Java中内部类和静态嵌套类的主要区别是什么?设计/实现是否在选择其中一个方面发挥作用?


当前回答

我认为这里没有什么要补充的,大多数答案完美地解释了静态嵌套类和内部类之间的区别。但是,当使用嵌套类与内部类时,请考虑以下问题。正如在两个答案中提到的,如果没有封闭类的实例,内部类就无法实例化,这意味着它们持有指向封闭类实例的指针,这可能导致内存溢出或堆栈溢出异常,因为即使不再使用封闭类,GC也无法对其进行垃圾收集。要明确这一点,请检查以下代码:

public class Outer {


    public  class Inner {

    }


    public Inner inner(){
        return new Inner();
    }

    @Override
    protected void finalize() throws Throwable {
    // as you know finalize is called by the garbage collector due to destroying an object instance
        System.out.println("I am destroyed !");
    }
}


public static void main(String arg[]) {

    Outer outer = new Outer();
    Outer.Inner inner = outer.new Inner();

    // out instance is no more used and should be garbage collected !!!
    // However this will not happen as inner instance is still alive i.e used, not null !
    // and outer will be kept in memory until inner is destroyed
    outer = null;

    //
    // inner = null;

    //kick out garbage collector
    System.gc();

}

如果删除//inner=null;该计划将付诸实施“我被摧毁了!”,但保持评论不会。原因是白色内部实例仍然被引用,GC无法收集它,并且因为它引用(具有指向)外部实例,所以它也没有被收集。项目中有足够的这些对象,可能会耗尽内存。与静态内部类相比,静态内部类不指向内部类实例,因为它与实例无关,而是与类相关。如果将Inner类设置为静态并使用Outer.Inner I=newOuter.Innr()实例化,则上述程序可以打印“我被摧毁了!”;

其他回答

嵌套静态类的使用有一个微妙之处,这在某些情况下可能很有用。

尽管静态属性在类通过其构造函数实例化之前被实例化,嵌套静态类内部的静态属性似乎在类的构造函数被调用,或者至少直到属性被首次引用之后,即使它们被标记为“最终”。

考虑以下示例:

public class C0 {

    static C0 instance = null;

    // Uncomment the following line and a null pointer exception will be
    // generated before anything gets printed.
    //public static final String outerItem = instance.makeString(98.6);

    public C0() {
        instance = this;
    }

    public String makeString(int i) {
        return ((new Integer(i)).toString());
    }

    public String makeString(double d) {
        return ((new Double(d)).toString());
    }

    public static final class nested {
        public static final String innerItem = instance.makeString(42);
    }

    static public void main(String[] argv) {
        System.out.println("start");
        // Comment out this line and a null pointer exception will be
        // generated after "start" prints and before the following
        // try/catch block even gets entered.
        new C0();
        try {
            System.out.println("retrieve item: " + nested.innerItem);
        }
        catch (Exception e) {
            System.out.println("failed to retrieve item: " + e.toString());
        }
        System.out.println("finish");
    }
}

即使“nested”和“innerItem”都声明为“static final”。设置nested.innerItem的值在类实例化后才会发生(或至少直到第一次引用嵌套的静态项之后),正如您自己所看到的通过注释和取消注释上面提到的行。这一点不成立对于“outerItem”为true。

至少这是我在Java6.0中看到的。

我已经说明了java代码中可能出现的各种可能的正确和错误场景。

    class Outter1 {

        String OutStr;

        Outter1(String str) {
            OutStr = str;
        }

        public void NonStaticMethod(String st)  {

            String temp1 = "ashish";
            final String  tempFinal1 = "ashish"; 

            //  below static attribute not permitted
            // static String tempStatic1 = "static";    

            //  below static with final attribute not permitted         
            // static final String  tempStatic1 = "ashish";  

            // synchronized keyword is not permitted below          
            class localInnerNonStatic1 {            

                synchronized    public void innerMethod(String str11) {
                    str11 = temp1 +" sharma";
                    System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
                }

                /* 
        //  static method with final not permitted
          public static void innerStaticMethod(String str11) { 

                    str11 = temp1 +" india";
                    System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
                }*/
            }

            // static class not permitted below
            //  static class localInnerStatic1 {   }                            

        }

        public static  void StaticMethod(String st)     {

            String temp1 = "ashish";
            final String  tempFinal1 = "ashish"; 

            // static attribute not permitted below
            //static String tempStatic1 = "static";     

