用@staticmethod修饰的方法和用@classmethod修饰的方法有什么区别?
当前回答
我的贡献展示了@classmethod、@staticmethod和实例方法之间的区别,包括实例如何间接调用@staticmmethod。但是,与其从实例间接调用@staticmethod,不如将其私有化可能更“Python化”。这里没有演示从私有方法获取内容,但基本上是相同的概念。
#!python3
from os import system
system('cls')
# % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % %
class DemoClass(object):
# instance methods need a class instance and
# can access the instance through 'self'
def instance_method_1(self):
return 'called from inside the instance_method_1()'
def instance_method_2(self):
# an instance outside the class indirectly calls the static_method
return self.static_method() + ' via instance_method_2()'
# class methods don't need a class instance, they can't access the
# instance (self) but they have access to the class itself via 'cls'
@classmethod
def class_method(cls):
return 'called from inside the class_method()'
# static methods don't have access to 'cls' or 'self', they work like
# regular functions but belong to the class' namespace
@staticmethod
def static_method():
return 'called from inside the static_method()'
# % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % %
# works even if the class hasn't been instantiated
print(DemoClass.class_method() + '\n')
''' called from inside the class_method() '''
# works even if the class hasn't been instantiated
print(DemoClass.static_method() + '\n')
''' called from inside the static_method() '''
# % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % %
# >>>>> all methods types can be called on a class instance <<<<<
# instantiate the class
democlassObj = DemoClass()
# call instance_method_1()
print(democlassObj.instance_method_1() + '\n')
''' called from inside the instance_method_1() '''
# # indirectly call static_method through instance_method_2(), there's really no use
# for this since a @staticmethod can be called whether the class has been
# instantiated or not
print(democlassObj.instance_method_2() + '\n')
''' called from inside the static_method() via instance_method_2() '''
# call class_method()
print(democlassObj.class_method() + '\n')
''' called from inside the class_method() '''
# call static_method()
print(democlassObj.static_method())
''' called from inside the static_method() '''
"""
# whether the class is instantiated or not, this doesn't work
print(DemoClass.instance_method_1() + '\n')
'''
TypeError: TypeError: unbound method instancemethod() must be called with
DemoClass instance as first argument (got nothing instead)
'''
"""
其他回答
静态方法:
没有自参数的简单函数。处理类属性;而不是实例属性。可以通过类和实例调用。内置函数staticmethod()用于创建它们。
静态方法的优点:
它在类作用域中本地化函数名它将功能代码移动到使用位置附近与模块级函数相比,导入更方便,因为不必专门导入每个方法@静态方法定义some_static_method(*args,**kwds):通过
类方法:
将第一个参数作为类名的函数。可以通过类和实例调用。这些是用内置函数中的classmethod创建的。@分类法定义some_class_method(cls,*args,**kwds):通过
实例方法:
+可以修改对象实例状态
+可以修改类状态
类方法:
-无法修改对象实例状态
+可以修改类状态
静态方法:
-无法修改对象实例状态
-无法修改类状态
class MyClass:
'''
Instance method has a mandatory first attribute self which represent the instance itself.
Instance method must be called by a instantiated instance.
'''
def method(self):
return 'instance method called', self
'''
Class method has a mandatory first attribute cls which represent the class itself.
Class method can be called by an instance or by the class directly.
Its most common using scenario is to define a factory method.
'''
@classmethod
def class_method(cls):
return 'class method called', cls
'''
Static method doesn’t have any attributes of instances or the class.
It also can be called by an instance or by the class directly.
Its most common using scenario is to define some helper or utility functions which are closely relative to the class.
