在HTML中,表格不应该用于布局,这似乎是普遍的观点。

Why?

我从来没有(老实说,很少)看到过支持这一点的有力论据。通常的答案是:

It's good to separate content from layoutBut this is a fallacious argument; Cliche Thinking. I guess it's true that using the table element for layout has little to do with tabular data. So what? Does my boss care? Do my users care?Perhaps me or my fellow developers who have to maintain a web page care... Is a table less maintainable? I think using a table is easier than using divs and CSS.By the way... why is using a div or a span good separation of content from layout and a table not? Getting a good layout with only divs often requires a lot of nested divs. Readability of the codeI think it's the other way around. Most people understand HTML, few understand CSS. It's better for SEO not to use tablesWhy? Can anybody show some evidence that it is? Or a statement from Google that tables are discouraged from an SEO perspective? Tables are slower.An extra tbody element has to be inserted. This is peanuts for modern web browsers. Show me some benchmarks where the use of a table significantly slows down a page. A layout overhaul is easier without tables, see css Zen Garden.Most web sites that need an upgrade need new content (HTML) as well. Scenarios where a new version of a web site only needs a new CSS file are not very likely. Zen Garden is a nice web site, but a bit theoretical. Not to mention its misuse of CSS.

我对使用divs + CSS而不是表的良好参数非常感兴趣。


当前回答

使用表格布局的工具可能会因为创建布局所需的大量代码而变得异常沉重。SAP的Netweaver Portal默认使用TABLE来布局页面。

在我目前的工作中,生产SAP门户有一个主页,它的HTML超过60K,有7个表那么深,在页面中有3次。再加上Javascript,误用了16个iframe,其中有类似的表格问题,CSS过重等,页面重量超过5MB。

花点时间降低页面重量,这样你就可以利用带宽与用户进行互动,这是值得的。

其他回答

一般来说,表并不比CSS更容易或更易于维护。然而,在一些特定的布局问题中,表确实是最简单和最灵活的解决方案。

在表示标记和CSS支持相同类型的设计的情况下,CSS显然是更可取的,没有人会认为字体标记比在CSS中指定排版更好,因为CSS提供了与字体标记相同的功能,但以一种更干净的方式。

The issue with tables, however, is basically that the table-layout model in CSS is not supported in Microsoft Internet Explorer. Tables and CSS are therefore not equivalent in power. The missing part is the grid-like behavior of tables, where the edges of cells align both vertically and horizontally, while cells still expand to contain their content. This behavior is not easy to achieve in pure CSS without hardcoding some dimensions, which makes the design rigid and brittle (as long as we have to support Internet Explorer - in other browsers this is easliy achieved by using display:table-cell).

因此,这并不是一个表或CSS更可取的问题,而是一个认识到使用表可以使布局更灵活的具体情况的问题。

不使用表的最重要原因是可访问性。Web内容可访问性指南http://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG10/建议不要使用表格进行布局。如果您担心可访问性(在某些情况下,您可能有法律义务这样做),即使表更简单,也应该使用CSS。请注意,您总是可以用CSS创建与表相同的布局,这可能只是需要更多的工作。

我相信这是一个与普遍问题有关的问题。HTML诞生时,没有人能预见到它的广泛应用。另一项在自身成功的重压下几乎崩溃的技术。当HTML页面用vi在绿色文本终端上编写时,向页面访问者显示数据所需要的只是一个TABLE,而且大多数数据都是以表格形式显示的。

我们都知道事物是如何进化的。相对来说,table最近已经过时了,但是有很多理由更喜欢基于div和CSS的布局(可访问性不是最后一个)。当然我不能写一个CSS来拯救我的生命:-),我认为图形设计专家应该总是在手边。

也就是说……即使在现代网站中,也有许多数据应该在表格中显示。

使用表格布局的工具可能会因为创建布局所需的大量代码而变得异常沉重。SAP的Netweaver Portal默认使用TABLE来布局页面。

在我目前的工作中,生产SAP门户有一个主页,它的HTML超过60K,有7个表那么深,在页面中有3次。再加上Javascript,误用了16个iframe,其中有类似的表格问题,CSS过重等,页面重量超过5MB。

花点时间降低页面重量,这样你就可以利用带宽与用户进行互动,这是值得的。

Google gives very low priority to text content contained inside a table. I was giving some SEO advice to a local charity. In examining their website it was using tables to layout the site. Looking at each page, no matter what words - or combination of words - from their pages I used in the Google search box the pages would not come up in any of the top search pages. (However, by specifying the site in the search the page was returned.) One page was well copy written by normal standards to produce a good result in a search but still it didn't appear in any of the first pages of search results returned. (Note this text was within a table.) I then spotted a section of text on the pages which was in a div rather than a table. We put a few of the words from that div in the search engine. Result? It came in at No.2 in the search result.

Flex有一个标签,用于在垂直列中布局内容。说实话,我不认为他们在布局/内容方面做得很好,但至少他们已经解决了这个问题。

像许多对CSS感到沮丧的人一样,我也到处寻找一个简单的答案,当我以为我找到了它时,我感到兴奋,然后当我在Chrome中打开页面时,我的希望破灭了。我肯定没有足够的技能说这是不可能的,但我还没有看到任何人提供样本代码供同行评审,明确地证明它可以可靠地完成。

那么,这个岛的CSS方面有人能推荐一种布局垂直列的心态/方法吗?我尝试过在第二行和第三行绝对定位,但我最终与到处重叠的东西和浮动有类似的问题,如果页面缩小。

如果这个问题有答案,我会欣喜若狂地做正确的事情——只要告诉我一些像“嘿,你试过**流:垂直|水平”这样的事情,我就完全不烦你了。