            //  static with final attribute not permitted below
            // static final String  tempStatic1 = "ashish";                         

            class localInnerNonStatic1 {
                public void innerMethod(String str11) {
                    str11 = temp1 +" sharma";
                    System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
                }

                /*
    // static method with final not permitted
    public static void innerStaticMethod(String str11) {  
                    str11 = temp1 +" india";
                    System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
                }*/
            }

            // static class not permitted below
            //  static class localInnerStatic1 {   }    

        }

        // synchronized keyword is not permitted
        static  class inner1 {          

            static String  temp1 = "ashish";
            String  tempNonStatic = "ashish";
            // class localInner1 {

            public void innerMethod(String str11) {
                str11 = temp1 +" sharma";
                str11 = str11+ tempNonStatic +" sharma";
                System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
            }

            public static void innerStaticMethod(String str11) {
                //  error in below step
                str11 = temp1 +" india";    
                //str11 = str11+ tempNonStatic +" sharma";
                System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
            }
            //}
        }

        //synchronized keyword is not permitted below
        class innerNonStatic1 {             

//This is important we have to keep final with static modifier in non
// static innerclass below
            static final String  temp1 = "ashish";  
            String  tempNonStatic = "ashish";
            // class localInner1 {

            synchronized    public void innerMethod(String str11) {
                tempNonStatic = tempNonStatic +" ...";
                str11 = temp1 +" sharma";
                str11 = str11+ tempNonStatic +" sharma";
                System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
            }

            /*
            //  error in below step
            public static void innerStaticMethod(String str11) {   
                            //  error in below step
                            // str11 = tempNonStatic +" india";                     
                            str11 = temp1 +" india";
                            System.out.println("innerMethod ===> "+str11);
                        }*/
                    //}
                }
    }

我认为上面的答案都没有向您解释嵌套类和静态嵌套类在应用程序设计方面的真正区别:

概述

嵌套类可以是非静态的或静态的,并且在每种情况下都是在另一个类中定义的类。嵌套类应该只存在于服务于封闭类,如果嵌套类对其他类(不仅仅是封闭类)有用,则应该声明为顶级类。

差别

非静态嵌套类:与包含类的封闭实例隐式关联,这意味着可以调用封闭实例的方法和访问变量。非静态嵌套类的一个常见用法是定义Adapter类。

静态嵌套类:无法访问封闭类实例并在其上调用方法,因此当嵌套类不需要访问封闭类的实例时应使用。静态嵌套类的一个常见用法是实现外部对象的组件。

结论

所以从设计角度来看,两者之间的主要区别是:非静态嵌套类可以访问容器类的实例,而静态类不能。

嵌套类的另一个用例,除了已经提到的那些用例之外,是当嵌套类具有只能从外部类访问的方法时。这是可能的,因为外部类可以访问嵌套类的私有构造函数、字段和方法。

在下面的示例中,银行可以发行具有私有构造函数的Bank.CreditCard,并可以使用Bank.credit card的私有setLimit(…)实例方法根据当前银行策略更改信用卡的限额。从任何其他类只能访问Bank.CreditCard的公共方法。

public class Bank {

    // maximum limit as per current bank policy
    // is subject to change
    private int maxLimit = 7000;

    // ------- PUBLIC METHODS ---------

    public CreditCard issueCard(
            final String firstName,
            final String lastName
    ) {
        final String number = this.generateNumber();
        final int expiryDate = this.generateExpiryDate();
        final int CVV = this.generateCVV();
        return new CreditCard(firstName, lastName, number, expiryDate, CVV);
    }


    public boolean setLimit(
            final CreditCard creditCard,
            final int limit
    ) {
        if (limit <= this.maxLimit) {    // check against current bank policy limit
            creditCard.setLimit(limit);  // access private method Bank.CreditCard.setLimit(int)
            return true;
        }
        return false;
    }

    // ------- PRIVATE METHODS ---------

    private String generateNumber() {
        return "1234-5678-9101-1123";   // the numbers should be unique for each card
    }


    private int generateExpiryDate() {
        return 202405;                  // date is YYYY=2024, MM=05
    }


    private int generateCVV() {
        return 123;                     // is in real-life less predictable
    }


    // ------- PUBLIC STATIC NESTED CLASS ---------

    public static final class CreditCard {
        private final String firstName;
        private final String lastName;
        private final String number;
        private final int expiryDate;
        private final int CVV;

        private int balance;
        private int limit = 100; // default limit

        // the constructor is final but is accessible from outer class
        private CreditCard(
                final String firstName,
                final String lastName,
                final String number,
                final int expiryDate,
                final int CVV
        ) {
            this.firstName = firstName;
            this.lastName = lastName;
            this.number = number;
            this.expiryDate = expiryDate;
            this.CVV = CVV;
        }

