):
"""Indicate whether or not to enter a case suite"""
if self.fall or not args:
return True
elif self.value in args: # changed for v1.5, see below
self.fall = True
return True
else:
return False
下面是一个示例:
# The following example is pretty much the exact use-case of a dictionary,
# but is included for its simplicity. Note that you can include statements
# in each suite.
v = 'ten'
for case in switch(v):
if case('one'):
print 1
break
if case('two'):
print 2
break
if case('ten'):
print 10
break
if case('eleven'):
print 11
break
if case(): # default, could also just omit condition or 'if True'
print "something else!"
# No need to break here, it'll stop anyway
# break is used here to look as much like the real thing as possible, but
# elif is generally just as good and more concise.
# Empty suites are considered syntax errors, so intentional fall-throughs
# should contain 'pass'
c = 'z'
for case in switch(c):
if case('a'): pass # only necessary if the rest of the suite is empty
if case('b'): pass
# ...
if case('y'): pass
if case('z'):
print "c is lowercase!"
break
if case('A'): pass
# ...
if case('Z'):
print "c is uppercase!"
break
if case(): # default
print "I dunno what c was!"
# As suggested by Pierre Quentel, you can even expand upon the
# functionality of the classic 'case' statement by matching multiple
# cases in a single shot. This greatly benefits operations such as the
# uppercase/lowercase example above:
import string
c = 'A'
for case in switch(c):
if case(*string.lowercase): # note the * for unpacking as arguments
print "c is lowercase!"
break
if case(*string.uppercase):
print "c is uppercase!"
break
if case('!', '?', '.'): # normal argument passing style also applies
print "c is a sentence terminator!"
break
if case(): # default
print "I dunno what c was!"
一些评论指出,使用foo作为case而不是foo中的case的上下文管理器解决方案可能更干净,对于大型switch语句,线性而不是二次行为可能是一个不错的选择。使用for循环的答案的一部分价值是有中断和突破的能力,如果我们愿意稍微使用我们选择的关键字,我们也可以在上下文管理器中实现这一点:
class Switch:
def __init__(self, value):
self.value = value
self._entered = False
self._broken = False
self._prev = None
def __enter__(self):
return self
def __exit__(self, type, value, traceback):
return False # Allows a traceback to occur
def __call__(self, *values):
if self._broken:
return False
if not self._entered:
if values and self.value not in values:
return False
self._entered, self._prev = True, values
return True
if self._prev is None:
self._prev = values
return True
if self._prev != values:
self._broken = True
return False
if self._prev == values:
self._prev = None
return False
@property
def default(self):
return self()
下面是一个示例:
# Prints 'bar' then 'baz'.
with Switch(2) as case:
while case(0):
print('foo')
while case(1, 2, 3):
print('bar')
while case(4, 5):
print('baz')
break
while case.default:
print('default')
break
除了字典方法(我很喜欢,BTW),您还可以使用if elif else来获得switch/case/default功能:
if x == 'a':
# Do the thing
elif x == 'b':
# Do the other thing
if x in 'bc':
# Fall-through by not using elif, but now the default case includes case 'a'!
elif x in 'xyz':
# Do yet another thing
else:
# Do the default
当然,这与switch/case不同——你不可能像放弃break语句那样轻易地通过,但你可以进行更复杂的测试。它的格式比一系列嵌套的if更好,尽管在功能上更接近。