例如,您为用户/9运行一个GET请求,但没有id为#9的用户。 哪个是最佳响应码?

200好了 202年接受 204无内容 400错误请求 404未找到


当前回答

204号更合适。特别是当你有一个警报系统来确保你的网站是安全的,404在这种情况下会引起混乱,因为你不知道一些404警报是后端错误或正常的请求,但响应为空。

其他回答

根据微软:控制器动作返回类型在ASP。NET Core web API,向下滚动几乎到底部,你会发现下面关于404的简介,与数据库中没有的对象有关。在这里,他们建议404适用于空数据。

Twitter使用404,并带有类似“找不到数据”的自定义错误消息。

裁判:https://developer.twitter.com/en/docs/basics/response-codes.html

如果期望资源存在,但它可能是空的,我认为它可能更容易得到一个200 OK的表示,表明这个东西是空的。

因此,我宁愿让/things返回一个带有{"Items":[]}的200 OK,而不是一个没有任何内容的204,因为这样,一个包含0项的集合可以被视为一个包含一个或多个项目的集合。

我将把204 No Content留给put和delete,在这种情况下,可能真的没有有用的表示。

在/thing/9不存在的情况下,404是合适的。

根据RFC7231 -第59页(https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc7231#page-59) 404状态码响应的定义是:

6.5.4. 404 Not Found The 404 (Not Found) status code indicates that the origin server did not find a current representation for the target resource or is not willing to disclose that one exists. A 404 status code does not indicate whether this lack of representation is temporary or permanent; the 410 (Gone) status code is preferred over 404 if the origin server knows, presumably through some configurable means, that the condition is likely to be permanent. A 404 response is cacheable by default; i.e., unless otherwise indicated by the method definition or explicit cache controls (see Section 4.2.2 of [RFC7234]).

而引起质疑的主要是上述语境中对资源的定义。 根据同一个RFC(7231), resource的定义是:

Resources: The target of an HTTP request is called a "resource". HTTP does not limit the nature of a resource; it merely defines an interface that might be used to interact with resources. Each resource is identified by a Uniform Resource Identifier (URI), as described in Section 2.7 of [RFC7230]. When a client constructs an HTTP/1.1 request message, it sends the target URI in one of various forms, as defined in (Section 5.3 of [RFC7230]). When a request is received, the server reconstructs an effective request URI for the target resource (Section 5.5 of [RFC7230]). One design goal of HTTP is to separate resource identification from request semantics, which is made possible by vesting the request semantics in the request method (Section 4) and a few request-modifying header fields (Section 5). If there is a conflict between the method semantics and any semantic implied by the URI itself, as described in Section 4.2.1, the method semantics take precedence.

所以在我的理解中,404状态代码不应该用于成功的GET请求,结果为空。(例如:一个没有特定过滤器结果的列表)

TL;DR:使用404

请看这个博客。这解释得很好。

博客对204的评论总结如下:

204 No Content作为浏览器的响应代码并不是特别有用(尽管根据HTTP规范,浏览器需要将其理解为“不要更改视图”的响应代码)。 然而,No Content对于ajax web服务非常有用,它可能想要表示成功而不需要返回任何东西。(特别是在DELETE或post这样不需要反馈的情况下)。

因此,您的问题的答案是在您的情况下使用404。204是一个专门的响应代码,您不应该经常将其返回给浏览器以响应GET。

其他响应代码甚至比204和404更不合适:

200 should be returned with the body of whatever you successfully fetched. Not appropriate when the entity you're fetching doesn't exist. 202 is used when the server has begun work on an object but the object isn't fully ready yet. Certainly not the case here. You haven't begun, nor will you begin, construction of user 9 in response to a GET request. That breaks all sorts of rules. 400 is used in response to a poorly formatted HTTP request (for instance malformed http headers, incorrectly ordered segments, etc). This will almost certainly be handled by whatever framework you're using. You shouldn't have to deal with this unless you're writing your own server from scratch. Edit: Newer RFCs now allow for 400 to be used for semantically invalid requests.

维基百科对HTTP状态码的描述尤其有用。 您也可以在www.w3.org上看到HTTP/1.1 RFC2616文档中的定义