我最近一直在尝试使用Docker构建一些服务,有一件事一直困扰着我,那就是把密码放在Dockerfile中。我是一名开发人员,所以在源代码中存储密码感觉就像在脸上打了一拳。这值得担心吗?Dockerfiles中有什么好的处理密码的约定吗?


当前回答

在Docker v1.9中,你可以使用ARG指令在构建操作时获取通过命令行传递给映像的参数。只需使用——build-arg标志。因此,您可以避免在Dockerfile中保留显式密码(或其他敏感信息),并随时传递它们。

来源:https://docs.docker.com/engine/reference/commandline/build/ http://docs.docker.com/engine/reference/builder/#arg

例子:

Dockerfile

FROM busybox
ARG user
RUN echo "user is $user"

生成映像命令

docker build --build-arg user=capuccino -t test_arguments -f path/to/dockerfile .

在构建过程中打印

$ docker build --build-arg user=capuccino -t test_arguments -f ./test_args.Dockerfile .

Sending build context to Docker daemon 2.048 kB
Step 1 : FROM busybox
 ---> c51f86c28340
Step 2 : ARG user
 ---> Running in 43a4aa0e421d
 ---> f0359070fc8f
Removing intermediate container 43a4aa0e421d
Step 3 : RUN echo "user is $user"
 ---> Running in 4360fb10d46a
**user is capuccino**
 ---> 1408147c1cb9
Removing intermediate container 4360fb10d46a
Successfully built 1408147c1cb9

希望能有所帮助!再见。

其他回答

我想,如果它是bash shell,像这样简单的东西就可以工作。

读取-sp "db_password:" password | docker run -itd——name <container_name>——build-arg mysql_db_password=$db_password alpine /bin/bash

只需默读它,并在Docker映像中作为参数传递。你需要在Dockerfile中接受变量作为ARG。

从版本20.10开始,除了使用secret-file,您还可以直接使用env提供秘密。

Buildkit: secrets:允许提供秘密与env moby/moby#41234 docker/cli#2656 moby/ Buildkit #1534 支持——secret id=foo,env=MY_ENV作为将秘密值存储到文件的替代方案。 ——secret id=GIT_AUTH_TOKEN将加载env,如果它存在,而文件不存在。

秘密文件:

THIS IS SECRET

Dockerfile:

# syntax = docker/dockerfile:1.3
FROM python:3.8-slim-buster
COPY build-script.sh .
RUN --mount=type=secret,id=mysecret ./build-script.sh

build-script.sh:

cat /run/secrets/mysecret

执行:

$ export MYSECRET=theverysecretpassword
$ export DOCKER_BUILDKIT=1
$ docker build --progress=plain --secret id=mysecret,env=MYSECRET -t abc:1 . --no-cache
......
#9 [stage-0 3/3] RUN --mount=type=secret,id=mysecret ./build-script.sh
#9 sha256:e32137e3eeb0fe2e4b515862f4cd6df4b73019567ae0f49eb5896a10e3f7c94e
#9 0.931 theverysecretpassword#9 DONE 1.5s
......

Docker现在(版本1.13或17.06或更高)支持管理秘密信息。下面是概述和更详细的文档

kubernetes和DCOS也存在类似的特征

永远不要向容器添加凭据,除非您可以将凭据广播给任何可以下载映像的人。特别是,执行并添加creds并随后运行rm creds是不安全的,因为creds文件仍然保存在中间文件系统层的最终映像中。任何能接触到图像的人都能很容易地提取出来。

The typical solution I've seen when you need creds to checkout dependencies and such is to use one container to build another. I.e., typically you have some build environment in your base container and you need to invoke that to build your app container. So the simple solution is to add your app source and then RUN the build commands. This is insecure if you need creds in that RUN. Instead what you do is put your source into a local directory, run (as in docker run) the container to perform the build step with the local source directory mounted as volume and the creds either injected or mounted as another volume. Once the build step is complete you build your final container by simply ADDing the local source directory which now contains the built artifacts.

我希望Docker添加一些功能来简化这一切!

Update: looks like the method going forward will be to have nested builds. In short, the dockerfile would describe a first container that is used to build the run-time environment and then a second nested container build that can assemble all the pieces into the final container. This way the build-time stuff isn't in the second container. This of a Java app where you need the JDK for building the app but only the JRE for running it. There are a number of proposals being discussed, best to start from https://github.com/docker/docker/issues/7115 and follow some of the links for alternate proposals.

While I totally agree there is no simple solution. There continues to be a single point of failure. Either the dockerfile, etcd, and so on. Apcera has a plan that looks like sidekick - dual authentication. In other words two container cannot talk unless there is a Apcera configuration rule. In their demo the uid/pwd was in the clear and could not be reused until the admin configured the linkage. For this to work, however, it probably meant patching Docker or at least the network plugin (if there is such a thing).