        // ------- PUBLIC METHODS ---------

        public String getFirstName() {
            return this.firstName;
        }

        public String getLastName() {
            return this.lastName;
        }

        public String getNumber() {
            return this.number;
        }

        public int getExpiryDate() {
            return this.expiryDate;
        }

        // returns true if financial transaction is successful
        // otherwise false
        public boolean charge(final int amount) {
            final int newBalance = this.balance - amount;
            if (newBalance < -this.limit) {
                return false;
            }
            this.balance = newBalance;
            return true;
        }

        // ------- PRIVATE METHODS ---------

        private int getCVV() {
            return this.CVV;
        }

        private int getBalance() {
            return this.balance;
        }

        private void setBalance(final int balance) {
            this.balance = balance;
        }

        private int getLimit() {
            return limit;
        }

        private void setLimit(final int limit) {
            this.limit = limit;
        }
    }
}

我认为在上述答案中,真正的区别并不明显。

首先要正确使用条款:

嵌套类是包含在源代码级别的另一个类中的类。如果使用static修饰符声明它,则它是静态的。非静态嵌套类称为内部类。(我使用非静态嵌套类。)

到目前为止,马丁的回答是正确的。然而,实际的问题是:声明一个嵌套类静态或不静态的目的是什么?

如果您只想将类保持在一起(如果它们在主题上属于一起),或者如果嵌套类只在封闭类中使用,则可以使用静态嵌套类。静态嵌套类和其他类之间没有语义差异。

非静态嵌套类是另一种野兽。与匿名内部类类似,此类嵌套类实际上是闭包。这意味着它们捕获其周围范围和封闭实例,并使其可访问。也许一个例子可以说明这一点。查看容器的存根:

public class Container {
    public class Item{
        Object data;
        public Container getContainer(){
            return Container.this;
        }
        public Item(Object data) {
            super();
            this.data = data;
        }

    }

    public static Item create(Object data){
        // does not compile since no instance of Container is available
        return new Item(data);
    }
    public Item createSubItem(Object data){
        // compiles, since 'this' Container is available
        return new Item(data);
    }
}

在这种情况下,您希望具有从子项到父容器的引用。使用非静态嵌套类,这可以在不做任何工作的情况下工作。您可以使用语法Container.this访问容器的封闭实例。

更多核心解释如下:

如果您查看编译器为(非静态)嵌套类生成的Java字节码,可能会更清楚:

// class version 49.0 (49)
// access flags 33
public class Container$Item {

  // compiled from: Container.java
  // access flags 1
  public INNERCLASS Container$Item Container Item

  // access flags 0
  Object data

  // access flags 4112
  final Container this$0

  // access flags 1
  public getContainer() : Container
   L0
    LINENUMBER 7 L0
    ALOAD 0: this
    GETFIELD Container$Item.this$0 : Container
    ARETURN
   L1
    LOCALVARIABLE this Container$Item L0 L1 0
    MAXSTACK = 1
    MAXLOCALS = 1

  // access flags 1
  public <init>(Container,Object) : void
   L0
    LINENUMBER 12 L0
    ALOAD 0: this
    ALOAD 1
    PUTFIELD Container$Item.this$0 : Container
   L1
    LINENUMBER 10 L1
    ALOAD 0: this
    INVOKESPECIAL Object.<init>() : void
   L2
    LINENUMBER 11 L2
    ALOAD 0: this
    ALOAD 2: data
    PUTFIELD Container$Item.data : Object
    RETURN
   L3
    LOCALVARIABLE this Container$Item L0 L3 0
    LOCALVARIABLE data Object L0 L3 2
    MAXSTACK = 2
    MAXLOCALS = 3
}

如您所见,编译器创建了一个隐藏字段Container this$0。这是在构造函数中设置的,该构造函数有一个Container类型的附加参数,用于指定封闭实例。在源代码中看不到该参数,但编译器为嵌套类隐式生成该参数。

马丁的例子

OuterClass.InnerClass innerObject = outerObject.new InnerClass();

将被编译为类似(字节码)的调用

new InnerClass(outerObject)

为完整起见:

匿名类是一个非静态嵌套类的完美例子,它只是没有与之关联的名称,以后无法引用。