'''
@staticmethod
def static_method():
return 'static method called'
obj = MyClass()
print(obj.method())
print(obj.class_method()) # MyClass.class_method()
print(obj.static_method()) # MyClass.static_method()
输出:
('instance method called', <__main__.MyClass object at 0x100fb3940>)
('class method called', <class '__main__.MyClass'>)
static method called
实例方法实际上可以访问对象实例,所以这是我的类对象的一个实例,而使用类方法,我们可以访问类本身。但不适用于任何对象,因为类方法并不真正关心现有的对象。但是,您可以同时调用对象实例上的类方法和静态方法。这将起作用,但实际上并没有什么不同,所以当你在这里调用静态方法时,它会起作用,它会知道你要调用哪个方法。
静态方法用于执行一些实用程序任务,类方法用于工厂方法。工厂方法可以为不同的用例返回类对象。
最后,举一个简短的例子来更好地理解:
class Student:
def __init__(self, first_name, last_name):
self.first_name = first_name
self.last_name = last_name
@classmethod
def get_from_string(cls, name_string: str):
first_name, last_name = name_string.split()
if Student.validate_name(first_name) and Student.validate_name(last_name):
return cls(first_name, last_name)
else:
print('Invalid Names')
@staticmethod
def validate_name(name):
return len(name) <= 10
stackoverflow_student = Student.get_from_string('Name Surname')
print(stackoverflow_student.first_name) # Name
print(stackoverflow_student.last_name) # Surname
关于staticmethod vs classmethod的另一个考虑是继承。假设你有以下课程:
class Foo(object):
@staticmethod
def bar():
return "In Foo"
然后您需要在子类中重写bar():
class Foo2(Foo):
@staticmethod
def bar():
return "In Foo2"
这是可行的,但请注意,现在子类(Foo2)中的bar()实现不能再利用该类特有的任何特性。例如,假设Foo2有一个名为magic()的方法,您希望在Foo2实现bar()时使用该方法:
class Foo2(Foo):
@staticmethod
def bar():
return "In Foo2"
@staticmethod
def magic():
return "Something useful you'd like to use in bar, but now can't"
这里的解决方法是在bar()中调用Foo2.magic(),但随后您重复自己的操作(如果Foo2的名称发生更改,您必须记住更新bar()方法)。
对我来说,这稍微违反了开放/封闭原则,因为在Foo中做出的决定会影响您重构派生类中的公共代码的能力(即扩展的开放性较低)。如果bar()是一个类方法,我们就可以了:
class Foo(object):
@classmethod
def bar(cls):
return "In Foo"
class Foo2(Foo):
@classmethod
def bar(cls):
return "In Foo2 " + cls.magic()
@classmethod
def magic(cls):
return "MAGIC"
print Foo2().bar()
给出:In Foo2 MAGIC
此外:历史笔记:Guido Van Rossum(Python的创建者)曾将静态方法称为“意外”:https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-ideas/2012-May/014969.html
我们都知道静态方法有多有限。(它们基本上是一个意外——回到Python 2.2时代,当我发明新型类和描述符时,我想实现类方法,但一开始我不理解它们,意外地先实现了静态方法。然后,删除它们,只提供类方法已经太晚了。
也:https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-ideas/2016-July/041189.html
老实说,staticmethod是一个错误——我试图做一些类似Java类方法的事情,但一旦发布,我发现真正需要的是类方法。但要摆脱静态方法为时已晚。
一个非常重要的实际差异发生在子类化时。如果你不介意的话,我会劫持@unsubu的例子:
class A:
def foo(self, x):
print("executing foo(%s, %s)" % (self, x))
@classmethod
def class_foo(cls, x):
print("executing class_foo(%s, %s)" % (cls, x))
@staticmethod
def static_foo(x):
print("executing static_foo(%s)" % x)
class B(A):
pass
在class_foo中,该方法知道它是在哪个类上调用的:
A.class_foo(1)
# => executing class_foo(<class '__main__.A'>, 1)
B.class_foo(1)
# => executing class_foo(<class '__main__.B'>, 1)
在static_foo中,无法确定它是在A还是B上调用的:
A.static_foo(1)
# => executing static_foo(1)
B.static_foo(1)
# => executing static_foo(1)
注意,这并不意味着您不能在静态方法中使用其他方法,您只需直接引用类,这意味着子类的静态方法仍将引用父类:
class A:
@classmethod
def class_qux(cls, x):
print(f"executing class_qux({cls}, {x})")
@classmethod
def class_bar(cls, x):
cls.class_qux(x)
@staticmethod
def static_bar(x):
A.class_qux(x)
class B(A):
pass
A.class_bar(1)
# => executing class_qux(<class '__main__.A'>, 1)
B.class_bar(1)
# => executing class_qux(<class '__main__.B'>, 1)
A.static_bar(1)
# => executing class_qux(<class '__main__.A'>, 1)
B.static_bar(1)
# => executing class_qux(<class '__main__.A'>, 1)
静态方法是一种对所调用的类或实例一无所知的方法。它只获取传递的参数,而不是隐式的第一个参数。它在Python中基本上是无用的——您可以只使用模块函数而不是静态方法。
另一方面,类方法是一种方法,它将被调用的类或被调用的实例的类作为第一个参数传递。当您希望该方法成为类的工厂时,这很有用:因为它获得了作为第一个参数调用的实际类,所以即使涉及子类,您也可以始终实例化正确的类。例如,观察类方法dict.fromkeys()在子类上调用时如何返回子类的实例:
>>> class DictSubclass(dict):
... def __repr__(self):
... return "DictSubclass"
...
>>> dict.fromkeys("abc")
{'a': None, 'c': None, 'b': None}
>>> DictSubclass.fromkeys("abc")
DictSubclass
>>>
推荐文章
- 证书验证失败:无法获得本地颁发者证书
- 当使用pip3安装包时,“Python中的ssl模块不可用”
- 无法切换Python与pyenv
- Python if not == vs if !=
- 如何从scikit-learn决策树中提取决策规则?
- 为什么在Mac OS X v10.9 (Mavericks)的终端中apt-get功能不起作用?
- 将旋转的xtick标签与各自的xtick对齐
- 为什么元组可以包含可变项?
- 如何合并字典的字典?
- 如何创建类属性?
- 不区分大小写的“in”
- 在Python中获取迭代器中的元素个数
- 解析日期字符串并更改格式
- 使用try和。Python中的if
- 如何在Python中获得所有直接子目录